As I expected, things are picking up as we move around the
diamond. There’s a lot to talk about at the keystone, so let’s get to it.
Trade Market
One of the second baseman that I think should be traded has
already been mentioned several times in trade rumors this offseason – Brian Roberts.
Another player I think should be made available is Mark Ellis. Roberts is due
$6.6M and $8M the next two seasons before becoming a free agent, and playing on
a bad Baltimore club, he isn’t worth that price. Put him on a contender, and
he’s easily worth that salary. The same case could be made for Ellis, who is
due $5M in 2008 and will be a free agent following the season. Both teams have
already shown a willingness to trade away veterans this offseason, and Roberts
and Ellis should be on their ways out.
As for who should be trying to acquire either one of these
players, the first team that comes to mind is Houston, who just gave a 3-year,
$15M contract to Kazuo Matsui. Matsui only hit .249/.304/.333 away from Coors
Field last year, and he was protected against left-handed pitchers as he only had
70 ABs in which he hit .271/.311/.386 against them. It doesn’t appear that
Houston would have what it takes to acquire Roberts anyway, but it’s not like
they gave Baltimore much for Miguel Tejada either.
The next tier of teams that should be interested in
upgrading at second consists of the New York Mets, Colorado Rockies, and Chicago
Cubs. Like the Astros, the New York Mets just signed a player to a multi-year
deal to play second base, but Luis Castillo has been on the decline the last
couple of years. At 32, he’s no longer the speedster he was in Florida, and
he’s only managed to hit .296/.358/.370 and .301/.362/.359 the last two years.
Those would be acceptable lines if his defense was better. Since Castillo will
make $6M for each of the next 4 years, I think it’s safe to say that the Mets
aren’t looking to replace him anytime soon.
The Rockies are going into camp with the second base job up
for grabs between Jayson Nix, Marcus Giles, Omar Quintanilla, and Ian Stewart.
If Stewart can play an acceptable second base, the Rockies could be scratched
off the list, but there are doubts that he can make the transition from third.
One of the Rockies’ top prospects is shortstop Chris Nelson. With Troy
Tulowitzki locked into the shortstop spot at the major league level, maybe they
could part with Nelson in a package for Roberts. A move for Roberts would
considerably improve their chances of making a return trip to the postseason.
Although the Cubs have been rumored to be trading for Brian
Roberts for quite a while, I actually think they’d be better off asking about
Mark Ellis. Right now, their middle infield spots will be occupied by two of
Mark DeRosa, Mike Fontenot, Eric Patterson, Ryan Theriot, and Ronny Cedeno. If
they acquire Roberts, the shortstop job would be up to DeRosa and Theriot
(assuming Cedeno gets traded). If instead they got Ellis, they could play him
at either second or short with the remaining spot going to one of DeRosa,
Fontenot, Patterson, Theriot, and Cedeno (minus whoever gets traded). If they
get a deal done for either one, the real key to how much they’ve improved their
’08 playoff odds is whether or not Theriot remains in the starting lineup.
Contract
Extensions
Mark Ellis, Orlando Hudson, and Jeff
Kent are all free agents after the season. I’ve already covered Ellis, and Kent
contemplated retirement following the 2007 season, eliminating both from the contract
extension discussion unless Ellis gets traded. Regarding Hudson, the
Diamondbacks got Chris Burke in the Jose Valverde trade, and some speculate
that Burke will be Hudson’s successor in Arizona. While I wanted the Astros to
give him Craig Biggio’s starting job for a couple of years now, I don’t see him
as a great replacement for Hudson in Arizona. Burke’s going to be 28 when the
season starts, and if he hasn’t proven his worth as a starter so far, I doubt
he ever will. He has a career .249/.319/.377 line over 1020 major league ABs. At
30, Hudson’s entering his decline phase, but a two- or three-year extension
could help keep the Diamondbacks at the top of a tough division.
When looking at young second baseman
worth offering an extension during their pre-arbitration years, Dustin Pedroia,
Ian Kinsler, Kelly Johnson, Dan Uggla, Howie Kendrick, and Rickie Weeks all
enter the discussion. Pedroia and Kendrick both have two years before arbitration,
so I wouldn’t worry about getting them locked up just yet. The other four all
have one pre-arbitration year left. In two years as a starting shortstop, Kinsler
has put up pretty similar seasons, and the Rangers should consider locking him
up to be Michael Young’s double play partner for the next four or five years. Johnson
split time in left field with Brian Jordan and Ryan Langerhans back in 2005
before spending 2006 battling injury and recovering from Tommy John surgery. He
returned last year at second base and did very well. I think waiting one more
year to see if he can do it again is the right move for the Braves. Uggla’s
ability to stay at second base has been questioned time and time again. If he’s
forced to change positions, his bat goes from remarkable to average. With that
question mark hanging in the balance, it would be unwise to offer him an
extension at the present time. Despite three straight years as the Milwaukee
second baseman, Weeks has yet to put in a full season with the big league club.
Many are expecting him to breakout in 2008, and at 25, there’s no reason he
can’t. If it was my money, I’d like to see him break out in 2008 before
awarding him with a big-time contract.
Recap
Brian Roberts and Mark Ellis should
be available on the trade market, and the Astros, Mets, Rockies, and Cubs could
all use an upgrade at the position. With multi-year contracts given to free
agent second basemen this offseason, the Astros and Mets probably don’t agree.
The Diamondbacks should look to extend Orlando Hudson before he leaves as a
free agent following the 2008 season. Ian Kinsler is the only pre-arbitration
second baseman I’d be worried about signing to an extension right now; I’d wait
a year to worry about Dustin Pedroia, Howie Kendrick, Kelly Johnson, and Rickie
Weeks.
With tonight's loss to Philadelphia, the Atlanta Braves are officially eliminated from the playoffs. With Andruw Jones's disappointing season and the fact that the Braves employ 3/5 of a starting rotation, it's surprising they made it this far.
Strengths
Around the horn, the Braves have a strong set of infielders. Chipper Jones has once again proven that when he is on the field (I was going to say healthy, but even when playing, he's never healthy), he is still a great player. He was joined this year by Edgar Renteria, Kelly Johnson, and midseason acquisition Mark Teixeira. With the emergence of Yunel Escobar this season, there has been talk of Edgar Renteria being on the trade market, and given the holes that I will discuss later, John Schuerholz just might pursue that option.
Out in the outfield, Matt Diaz, Willie Harris, and Jeff Francoeur have had pretty good seasons. Diaz and Harris have been a great platoon in left, and Francoeur is proving that talent and age truly do trump poor plate discipline over time. Diaz has hit .356/.384/.580 against lefties, and Harris has hit .291/.370/.428 against righties. Meanwhile, Francoeur has been great defensively and is learning to manage the strike zone offensively. After only 23 walks in 2006, Francoeur has walked 41 times this year at 23. He's lost some of his power stroke, but again, he's only 23 so he should figure things out. Unfortunately, the Braves don't have an easy replacement for Andruw Jones, which means they'll need to re-sign him, sign one of the other free agent center fielders (Torii Hunter and Aaron Rowand), or pick one up in a trade.
Behind the plate, Brian McCann has regressed from his tremendous 2006 season, but it is very rare for a catcher to have back-to-back .333/.388/.572 while playing well defensively. His .272/.322/.456 is certainly nothing to sneeze at from your backstop.
Pitching to McCann, the Braves have seen #1 seasons from both John Smoltz and Tim Hudson. They should both be in the NL Cy Young race, but since their teams weren't good enough to make the playoffs, they won't get enough votes to win (nor should they, Jake Peavy should be the runaway winner). As a #3 starter, 25 year old Chuck James has done well.
Weaknesses
Aside from the center field problem that everyone knows about, the Braves need .... pitching help? A few years ago, that would have been unheard of. Although they have Smoltz and Hudson at the front of the rotation and Rafael Soriano and Peter Moylan doing good work out in the pen, the Braves need to fix the back of the rotation and the rest of the bullpen. Mike Gonzalez won't be back from Tommy John surgery until midseason, and Octavio Dotel has been horrible since coming over to the NL. Dotel has a player option at $5.5M for 2008, but the club has the option to void it. The Braves aren't usually big players on the free agent market, but they might be able to find some answers on the trade market. Schuerholz has had a lot of success there.
Overall
The Atlanta Braves have several pieces in place, but they still have some holes that need fixing. If they fail to keep or replace Andruw Jones in center field, that could be a problem in terms of putting runs on the board and keeping them off. The NL East will continue to be a tough place to compete, but the Braves are no stranger to the top of the division. I don't expect 2008 to be their year, but it wouldn't surprise me either.
Following up my AL All-Star piece, I'm moving over to the senior circuit. Again, starters are marked with an asterisk.
Catcher *Russell Martin, Los Angeles Dodgers Brian McCann, Atlanta Braves
First Base *Albert Pujols, St. Louis Cardinals Prince Fielder, Milwaukee Brewers Dmitri Young, Washington Nationals
Second Base *Chase Utley, Philadelphia Phillies Orlando Hudson, Arizona Diamondbacks
Third Base *Miguel Cabrera, Florida Marlins David Wright, New York Mets Chipper Jones, Atlanta Braves
Shortstop *Jose Reyes, New York Mets Hanley Ramirez, Florida Marlins Edgar Renteria, Atlanta Braves
Outfield *Barry Bonds, San Francisco Giants *Matt Holliday, Colorado Rockies *Ken Griffey, Jr., Cincinnati Reds Alfonso Soriano, Chicago Cubs Hunter Pence, Houston Astros Carlos Beltran, New York Mets
Starting Pitchers *Jake Peavy, San Diego Padres Brad Penny, Los Angeles Dodgers Roy Oswalt, Houston Astros Chris Young, San Diego Padres John Smoltz, Atlanta Braves Ben Sheets, Milwaukee Brewers Ian Snell, Pittsburgh Pirates Derek Lowe, Los Angeles Dodgers Tim Hudson, Atlanta Braves John Maine, New York Mets
Relief Pitchers Takashi Saito, Los Angeles Dodgers Billy Wagner, New York Mets
Guys Selected due to 1 Player per Team Rule Dmitri Young is the only player I had to select due to the 1 player per team rule, but I did choose from Orlando Hudson instead of either Dan Uggla and Kelly Johnson because I needed a Diamondback.
Guys on My All-Star Team that Aren't Going to San Francisco 3B Chipper Jones SS Hanley Ramirez SS Edgar Renteria OF Hunter Pence SP Roy Oswalt SP Chris Young SP Ian Snell SP Derek Lowe SP Tim Hudson SP John Maine
There are several guys here with very strong cases that they should be on the All-Star Team: Chipper Jones, Hanley Ramirez, Roy Oswalt, and Chris Young. To make room, I'd remove Freddy Sanchez, J.J. Hardy, the deposed Brian Fuentes, Cole Hamels, and Francisco Cordero, which also makes room for Ian Snell to be the Pirate representative.
All-Star Starters that Aren't on My Team None, fans did a pretty good job here, although I don't understand how Albert Pujols isn't the starting 1B. He has been arguably the best player in baseball for the last six seasons. Plus, he has nearly matched Prince's OPS even after his slow start and Prince's fast start.
Final Vote Two of my players from the "Guys on My All-Star Team that Aren't Going to San Francisco" are eligible for the final vote: Roy Oswalt and Chris Young. With Oswalt on his way to his 4th great season in a row, it's a no-brainer that he gets my vote.
First Tier 1. Chase Utley, Philadelphia Phillies Runs unmatched by any other 2B, HR unmatched by any other 2B, and RBI unmatched by any other 2B all wrapped in one package. Hands down, top fantasy 2B.\
Second Tier 2. Howie Kendrick, Los Angeles Angels Unbelievable batting averages throughout the minors: .318, .368, .367, .384, .342, .369, plus he's developing some power to go with it.
Third Tier 3. Ian Kinsler, Texas Rangers 4. Robinson Cano, New York Yankees 5. Orlando Hudson, Arizona Diamondbacks 6. Ray Durham, San Francisco Giants 7. Rickie Weeks, Milwaukee Brewers 8. Kelly Johnson, Atlanta Braves 9. Ryan Freel, Cincinnati Reds *10. Brian Roberts, Baltimore Orioles
Kinsler provides extra power for the position. Cano lacks the steals, but makes up for it with batting average. Hudson gets a few extra runs while sacrificing a few RBI. Durham's age and previous seasons makes 2006 scream fluke. If Weeks can stay healthy and play better defense, he can become one of the best second baseman over the next few years. Johnson doesn't qualify at second yet, but if he wins the job, he'll provide strong numbers at second base. Freel makes up for the power outage with monster stolen base numbers if he wins a starting outfield spot in Cincinnati. Roberts should put up numbers very similar to Freel.
Fourth Tier 11. Tadahito Iguchi, Chicago White Sox 12. Chone Figgins, Los Angeles Angels 13. Freddy Sanchez, Pittsburgh Pirates 14. Luis Castillo, Minnesota Twins 15. Julio Lugo, Boston Red Sox 16. Dan Uggla, Florida Marlins 17. Brandon Phillips, Cincinnati Reds
This group of players contain several guys that came out of nowhere last year to put up big numbers - Sanchez, Uggla, and Phillips - who will most likely come back down to earth. Iguchi has been consistently solid since coming over from Japan: 80 R, 15 HR, 70 RBI, 13 SB, .280 AVG. Figgins provides major steals, covering up for his poor AVG and RBI total. Freddy Sanchez is the exact opposite in using his AVG to make up for his lack of steals. Castillo and Lugo are pretty similar with Castillo providing slightly better AVG and Lugo a few more home runs. Uggla provides a little more power than the rest of the guys in this tier, but his AVG brings him back to the pack. Phillips has streaky plate discipline, which can hurt his production, but he's still solid across the board.
As always, bring on the comments.
*Brian Roberts was originally a member of the 4th tier, but I looked into it after JoshQPublic questioned his placement and moved him up into the 3rd tier.
This is baseball. Let's have some fun.
Recommended Websites:
MLB Trade Rumors, Baseball Prospectus, Cot's Baseball Contracts, Fan Graphs, Football Outsiders