These are the alumni of both Florida and Ohio State that are currently in the NFL.  I'll let you be the judge.  Info from scout.com.

Florida Offense:

• QB - Rex Grossman, CHI
• RB – Fred Taylor, JAX
• WR – Travis Taylor, MIN
• WR – Ike Hillard, TB
• WR – Darrell Jackson, SEA
• TE – Ben Troupe, TEN
• OL – Cooper Carlisle, DEN
• OL – Tavares Washington, SF
• OL – Kenyatta Walker, TB
• OL – Zach Piller, TEN
• OL – Mike Pearson, MIA

Florida Defense:

• DE - Jevon Kearse, PHI
• DT – Gerald Warren, DEN
• DT Ian Scott, CHI
• DE - Alex Brown, CHI
• LB – Mike Peterson, JAX
• LB – Andra Davis, CLE
• LB – Channing Crowder, MIA
• CB - Lito Sheppard, PHI
• CB – Keiwan Ratliff, CIN
• S - Gus Scott, NE
• S - Todd Johnson, CHI
  
  Ohio State Offense:  
• QB – No current QB in NFL
• RB – No current RB in NFL
• WR – Terry Glenn, DAL
• WR – Michael Jenkins. ATL
• WR – Joey Galloway, TB
• TE Darnell Sanders, CIN
• OL – Orlando Pace, STL
• OL – Rob Sims, SEA
• OL – Nick Mangold, NYJ
• OL – Shane Olivea, SD
• OL – Adrien Clarke, PHI  

Ohio State Defense:

• DE – Darrion Scott, DE
• DT – Marcus Green, SEA
• DT – Dan Wilkerson, MIA
• DE – Will Smith, NO
• LB – Bobby Carpenter, DAL
• LB – Mike Vrabel, NE
• LB – A.J. Hawk, GB
• CB – Shawn Springs, WAS
• CB – Nate Clements, BUF
• S – Will Allen, TB
• S – Donte Whitner, BUF