The NHL off season is well underway and many teams have made many
personnel changes to bolster their rosters. I am going to go through
and grade each team on the moves they made so without further ado...
Atlantic Division Pittsburgh Penguins The
Pens coming off of a Stanley Cup finals appearance didn't have a large
amount of money to spend but they had a lot of players to sign.
Obviously they were going to lose some in the shuffle; their biggest
losses came in the form of losing Marian Hossa. Hossa signed on with
the Red Wings so in turn the Penguins have nothing left from their
blockbuster deadline deal for Hossa. They really risked a lot of future
to win now and it didn't quite pay off. Another key loss for the Pens
came from losing Ryan Malone and Gary Roberts heading to Tampa, of the
best depth players they have.
The Penguins added the likes of
Miro Satan and Ruslan Fedotenko, but those 2 can not replace Hossa,
Malone and Roberts, not by a long shot. Another bright point for the
Penguins off season was resigning Evgeni Malkin and Marc-Andre Fleury
to a long term deals which will solidify the core of their team for the
next 5-6 years. Overall this off season the Penguins are getting a
B- from me because their losses in the roster far outweigh the
additions, but the resigning of Malkin and Fleury are huge. I can't
believe I wrote the whole column on the Pens and didn't mention Crosby
once, oh #### there goes that hope.
New York Rangers The
Rangers got a lot better in the offseason through trades and free
agency. I don't think the loss of Jagr will hurt the Rangers as it
seems he was just a cancer in the dressing room anyways. The addition
of Wade Redden is big for this club, but they well overpaid for a
player who is gradually getting worse. Redden and Rosival will be
sufficient for this team on the back end as long as Henrik Lundqvist
plays to his potential. Adding Marcus Naslund was a nice move my the
Rangers as well, I really think he just needed a change of scenery from
out West to get his game going again.
The big splash that really
improved the Rangers was trading for Nikolai Zheredev and Dan Fritsche.
Zheredev seemed to come into his own last season and started to
separate himself from being just a regular player to a offensive
threat. Fritsche is still young but will have a nice career in the NHL.
It seemed the Rangers had to give up very little to Fedor Tyutin and
Christian Backman to get these 2 forwards, you can tell Columbus was
desparate for D-men on this deal.
The Rangers will be a solid
team next season, their biggest worry as always is going to be
consistency and chemistry. On paper they should have no problems
scoring, but when you put a bunch of individual players that play for
themselves on one team it typically spells disaster. For their
offseason moves I give the Rangers an A-. They look like a deadly team
that's going to be a force...at least on paper.
New York Islanders What
a terrible, terrible team this is going to be. I am sorry to any
Islanders fans but you can not get excited when you look at this
roster. After trading down in the draft several times, the Isles really
missed out on getting Luke Schenn. The Islanders only notable pick-up
in the offseason has been Mark Streit, a great power play defencemen,
who can be a potential liability on D. He is versatile as he plays both
wing and defence, but he alone certainly can not save this team.
The
one bright spot for this team is seeing players like Jeff Tambelleni
and Kyle Okposo develop and become talents in the league as they both
have the potential to do that. The Isles are getting a C for their
off season moves, an improvement on the blue line will help, but they
need more then that......maybe they need John Tavares?
New Jersey Devils The
Devils threw some cash around this off-season, most notably signing
Bobby Holik and Brian Rolston. They kept Bryce Salvador on the blue
line after acquiring him at last years trade deadline and he should
help out back there. Unfortunately, this team is lacking a lot of
defence (but so is everyone) but I will never count out the defensive
abilities of a team that has Martin Brodeur in net, no matter how old
he's getting. Not to mention the traditional style of a New Jersey team
is to play the "trap", and they can sure do it well.
They should
make up for a lack of star power on the back end with the likes of
Rolston, Elias, Gionta and Parise to name a few. New Jersey has always
been a solid team over the past years, and I don't see any difference
come this year.
The Devils get a B for their off season
acquisitions, they lost nobody notable, and signed a great goal scorer
in Brian Rolston who was one of the top forward UFAs this off-season.
Philadelphia Flyers This
off-season they didn't make any staggering moves to sign players, but
they didn't have to (and didn't really have the cap space for it
either). They got the most important guy to them signed in Jeff Carter.
They also shed the contract of R.J. Umberger who was an RFA this
season; as much as that is a loss to Philly you can't expect R.J. to
play like he did last playoffs all season long. This is a team with a
very bright future and has many up-and-comers who can jump into
Umbergers old spot.
The Flyers will be a good team once again,
and the issue as always with them is at the back end. The goaltending
is nothing to brag over. Biron had an amazing playoffs but how long
will that continue in this season? The other issue with the Flyers is
on defence, aside from Kimmo Timonen, there isn't much to brag over.
Braydon Coburn and newly acquired Steve Eminger will have to have big
years.
The Flyers get a B- for this off-seasons work. They did
what they had to do under the CBA and managed to get Carter signed on
for 3 more seasons.
Final Grades: Penguins B- Rangers A- Islanders C Devils B Flyers B-
Overall
the Atlantic division should be a competitive one next season as each
team with the exception of the Islanders could very easily make the
playoffs. Next time I will have the Northeast division and we will look
at the moves Montreal, Toronto, Ottawa, Buffalo and Boston made and see
how they made out this off-season.
Im surprised you gave the Rangers anywhere near an A. Redden is a 2nd defensive pairing guy who is rapidly declining (did you watch him vs the penguins in the playoffs?). And paying him top notch money long term is completely foolish. I really don't see him making the team any better. Picking up Nasland was a good move for them but it seems to me that he is going to be nothing more than a good roster filler and wont put up more than 50 points like many people expect.
The Islanders I agree are just awful. They let two of thier best offensive players (on a team lacking offense) go sign to the offensive power house in the league (and their division)
The penguins did very well in my opinion this offseason. Yes they lost Hossa who will hurt short term but will probably keep the core penguins together because it frees up so much cap room. Malone gone is going to hurt but he is replacable and not worth nearly what he got in tampa (i am a huge malone fan btw but he isnt THAT good)
I have a big problem with the pens rating, because yeah they lost hossa but the statement that they have nothing left from the blockbuster trade is completley false they still have pascal dupis who was playing excellent hockey with the pens. As well i don't think that they mortgaged nearly as much of the future in that trde as he suggested because they lost a center (which they have like 10 of) who was barely performing(except in shootouts) and a winger who is easily replaced by a guy in juniors by th name of luca caputi (51gls-60assists in 54 games). As well, roberts was a very small loss considering he barely played last season and when he did (barring game 1 of the playoffs) he was vitrually ineffective. So really their only losses are hossa and malone (who had numbers that weren't too different from fedotenko's until he started playing with Malkin.
Rangers grading is too high. Redden will never play up to the expectation of that huge contract, and Naslund's ability is beginning to fade. It seems that the Rangers are just gathering a bunch of players together and seeing what they come up with it as far as a line up goes - when they should have taken a selective approach to evaluated available players on the market to see how they would fit into the Rangers system and scheme. I give them C+ at best!
Thanks for the comments.
I may have been a bit harsh on the Penguins and easier of the Rangers I guess... I think that the Rangers can put a good product on the ice this year after their moves they made.
I think everyone is a little to hard on Redden, give him time with some new scenery to see how he does. He wasn't liked in Ottawa and I wouldn't play very well in a place that hates me either.
I based the Penguins score on the fact I don't think that from their moves they will be as good as last year.
I could very well be totally wrong as they missed Crosby for most of the year, but as far as a run to the Stanley Cup finals goes? I don't think it's happening, and I think they lost a tonne in the Hossa deal.
Thanks again for the comments and criticism, I enjoy discussing it.
The difference between Naslund and Zherdev versus Shannahan and Jagr is the former will keep up with Gomez and Drury. This team's gonna look a lot like the Buffalo Sabres a few seasons ago. Sad to see Tyutin go, but it looks like their defense is set for the moment. Redden's getting some serious flak, but remember who he was playing for last season and the position they were in during the second half.
I think, as it was in 2007-2008, this division will be the dogfight of the regular season. The Islanders are going to grow a bit from within, and though they won't challenge for a playoff spot this year, it's shaping up to be the division to watch.
I am a sports enthusiast. I like just about every sport out there. Along with that I love discussing and chatting about any sport. I am going to school to become a Sports Journalist. I host a NFL Pre-game show every Sunday during the NFL season at 11A.M. Called 'Unnecessary Roughness' It can be seen worldwide on www.stellarra dio.ca. I look forward to talking sports with just about anyone.
Favorite Teams:
NHL-Montreal Canadiens
MLB-Oakland Athletics, Toronto Blue Jays
NFL-New Orleans Saints, Washington Redskins
NBA-Toronto Raptors
College sports-Michig an State Spartans
NASCAR-Dale Jr.
MMA fighter-Georg es St. Pierre, Forrest Griffin