A recent post by 1steelerfan1 got me thinking. We sports fans sit and talk about which players are overlooked by the Hall of Fame all the time. What about players who are in the Hall of Fame but don't deserve to be there? There plenty of examples.
In baseball there are so many it's not even funny. Several selections from Frankie Frisch's tenure as chairman of the Veterans Committee are questionable to say the least. For those of you who don't know what I'm talking about, check out some of the Hall of Famers who played with Frisch on the New York Giants and St. Louis Cardinals. Most of them have no business being there. Many people believe that players such as George Kelly, Ross Youngs, Chick Hafey and Jesse Haines only got elected because they were Frisch's old teammates, and I think they're right. Click on the links to see the stats of each of those guys I mentioned. While they were all decent players, none had an outstanding career that made him worthy of the Hall of Fame. There are plenty more examples in baseball, but discussing each one here would take too much time.
In basketball, there's one clear name in the Hall of Fame that shouldn't be there: Bill Bradley. Sure, he had a great collegiate career at Princeton, but in the pros he was nothing more than a good player. His career numbers include 12.4 PPG, 3.2 RPG, and 3.4 APG. According to Wilt Chamberlain's book A View From Above (which is a great read), he believed Bill Bradley got into the Hall (on the first ballot no less) because the voters thought having a U.S. Senator as a member would bring more prestige to the organization itself. Clearly it was a case of politics coming into play.
As for football, these seem to be some of the most hotly debated in sports. Some people might say that a certain player doesn't deserve to be in while others would think it blasphemous to suggest anything else. There are some players whose numbers don't suggest to me that they're Hall of Famers, but there's always someone out there who can make a case for them. I'll try to avoid being too controversial here, but I will say that if Lynn Swann should be in the Hall of Fame, so should Art Monk.
I don't follow hockey very closely, so I'm not qualified to give an opinion on the issue. Feel free to discuss it here though.
Anyway, those are a few of my opinions. Who are some players you don't think were worthy of immortality in their chosen sports?
Send Message
Add Friend
All Star










