Recently, Donovan McNabb sat down for an interview with James Brown
and made some controversial comments. Basically, what he said was that
African-American Quarterbacks have to do a "little extra" because of
their skin color.
Well, there's one position where I think the minority has to do a lot extra because of their skin color.
White running backs, nearly extinct in the upper echelon of
football, face strong opposition from the earliest stages and a
strongly held belief that they simply can't play the position. All that
may be about to change...
A Little History
Shortly before the NFL draft this season I wrote a little piece about this phenomenon. It was titled "Position Available: White's Need Not Apply" and focused on the story of a prospective white running back named Brian Leonard.
Over the course of the article I discussed the anomalous game of Brock Forsey against the Cardinals and the questions that followed (including, "Is it surprising you came out and had a great game and you're white?").
I also talked about how, according to Tony Dungy,
white's are discouraged from a young age from pursuing the "skill
positions" (RB, WR, CB) and funneled into more appropriate positions.
Finally, I concluded that Brian Leonard, despite his size, skills,
stats, speed, and toughness, would face a strong current against him
because of his race. I don't think it can be denied that to be a white
running back you have to be truly special.
During my research I was very discouraged about his chances. Most
sites agreed that he should be shifted to full-back despite running a
4.49 40 (Reggie Bush ran 4.38, Adrian Peterson ran 4.40, and Marshawn Lynch
ran 4.46) and stating he preferred to be a running back. I thought he
would surely be drafted as a full-back, if at all, and never get a real
shot in the NFL; all because he was white.
Current Events
But that all changed today. I recalled that he had been drafted by the Rams
in the second round but also that he had been drafted as a full-back.
Besides, no matter how good he was I seriously doubted he could
supplant Steven Jackson. Then Steven Jackson went and got hurt.
Now, the Rams are likely to elevate their number two running back
into the starting slot. And that number two running back is, of course,
Brian Leonard.
This development is stunning and quite unbelievable. I honestly
didn't know how to react when I learned that Brian Leonard would likely
start this Sunday at running back. I thought it was a joke or a dream
maybe even a Pepsi-induced
hallucination. But, nay, it appears the Rams are seriously preparing to
launch us into a brave new era in the NFL; an era in which franchise
black quarterbacks are handing the ball off to elite white running
backs.
Great White Hope
Now, Leonard's not going to have an easy task this Sunday. He's
going up against the number 8 rush defense in the league and a team
that is sitting atop the NFC. The Cowboys are sure to key on struggling QB Marc Bulger and will be looking to improve to 4-0.
Brian Leonard will face a determined defense Sunday and a group of
guys determined not to let a white running back do well against them.
We have yet to really see if he's capable of doing the things he did in
college in the NFL. And I'm not sure Leonard has had enough experience
to be truly prepared for Sunday and I don't think he's going to set the
world on fire, at least not yet.
But he has brought his "Leonard Leap" to the NFL in the preseason:
I'm really torn this Sunday. On the one hand, I'd love
to see Leonard do really well this Sunday just to put a monkey wrench
in people's perceptions. On the other hand, the Rams are playing the
Cowboys and I, therefore, would love to see them completely crushed.
But even if Leonard isn't successful this Sunday I
think there is still one up and coming running back who could give
white people everywhere reason for hope:
Conclusion
Are we going to see this stereotype torn down before
our eyes on Sunday? I seriously doubt it. I think we'll see Leonard
struggle in his first start against a pretty good run defense but his
struggles will not be because he's white.
Will we see a day when both Brian Leonard and Sam McGuffie
are starting in the NFL? Will we see a day when white running backs are
as prosperous as they once were (post-integration I mean)? I don't
know. But be sure and tune in on Sunday because even if we don't see
those barriers torn down, we're going to see a little crack form in
them, and then it's only a matter of time.
Forget the fact that it's now afternoon. I think a good name for this column (which I plan to make weekly) is the The Morning After, just has a nice ring to it.
Last night the Dallas Cowboys defeated the Chicago Bears
in what many considered to be a potential NFC Championship preview.
Afterwards, the Bears were left wondering who exactly they are and how
much longer Coach Smith will stand behind Rex Grossman.
Meanwhile, the Cowboys offense came alive in the second half and Tony Romo demonstrated a poise that many critics felt he didn't have. Terrell Owens lit up the Bears and Jason Witten continued to be one of the toughest Tight End's in the league. Finally, Marion Barber III showed he deserves to be the Cowboys number one running back and punished the Bears defense.
First Half
This game was really a story of two halves, with the first half being a defense slug fest.
Before the game there was a lot of talk about how the Cowboys were going to kick away from Devin Hester. To me, it sounded like a good strategy, and the Cowboys employed it early; the opening kickoff sailed out of bounds.
Then the Bears defense came on during the Cowboys' first series.
They sacked Tony Romo and the quarterback struggled early. It looked as
if Romo's critics were right and that his image was bloated by facing
weak opponents. The scariest defense in the league had finally brought
the young "gunslinger" back to earth.
By half time, the score was 3-3 and neither team's offense was
clicking. Both quarterbacks had been intercepted without throwing a
touchdown and the Cowboys had only 18-yards of rushing offense.
Then in the second half, the Cowboy came alive and put up the most
points on the Bears since 2004. And the Bears have to be thinking it's
finally time to take the crown off of Grossman and hand it over to Griese.
Nothing Special
The first key to the Cowboys victory was limiting Devin Hester. They
changed their strategy and began actually kicking to the phenomenal
returner. But the coverage was near perfect and Hester was frustrated.
He muffed one kick and was striped on another. He had to fair catch
a couple and did nothing of note all game. The Cowboys punter, Mat McBriar, used a special kind of kick to maximize hand time and allow his coverage team to get down the field.
Nick Folk also helped matters by getting some good hang time and booming his kickoffs to within the 5.
Pay the Man
Tony
Romo is the real deal. It's time the Cowboys pay him and lock him up
long term. He showed tremendous poise and recognition. He dodged a
great defense and picked it apart. There's no question now as to what
kind of a quarterback he is.
Tony Romo sparkled against a great defense and inspired hope in the
offense. And he did so while still missing his number-two wide
receiver, Terry Glenn. If he keeps this up he'll be headed back to another Pro Bowl and maybe the Cowboys will be headed to the Super Bowl.
Rex Grossman
Rex is not the Bears quarterback. He's terrible. Enough is enough. He's so bad he makes Roy Williams
look good in coverage. It's time for the Bears to accept that he simply
isn't he answer and hand the reins over to Brian Griese.
The Bears can maybe groom Kyle Orton
but they've definitely got to give up on Rex Grossman. The Bears should
see if they can pull a Cleveland and see if they can't trade Grossman
for a late pick. I mean, if Seattle would take Frye there's got to be a team that will take Grossman.
Marion Barber III
This guy is a stud. A complete contrast to either of the other two major running backs in this game (Cedric Benson and Julius Jones).
Barber doesn't have the break away speed of an elite running back. What
he does have is toughness and intensity and that makes up for it.
He will push the pile every time and he doesn't bounce backwards.
Barber smashed up the Bears in the late parts of the game and broke off
a 54-yard run when just trying to run out the clock. He also swatted Adam Archuleta aside for another TD.
Meanwhile, Cedric Benson continues to make the Bears look foolish for trading away Thomas Jones. Benson had a total of 46 yards on 16 attempts (2.9 yards a carry with a long of 12 yards).
Granted the Cowboys are fairly good team against the run, a number
one running back should still put up better numbers than that.
Especially on a team with Rex Grossman under center. Trading Jones now
looks like an even greater mistake than it did when the trade went down.
Cowboys Defense
Anthony Spencer, the Cowboys first round pick, got his first sack. DeMarcus Ware got two sacks. Anthony Henry got two interceptions. This defense is starting to click.
Terence Newman
returned after missing the first two games, and while he didn't have
much impact today, his presence will help as the season continues.
While the defense played against an anemic offense, and the
secondary still struggled. However, each week the Cowboys' defense has
been doing the little things better. They seem to be getting more
comfortable in this new scheme and their play making is up.
If they continue to develop and improve they could do some damage once Newman is back to full strength and Ellis
finally returns. If those two come back near 100% then they could
catapult this defense towards the top and give the Cowboys a truly
great team.
Conclusion
This game was really a game of contrasts. Tony Romo shined while Rex
Grossman faded. Marion Barber hit the Bears' D in the mouth while
Cedric Benson was quiet. Terrel Owens dominated while Muhsin Muhammad is still wondering why he left Carolina.
The Cowboys demonstrated they are one of the best teams in the NFC
(if not the best) and showed maybe those Super Bowl prognosticators
aren't crazy. Meanwhile, the loss of confidence was evident all over
the Bears' faces. Even the defense surrendered in this game and you
knew no one in that locker room believes in Rex Grossman anymore (maybe
not even Grossman himself). If the Bears don't start Griese next week,
then Smith should be fired immediately.
In the end, what should've been a close game turned into a blow out. And the Cowboys showed how unpredictable the NFC still is.
Note:
Donovan McNabb (21/26, 381 yards, 4 TD's, 0 Int's), Kevin Curtis (11 Recs, 221 yards, 3 TD's). What a difference a week makes. McNabb looked good against the Lions
and so did Curtis, and put to rest all this "controversy" from the past
week. And my favorite part of this whole thing is that he did it with a
white wide receiver.
First, let me say this is in no way a shot at
SouthernCheeseHead or her post. In fact, I think it's a well written
post and a good point. It just got me thinking about this whole "America's Team" thing and how much I like applying it to my Dallas Cowboys.
But I've always wondered why the Cowboys adopted the title. I mean, they didn't coin it. It was coined for them after they lost Super Bowl XIII to the Steelers.
I think part of the reason it was coined was because the Steelers were
the dominant team of that decade. They were the dynasty and we all know
how much people hate dynasties. The Cowboys seemed like the only true
and consistent challenger to the Steelers dominance so, I feel, that's
part of the reason they were so embraced.
So, I began to do a little research and theorizing on why exactly
the Cowboys are called "America's Team" and I've stumbled upon some
interesting results.
In the Beginning
Way back in 1960 when the Dallas Cowboys were being born there was one man loathe to allow them into the league. His name was George Preston Marshall and he was the owner of the Washington Redskins.
He opposed the move because up to that point the Redskins were the
only team representing the southern United States. They were "Dixie's
Team." This monopoly was something Marshall was not in a hurry to
relinquish and he had been key to stopping Lamar Hunt's
initiative to start a team in Dallas the previous year. Then the claim
was the NFL couldn't afford to "oversaturate" the market and that
suited Marshall just fine.
However, two men by the names of Clint Murchison Jr. and Bedford Wynne saw his opposition coming. In a sly move they purchased the right to the Redskins' fight song "Hail to the Redskins."
The song epitomized the Redskins' status as "Dixie's Team" and was a
critical marketing tool for Marshall. When Murchison and Wynne
threatened to stop allowing him to use it Marshall caved and voted for
expansion.
1960 and Onward
After they were started, the Cowboys quickly sought ways to maximize their exposure. And they had to.
The Redskins had entrenched themselves since the 30's as the team of
the South and that loyalty would be hard to shake off. Also, the
Cowboys were in a city with another pro football team. After Hunt's NFL
proposal was shot down he founded a whole new league, called the AFL, and started a team in Dallas (called the Texans).
The Texans did better than the Cowboys during those early seasons
so the Cowboys had to find other interesting ways to gain attention.
Beginning in 1966 the Dallas Cowboys began hosting a game every Thanksgiving Day,
making sure a nation wide audience saw them. This allowed them to gain
exposure in regions that didn't have NFL team's and helped tremendously
in their effort to gain popularity.
Besides that exposure (which was shared by the Detroit Lions)
the Cowboys were also extremely successful. Beginning in 1966 the
Cowboys had a record 20 consecutive winning seasons. Their "Doomsday
Defense" was feared throughout the league and their high powered
offense, lead by scrambler Roger Staubach, made them exciting to watch.
Tex Schramm had been hired as the Cowboys President and General Manager and had helped shape the team. He was responsible for hiring coach Tom Landry and negotiating the deal to televise the Cowboys annual on Thanksgiving Day. Another innovation was his creation of the Dallas Cowboys' Cheerleaders.
Cheerleaders were common in the league, but in the 1970's Schramm
changed everything. He had a squad of attractive, athletic women train
to be a professional squad (at the time most groups were formed from
local highschoolers) to combine sex appeal and intense choreography.
This drew nationwide attention and garnered the DCC many television appearances. They went to South Korea with the USO and later began publishing their annual swimsuit calendar.
The squad even inspired a pornographic movie in the era of Deep Throat, called Debbie Does Dallas,
which only helped add to their popularity. All these factors drew
attention to the squad and, by extension, the Dallas Cowboys.
"America's Team"
The term America's Team has been used for a lot of teams. But not quite embraced it like the Dallas Cowboys have.
After their 1978 loss to the Steelers, NFL Films was putting
together a highlight video of the Dallas Cowboys season. They wanted a
unique handle and had noticed that anywhere the Cowboys went, a large
crowd of supporters was sure to be. For whatever reason, they saw this
as somewhat of a novelty and so called the Cowboys "America's Team."
The following season, against the objection of Tom Landry, the team
began using it for themselves and the rest is history. I believe Tex
Schramm had something to do with the embracing of this title since he
knew it was a great marketing ploy.
America's Team is catchy and was another tool in Schramm's arsenal.
It contrasted the old claims of the Redskins as "Dixie's Team" and
allowed the Cowboys to separate themselves from regional loyalty (as
dumb as it might sound, it probably made it easier for non-Texans to
swallow being fans of the Cowboys).
Conclusion
Do I think there is still an America's Team? No, no I don't. The Packers have always been at least as, if not more, popular as the Cowboys. Same for the Steelers and sometimes even teams like the Raiders and Bears.
But the Cowboys have embraced it and used it as a brilliant tool in
their marketing team. No matter who you are and what your feelings may
be when you hear "America's Team" you instantly picture that blue star
and think of the Dallas Cowboys.
The Cowboys have done a good job of making themselves one of the
most loved and hated teams in the league. No matter who you are, you
have an opinion about them. They are one of the most popular team's in
the country, and maybe even the world, and every American pays
attention to them.
The term has nothing to due with popularity just with marketing and
for that reason they have been and always will be "America's Team."
Last Sunday the Dallas Cowboys defeated the Miami Dolphins 37-20. In the Fourth Quarter Tony Romo hooked up with Terrell Owens
for a touchdown. The wide receiver quickly dashed around the goal post,
lifted the ball to his face, and briefly mimed filming the Dolphins'
sideline.
Afterwards, the referees threw the flag and penalized the Cowboys 15-yards. Wade Phillips visibly disapproved of Owens' actions and so did the league, fining him $7,500 yesterday.
This is just ridiculous. Terrell Owens did an excellent satire of
the biggest story in sports. All Owens did was bring a little levity to
the whole situation and hopefully help us move on from this scandal.
Owens' celebration was awesome and I think he showed he is a very
cerebral player.
What was even better was his response to the fine and the NFL
stating that he violated their rule of using the ball as a prop. He
said he, "misinterpreted the rule." Brilliant! I hope T.O. keeps having
fun with his celebrations and keeps his sense of humor. After all, it
is just a game.
The Bad
The Juice
is back in jail again. How can a man be so dumb? He knows there are
plenty of people out to get him and yet he still does this. While it
seems like he was set up, he still had to barge into the hotel room and
threaten those within.
Simpson has been a train wreck ever since he allegedly killed his
ex-wife and fled from cops lo those many years ago. He moved to Florida
to keep the Goldman family from getting his pension and his house but
he just bounced from one disaster to the next.
Of course, the latest nightmare was his authoring a book
about how he "hypothetically" would've killed his ex-wife and Ron
Goldman that night. He said he wrote it for the money, but would
somebody still searching for the "real" killer do such a thing?
Now, O.J.'s in jail in Las Vegas
and facing a potential life sentence. Regardless of his guilt or
innocence I am shocked by his stupidity. If I had come within a knife's
edge of a murder conviction I wouldn't be caught within 2 miles of a
deadly weapon. I mean, if you hang out with guys with guns in a public
place, bad things are going to happen.
While it seems like he's been set up I really have no sympathy for
him. If he wasn't smart enough to avoid these situations, especially
considering his past, then I don't know if he should be allowed back
into society. O.J., if you get away with this, start living in a commune or something and stay far, far away from any of your old friends.
The Ugly
Isiah Thomas'
comments were just plain ugly. Why? Because they're tinged with racism.
Saying that certain people can only say certain words based on the
color of their skin is ludicrous (however true it may be).
Especially when it's a word like "bitch." I would think that no
woman would appreciate being called a bitch by anybody, regardless of
race. But Isiah disagrees. In his humble opinion, a black man can feel
free to call a black woman a bitch while a white man may not. Why? Not
because the word itself is offensive but because is offensive but
because of the color of their skin.
I don't know if it's just me, but why are we still talking in racial
terms? I mean, why do we just accept that we're so different because of
our skin? Why not just get past this and say there is no distinction between white and black men calling a black woman a bitch, in either case it's just wrong.
Isiah Thomas is dead wrong on this one. Certain offensive words
aren't acceptable simply because of skin color. And until we stop
believing they are then we'll never go any farther than we've already
come.
I guess I would be remiss if I did an NFL post and didn't comment on this whole Patriots' spying situation.
First of all, to all those who say things like, "it doesn't really
give them an advantage" or "everybody else is doing" just please stop
talking. If it didn't give them an advantage they wouldn't bother doing
it (especially since it's illegal) and we know the Patriots did it we simply strongly believe
other teams do, that's a huge difference. Just because a lot of people
drive drunk doesn't mean you don't punish the people you catch.
The Patriots seem to have amassed an extensive library of tapes on
nearly every defense coordinator in the league. The theory is that
Belichick compiled video files in case these defensive coordinators
joined their division. Whether this is true or not remains to be seen.
The theory that they were taping the Jets defensive signals to use
later in the game I think is unrealistic. The time it would take to
process those signals and mesh them with game tape so you know what
those signals lead to would be immense. The Patriots were taping those
signals to give them an idea of what the Jets would do later in the
season, at the least, and in the playoffs, at the best.
The punishment doled out was also unfair. The League should have
suspended Belichick from the Patriots' playoff run. Not only keeping
him off the sidelines but barring him from any contact with the
Patriots during the playoff run, including the Super Bowl. If, by some
miracle, they didn't make the playoffs this year, then they should've
suspended him for all of next season (including the playoffs if the
Patriots make it next year).
That way Belichick and this crop of Patriots would've been punished
not the guys who come on board in the next couple seasons. Also, it
would've taken away Belichick when he would be most important to the
team and rob him from the experience of winning another Super Bowl with
his team (and I understand he's already done it three times, but that
would hurt).
Something
a little closer to home. I think this is a great move. Granted he won't
come in until Week 9 but that's when the Cowboys will be looking for
some fresh legs. They should be in the thick of things then and Tank
Johnson could give the defense a needed boost.
Is he a risk? Absolutely, but they signed a very short term contract
so that they can basically rent him this season. If he continues on his
development and doesn't cause problems he could be a real asset for the
Cowboys. If he doesn't, then they just cut him and experience a minor
cap hit. When he aren't desperate is precisely the time to take a
gamble and that's exactly what the Cowboys are doing.
They had to do this, absolutely had to. Joey Harrington was doing
poorly, beyond poorly, and the Falcons need something to get excited
about. Leftwich is a solid contributor and I think will help the
Falcons to actually win a couple of games this season.
Not only will he help with their on field issues he'll also help
with their image in the local community. Byron Leftwich is black, in
case you didn't know, and the Falcons have a huge black fan base that
felt alienated by the whole Michael Vick situation. If you don't
believe me, maybe you'll believe the Nation of Islam blog on sports.
But another black QB says Leftwich will face more criticism from the media simply because of the color of his skin...
McNabb stated that because he's black the media picks out his faults
even when he's successful. While that may be true, I think it has more
to do with his struggles of late and his frustration with his abilities
being called into question.
One can't help but question the Eagles as a whole, and Donovan
McNabb by extension, when you consider that this upcoming weekend the
undefeated Detroit Lions will march into Philadelphia to face the
winless Eagles.
McNabb may have a point but coming from him it sounds like sour
grapes. When he was going to Pro Bowl after Pro Bowl and leading the
Eagles to the NFC Championship every year there was Hall-of-Fame talk,
now that he's struggling he's facing the criticism that any other QB
would.
So, Simpson finally did something stupid enough that the authorities
could arrest him and throw him away for a long time. Apparently,
Simpson was pissed that somebody else was selling his merchandise and
recruited some buddies to take it back.
They broke into a hotel room, allegedly, with guns drawn to forcible
seize material Simpson claimed belonged to him. Somehow, the website
TMZ.com acquired a tape of the incident and the recording doesn't cast O.J in a good light.
The case against Simpson appears pretty solid (at this early stage) but
judging by the look on his face he's not too worried. Also, the
previous case that appeared pretty solid against him failed miserably.
Maybe Simpson will get off again and escape prison. But something tells
me the authorities will do everything they can to nail Simpson.
Conclusion
Well, that's about it. It doesn't cover everything that happened
this week in the NFL but these are the stories that caught my eye. If
something else caught your eye leave some and let me know about
anything you agree/disagree with. Peace.