The year 2005 is one that University of Michigan Head Football Coach Lloyd Carr cannot soon enough forget.
In a year that was defined by close calls, missed opportunities and just plain bad luck, the Wolverines struggled to find any semblance of consistency. Interestingly enough, it all began on the year's very first day.
The '05 Rose Bowl may be looked back upon by unbiased on-lookers as a classic battle with a dramatic finish, but to those who proudly don the Maize and Blue, the Michigan/Texas barnburner will be forever viewed as the beginning of a heartbreaking trend.
The Wolverines led the Longhorns by ten (31-21) heading into the fourth quarter, and although Vince Young was running roughshod over the Michigan defense, the offense was moving the ball and scoring at will, making victory appear inevitable. But in a strange and untimely twist of fate, the Wolverines' touchdown drives suddenly turned into field goals and allowed the Longhorns to come back and eventually win it 38-37 on the game's final play.
Still, despite a disappointing ending to an otherwise successful season, Lloyd Carr had to feel good about his team's chances of returning to Pasadena in '05. Sure, he lost his biggest playmaker on offense in Braylon Edwards, but he was returning several other key contributors on both sides of the ball, including QB Chad Henne and RB Mike Hart.
The optimism that Coach Carr and Michigan fans held was shared by several writers and college football experts. The Wolverines entered the '05 season ranked #3 in the pre-season polls and were a trendy pick to finish atop the Big Ten standings. However, after week one (a 33-18 victory over N. Illinois) the optimism that fans once had quickly turned into concern as the Wolverines lost two vital offensive contributors to injuries.
Senior TE Tim Massaquoi suffered a broken hand and sophomore WR Adrian Arrington was lost for the season with an ankle injury. Massaquoi would eventually return to the lineup a couple weeks later but with his right hand enveloped in a cast, his pass-catching abilities were severely hampered.
Nevertheless, Michigan went into week two with revenge on their minds against rival Notre Dame and their new Head Coach, Charlie Weis. But instead of revenge, the Wolverines received a tangible tail-kicking from the hungry and intense Irish defense. In the process, they lost their swift-footed tailback Mike Hart to a hamstring pull that would sideline him for the next two weeks.
Notwithstanding, Michigan still had an opportunity to win the game and improve to 2-0. Trailing by a touchdown and facing a fourth and goal on the one yard line late in the fourth quarter, Chad Henne appeared to sneak into the end zone for the game-tying score. The only problem was the sophomore QB didn't have the ball. The Irish recovered the fumble and went on to upset Michigan 17-10.
The winged-helmet warriors rebounded the following week with a 55-0 drubbing of Eastern Michigan and entered the Big Ten season with the same high hopes they had prior to the Notre Dame loss. However, Coach Carr and the boys knew that getting a road win at Wisconsin to start off the journey to another Big Ten title would be no easy task.
Michigan dominated the first half against the Badgers on both sides of the ball. However, they failed to pull away and knock Wisconsin out of the contest when they had the chance. In the second half, Wisconsin RB Brian Calhoun finally found some daylight and the Wolverine offense stumbled. And with less than a minute left, QB John Stocco took it in himself from six yards out to lift Wisconsin to a come-from-behind 23-20 win.
The loss left Lloyd Carr searching for answers. His offense was struggling to find a consistent rhythm and his defense, while stout at times, had problems tackling and stopping the opposing team in crucial situations. On top of all that, injuries were continuing to mount.
After a spectacular 34-31 overtime win at Michigan State the following week, Michigan welcomed Minnesota into the Big House for Homecoming in the battle for the Little Brown Jug, a trophy the Wolverines have held since 1986. The Golden Gophers came in reeling, having been buried a week earlier by Penn State, 44-14.
After Steve Breaston took the opening kickoff of the second half back for a touchdown, it seemed that Minnesota's spirit would be broken once again. Unfortunately for the maize and blue contingent, Michigan's offense continued to sputter and the tired defense allowed Minnesota's running game to take off, and eventually, take over. On a key third and ten play from deep in Minnesota territory, Gary Russell took a pitch and raced 68 yards down the sideline to set up the Golden Gophers for a game-winning field goal that transformed what was defined as a disappointing start into an improbable tailspin for the mighty Wolverines. What was even worse, undefeated Penn State was on their way to Ann Arbor the next week to clean up the scraps.
Unbelievably, the 3-3 and downtrodden Michigan football team picked themselves up and pulled off one of their most incredible victories in recent memory. With one second left on the clock and staring down the barrel of the program's first losing season in nearly 40 years, Chad Henne found freshman Mario Manningham on a crossing pattern in the end zone on the game's final play to knock off the Nittany Lions 27-25. The win not only ended Penn State's BCS championship dreams, it literally saved Michigan's season.
The Wolverines responded with three more victories, including an overtime road win at Iowa, and were set up for their annual end-of-the-season slugfest against arch-rival Ohio State in the Big House.
The four game winning streak that Michigan went on wasn't without dyar consequences though. Mike Hart suffered a sprained ankle early in the Iowa game and once again, the Wolverines were without a healthy starting running back.
In spite of everything, Michigan entered Ohio State week with a chance to right several wrongs, and in the process, put themselves in position to play in yet another New Year's Day bowl game. But once again, the fourth quarter bug-a-boos came to surface and the Wolverines found themselves on the losing end of college football's greatest rivalry for the fourth time in five years.
Leading 21-12 with nine minutes to go, Ohio State QB Troy Smith led the Buckeyes right down the field against the Michigan defense, hooking up with Santonio Holmes on a 26 yard TD pass to pull OSU within two. Still, Michigan had an opportunity to lump together a few first downs and run out the clock. Instead, they gave the football right back to the red-hot Buckeye offense who promptly scored again with 24 seconds to go, giving them a 25-21 victory and a berth in the BCS, and leaving Michigan to ponder what could have been.
After finishing the regular season a disheartening 7-4, the Wolverines were selected to compete in the Alamo Bowl against Nebraska on December 28th, marking the first time in nine years that they wouldn't be playing their bowl game on January 1st.
The game itself was entertaining, but the results were more of the same for Michigan. After taking a 28-17 lead early in the fourth, the Wolverines defense put the clamps on the Nebraska passing game and gave their offense a chance to ice the game. However, the Wolverines failed in their attempts and after a big punt return, the Huskers scored the next touchdown and subsequent 2-point conversion to pull within three midway through the final stanza. Michigan then turned it over on their next two possessions and Nebraska went ahead to stay with less than five minutes to play.
To add to Coach Carr's frustrations, the game was not without its share of controversy. After prematurely blowing the whistle on an obvious fumble during the game's opening drive, the officials (from the Sun Belt Conference, which considering the participants, was incomprehensible on its own) set a tone that bordered on complete incompetence. Not once, but twice during the second half, Carr was forced to waste timeouts in order for the hesitant replay official to review a questionable play. As it turned out, one of those plays was a touchdown that was rightfully reversed.
In addition, the officials missed a pass interference call near the goal line on fourth down that would've given the Wolverines a first and goal and four more chances to punch it in for the go-ahead score. Instead, the mysterious no-call gave the football back to the Cornhuskers with Michigan devoid of any timeouts and thus, helpless to stop the clock.
But despite the horrid officiating, the Michigan Wolverines had no one to blame but themselves in the end. Just like they had no one else to blame for much of the bad karma that they constantly ran into throughout the year. If they had simply made the plays when they were most needed, the entire scope of the season would've been different.
In spite of all the close calls, missed opportunities and bad luck that the 2005 Michigan Wolverines encountered, there is reason for optimism heading into '06. They return several important pieces to the puzzle next season including their two best players on offense (Henne and Hart) and two of their best on defense (LaMarr Woodley and Prescott Burgess).
A return to prominence won't be easy though due to a grueling schedule. Michigan will have to play several difficult road games in 2006 including at Notre Dame, at Penn State, and at Ohio State. But when you consider that three of their four regular season losses came at home this year, maybe going on the road isn't such a bad thing.
So breathe easy Coach Carr, your nightmare season is finally over and now it's time to start building on a new dream for Michigan football.
However, if the same visions like poor tackling and the inability to finish games appear in the new dream for 2006, the nightmare for you may have only just begun.