The biggest, fastest, and possibly dumbest creature to roam the earth since dinosaurs is professional baseball and like dinosaurs baseball's inevitable extinction is just as predictable. What pushes a sport to the brink of doom? Let's examine how baseball illustrates a disturbing fact; the age of the sports dinosaur is drawing to a bitter and sudden close.
Baseball. Why did it resonate for so long? Why was it cherished for almost 150 years? Why does it seem so hollow and phony now? You have to go back to the beginning to see why the end of professional baseball is near.
Baseball isn't just the national pastime it is the national pastime and for good reason. Baseball was incubated in the civil war and afterwards became the panacea that healed a divided nation. Baseball was bigger in all aspects than we can imagine today, it held the promise of spring, the struggle of summer and the decay and finality of fall so perfectly in balance it's hard to imagine life without it.
The rhythms and pace are as perfect as the diamond it's played upon. It's the great equalizer. There is a profound truth to its demands. The ball, the bat, the glove, the dimensions immutably played across nine innings, three outs, and a box score that sings the game across time. Brandeis said, sports is truth because once it was reduced to a box score there were no interpretations, no gray areas just the game as it was played forever fixed in the amber of Linotype.
The earliest professional teams rose and fell like summer corn. The players an amalgam of college graduates, drunks, and shifty characters were every bit as dodgy as the grifters and con men that owned the clubs. There was no privilege between the lines that mattered save your baseball pedigree. It didn't matter that Rube Waddell was mad as a hatter and twice as childlike, on the mound he was un-hittable and just as likely to chase a fire engine, as he was to strike out the side. His manager, Connie Mack, for fear he would disappear on a bender, doled his salary out a few bucks at a time.
Race played no part in the beginning it wasn't until Hall of Famer Cap Anson, a de####able racist, led a cabal that drove Black players from the game in the late 1800's and then like a Shakespearian tragedy it took the man who saved baseball Judge Landis to maintain that prejudice until his death when Branch Rickey and Jackie Robinson shattered that vile barrier six decades later. But don't get all misty-eyed.
The Negro League in its day was the 3rd largest black owned and operated business, and cornerstone of the Black community, their players were every bit the equal of any major league player. Robinson may have broken the barrier but the barrier fell directly on top of the Negro League. Nor were the Dodgers all that racially smart or advanced. To maintain a quota system that suppressed black players in the majors after Robinson and Larry Doby broke the color barrier they lost Roberto Clemente to the Pirates in the Rule 5 draft because they already had their quota filled on the Dodgers roster. But none of this is news to any real baseball fan.
Baseball stars in every era were considered family heirlooms passed on from father to son, each adding his own layer. It was a legacy and a trust. But all that began to change in the 1970's. It isn't fair to blame baseball for the changing environment of sports or even society. Nevertheless baseball withstood much change without the bedrock shifting. But like a Brontosaurus or a T-Rex seeing the meteor cross the sky that would kill them it didn't understand its time was over.
Baseball has spilled more ink than any other sport. It has a lyricism that attracts great writers to scribble great things. But suddenly newspapers faced their own extinction. Great dailies fell all across the country, as cable supplanted print media and now sports, once the favorite section of the daily paper, was a click away for an increasingly lazy and entertainment jaded public. Baseball a sport that thrived because it was the only affordable entertainment for the poor and middle class saw it's impact and place dwindle as the price of tickets pushed aside all but the deepest corporate pockets.
Family owned teams sold out to corporations who care only about the bottom line. Media companies bought teams for programming and chucked them into the hungry maw of 24-hour sports channels without understanding or caring about tradition. Baseball became another commodity measured in ratings. Like earth inverting underneath a flood ravaged dike, tradition washed and whirled away and by the time of the last real commissioner, Fay Vincent, the only thing owners cared about was whacking up billions in profits and everything else be damned.
Over expansion, fueled by a lust for the billions it brought current owners in entry fees, diluted the quality of the players, to compensate the mound was lowered until pitchers could barely pitch six injury free innings a game over an entire season even on 5 days rest. Under the greedy and clearly dumbest commissioner, Bud Selig, owner by proxy of the Milwaukee Brewers, major league baseball extorted new stadiums from taxpayers and then priced them out of attending. Attendance still rose as corporate box seats and the wealthy supplanted the dopes that paid for the stadium and ratings rose like a bubble until an unlikely pin, steroids, popped it.
Steroids are the genie let out of the bottle of real fan discontent. Players like Roger Clemens and Barry Bonds put a real face on a problem created, fostered and supported by MLB, owners, and teams. Baseball was all a lie. The thing we cherished and grew up with was gone. Replaced by a shimmering Vegas resort mirage. When fan outrage finally brick walled the mealy-mouthed Selig he tried to whitewash it with the Mitchell Report. But nobody was biting. With each new revelation, an ugly truth was left flopping and gasping for air like a fish made out of raw sewage.
Look at the baseball landscape today. There are only two teams, the Yankees and the Red Sox and $100 million dollars in salary behind them is every other team. Sure they don't win the World Series every season, but most. It isn't even a league it's like Batman and Superman fighting to the death with the rest of the Justice League happily sucking mocha lattes at a Starbucks.
The other teams are content to grab the TV cash and act as a feeder system. But the sport no longer resonates. It no longer captures the heart, mind and soul of our nation. There isn't a single player that isn't playing under the su####ion of performance enhancing drugs. Their personal lives are displayed like a colonoscopy so any hope of them ever being a hero to a small child is unlikely and finally when you do go to a ballpark, they fiscally rape you so hard it leaves a bad taste in your mouth.
Baseball should look at hockey and figure it out. Once a sport stops resonating, canceling a season or signing the wrong TV contract, makes it very easy for Americans to simply walk away. Right now baseball is kicking dirt over that cliff. Baseball will reap what it sows. Fans unfortunately inherit the wind.
JW,
Thanks, a salary cap would make a huge difference, the NBA model seems to work better than the NFL model, the other aspects are harder to fix, the game has all but disappeared on a pick up basis for kids which is troubling and while you could get into the wholesale failure of the structured childhood in vogue these days as a cause it speaks volumes to the exclusionary attitude baseball has taken towards the poor to middle class demographic baseball has walked away from. NASCAR is in danger of the same dynamic and it leads me to believe that in that vacuum something else will displace two major sports. Money may be the root of all evil but in this case it is choking baseball to death. There is a tipping point to these things and you have to hope the pendulum will swing back in time. Who can afford season tickets? The game is becoming a TV only scenario for the very audience it needs to capture live and in person. A good example of this can be seen in hockey. Attend a game then watch one on TV and tell me there isn't a huge chasm between the two. I don't see where catering exclusively to the luxury box corporate sponsor mentality builds any kind of sustainable base of fans in the long run. At some point the roar of the crowd will be replaced by the rattling of jewelry.
Great article. I have loved the game since I was a kid and I still do. Baseball has the same problems as our society. It is managed by unscrupulous and greedy men who have no concern for what is right. It is the love of money that is the root of all evil and I can only hope that the game can be saved and given back to it's true fans.
Well said, you hit the nail on the head.
It reminds us all there is always a Nero or in this case Selig who fiddles while Rome burns...the shame is the steely grip of greed is hard to pry off something once it is firmly in its grasp...
I don't know if baseball will go the way of the dinosaur or not...it seems to always survive..
The fans will change..they'll jus' play a "SHALLOWER" centerfield than we did in our day. And mebbe that's more of an indictment of fans like you and I becoming "dinosaur's" then baseball itself..
The only consolation we have, as "old-school" fans, is that we KNOW we watched a better game than fans do now...and played a DEEPER centerfield...
Pi_sses me off dat Selig/Fehr got away with this..
I do not agree. Sure baseball has had some downsides, strikes and the turning the blind eye on steroids for years, aswell as the high priced contracts. The NHL's salary cap shows that teams have to move players around to be under the cap. This will promote players changing teams more often. There will be players bouncing from team to team, year after year. Todd bertuzzi is a prime example in the NHL, Van-Flo-Det-Ana, in about 18 months. Baseball is maybe not the staple interest with sports fans, but look how many Red Sox fans have jumped on board, Tampa has created new excitement in Florida, and if the Cubs can win, holly smokes the Mid west will go crazy. the World Series has had many differnt winners the last few years, Red Sox x2, the Cards, White sox, and Angels. This is good for the game, and with the influx of asians in the game and the World baseball Classic, baseball will only get stronger.
Ed, I think you nailed it with your 24 hour sports network comment..................That's exactly what I was thinking, when I started reading this post.
Somethings are just not for us to know about, such as: The infidelity of second baseman on your favorite baseball team. Who cares if a player gambles on baseball? If a whole team does it, well that's different.
In the early days baseball was bigger than the media, even with the advent of specialty baseball newspapers the whole story failed to get reported.
Now it's breaking news if the manager of a midwest team gets a DWI coming home from a bar at night.
Should it affect baseball? No............But it still does.
Last edited by evilquacks101 on June 23rd at 9:14 AM.
Stevo,
Well said my good man...While I might be slower than a brontosaurus and crankier than a T-Rex I am not yet wholly dinosaur...you make a good point, but I don't see baseball as a growing sport or as omnipresent locally as it was in the past. It is now doled out in leagues or fun ruined by adults, I never see kids playing a pickup game and way back in time on my block there were usually games going all day, the effect of this will continue to marginalize baseball's future no matter how many dollars Bud crams in the pockets of owners from TV revenue and his IHOP tournament. Slaughterhouses leave more of the pig than Selig does when it comes to squeezing money out of the remaining fans...
Last edited by edhardiman on June 23rd at 9:27 AM.
UK,
Thanks for reading my scribble and disagreeing is what makes sports fun. I think a salary cap would help immensely but by the same token I think the sport needs to address what made the game great, a balance between hitting and pitching, the right number of teams, not just as many as you can cram down the throats of gullible fans. Over expansion killed hockey, ..fact is I think baseball has lost sight that great plays, great players and guys who lunch pail it are part of the mix that appeals to the broadest spectrum...and you have to address the cost of attending a stadium the team didn't even pay for...
Last edited by edhardiman on June 23rd at 9:25 AM.
Quacks,
I am fighting the urge to edit the piece and steal your jaw dropping observation, that baseball used to be bigger than the media and now it's smaller. Freaking brilliant. Great ducks think alike...
ed...Backindaday..(I swear I thought I'd never be old enuff to say dat...lol)..I was raised in South Houston, Texas and allda kids inda neighborhood mowed lawns jus' so we could build a baseball field inna huge lot behind a row of houses...dam_n good'un too...
Went by there few years ago...you guessed it!..It's a Mall now...kinda like Barry Bonds replacin' Willie Mays...ainnit?...The ballpark we built wuzza better deal...I'm thinkin'...
BRAVO! The duck is back, with a masterpiece. This was worth the wait. How about not making us wait so long for the next one?
I gave up on major league baseball about the time the Braves traded Dale Murphy. I still go to the minor league games in Charleston. Then vaguely follow some of those players as they progress to the show. Great scribble scrabble.
edhardiman
I see that you're knockin' it outta the ballpark once again ? This piece has reached the stratosphere and has yet to land . It's as brilliant as it is succinct and ought to be required reading for those who love the sport.
I've a new piece up within this forum titled To Serve, But To Do So With Distinction And Pride ! Let me know what you think as to the merits of the piece ? I'll look forward to reading your comments as and when you're ready. Chimin' out.
Ed. Too many great points to comment on all. What really jumps out at me about baseball today is the exclusivity of the game at the youth level. Youth league parks are now mini-shrines to big league parks, donated and supported with corporate sponsership. One of these new shrines is close to where I live. It has a high fence surrounding it and a beautiful wrought iron gate with a chain and padolock keeping it closed. If you have a couple a hundred bucks your kid has the opportunity to play in this shrine if he is fortunate enough to be drafted by one of the teams in the league. These tryouts are conducted by men wearing the corporate logos on their shirts carrying clipboards and somber looks on their faces. They seldom speak to any of the kids, offer encouragement or coaching. If your kid makes the team the parents pay admission to see them play and also pay inflated prices on hotdogs and popcorn. This money is used primarily for insurance premiums. Kids have become a liability rather than an asset. The public park fields are usually empty because any time you get 10-20 kids together the chances are greater that trouble rather than a ballgame breaks out. May Bud Selig choke on his daily hot dog.
Ed-i disagree with what you are saying. Baseball has such a wide fan base in so many areas I don't think it will die out. And what you said about the Red Sox and Yankees, that is wrong. The Yanks haven't won since 2000 and the Sox won because of farm system, not buying everyone. All of the teams in baseball have a CHANCE to become winners, which is less easily said in other sports.
The Sox won because they brought in two key free agents years back (Manny, Big Papi), who are the best hitters in the league, and traded for Josh Beckett. Their farm system made this already volatile combination that much more effective.
As a kid I remember trading bubblegum cards with friends. Baseball was king and we all knew the names and stats of every player on the home team roster. It's different now, kids don't trade cards anymore,it's all been commercialised at this point. Card shows, Memorabilia on QVC,and steroid scandals have dulled the lustre a bit, for me anyways.(I'm still lamenting clothespinning that mint Carlton Fisk rookie card to the spokes of my Columbia stingray, but who knew?)
Keep it coming Ed. You are one of the writers on this blog that I truly look forward to reading.
Last edited by 54fulltiltfulltime on June 23rd at 8:37 PM.
Ed; Ive never been in such total DISagreement with you. As long as fathers have sons there will be Base Ball. I know that for the last 5-6 years ive been preachin it to my boy, i dont see fathers changing that in the near future. It's a main stay of father son bonding, dont you think? You write Base Ball Healed the nation? You kiddin? In the next paragragh you tell me Cap Anson divided it..Base Ball or Pro Base Ball? I always thought Pro Base Ball was played soley in the Northern States back then.. Feel free to correct me, i wasn't there at the time. A lot of the rest of this post can have NFL NBA or NHL in the title, over paid players, stadiums funded by the public, unscrupulous personalities, early rasism and on and on. Why single out my favorite sport? Are you just so pis sed about the Phillies current play, your ready to kill off Base Ball?? Answer me dam it!!
Although I am not a great baseball fan I do agree with most of what you have said. At least the part I understand. LOL.
Here in Tulsa we only have minor league, the Drillers who finished last in the first half. They have been a successful team being very accesible to the fans before and after games which doesn't happen that much today with the big shots. But losing doesn't help. I asked my brother and his friends why they don't like baseball. No fights, no hitting each other (football?), little contact between two teams, they think it's boring.
My point is this. It may not be boring but if the young think it is, that "wide fan base" the other blogger talks about, is aging rapidly. To be honest I really don't care to hear about what Arod's wife wore or whose doing steroids or whatever. They've destroyed their own heros. They should have just taken of the problem internally long before it became daily news.
all we are left with now is "the stars are juiced or cheaters or this what their bimbo wives are doing" and to me that's not sport.
I guess it's different if you have a major league team in your city or even state but about all I pay attention to is how are the Red Sox and the Yankees doing in their rivarly. Bout it.
The Minnesota Twins and Florida Marlins have become farm teams for the rest of the major leagues. They develop great players but can't come close to doling out the $ that the two Evil Empires-New York and Boston-can. Tori Hunter has made the statement that baseball is no longer interested in recruiting great black athletes as they can pay Latinos so much less. I am wondering where this generations Dave Winfield or Willie Mays is going to come from? Greed has so scarred this game that used to be so wonderfully pristine.
Wow-what a post-easily your best ever-and that says a lot. Now a suggestion-have you ever considered writing a book on this topic? I really believe someone from our generation needs to chronicle this and after reading this post you have a great perspective on baseball's demise. I grew up as a baseball fanatic and now I could almost care less-and this post touches on many of the reasons why. However there are many more reasons and incidents over the past twenty years or so that should be documented and presented to the public and you would be da man to do it Ed.