Once again, the Montreal Canadiens are making life interesting for their fans, of which I am one (see sidebar).
Les Canadiens had a strong start to this season, but since mid-December have been mired in a lengthy slump that threatens to send them tumbling out of playoff contention in the very tight Eastern Conference standings.
It’s the same pattern as last season, although then the crappy goaltending of Jose Theodore was primarily to blame. Claude Julien unfairly lost his job as Habs head coach last January in no small part due to Theodore’s performance, although he's now probably much happier as the bench boss of the red-hot New Jersey Devils.
It took the emergence of Cristobal Huet to give the Canadiens the goaltending it needed to get back into the playoff race and save the season. This season, however, it remains to be seen what, if anything, can snap this year’s version of the Canadiens out of their current malaise.
Now it should be noted that the Habs aren’t the only team to suffer through a lengthy slump this season.
The Ottawa Senators got off to such a horrific start to this season that many of their fans were clamoring for team captain Daniel Alfredsson to be traded back in November.
The Calgary Flames and Vancouver Canucks started the season slowly before finding their groove by December. The Tampa Bay Lightning were stumbling so badly prior to New Year’s that management threatened on two occasions to shake things up with a trade before they turned the corner.
It’s quite possible Les Boys can turn things around, but to do so, the coaching staff and the front office must address some critical problem areas.
First and foremost, this team can’t score, especially five-on-five. Earlier in the season their powerplay was able to off-set this problem but of late even the PP has cooled.
The guys expected to contribute offensively on the first line – team captain Saku Koivu, Michael Ryder, Chris Higgins – have come up snake-eyes far too often in recent weeks. No offense to Radek Bonk, Mike Johnson and Mark Streit, but when a team's third-and-fourth liners are doing most of the scoring over the past month, you've got a team in trouble offensively.
Alex Kovalev's game blows hot and cold, depending on the state of his knee and, according to some, his mood. Kovalev’s problem is that he needs to have a superstar linemate, like he did in Pittsburgh with Jaromir Jagr, to truly shine. When his linemates are average, so too is his production.
And of course there’s Sergei Samsonov, expected to bolster the offensive depth this season but instead became a horrible bust . It was noted that head coach Guy Carbonneau hasn’t put him on Koivu’s line this season. Given the way the Habs offense has dried up over the last month, one wonders if it would be such a bad idea to put Sammy and Captain K on the same line with Kovalev and hope for the best.
Another major problem is Huet has struggled over the past month. His strong play in the first half of the season earned him a berth in the All-Star game, but nobody would mistake him for an All-Star since New Year’s.
Thankfully, backup David Aebischer has taken over and has played very well for the Canadiens since the All-Star break. The losses the Habs compiled since then weren’t his fault, and his strong play likely means he won’t become the trade bait everyone expected he would be by the trade deadline should Huet continue to struggle.
But even with “Abby’s” goaltending, the Canadiens have lacked the energy they had earlier in the season. Their special teams, once among the best in the league, have been disturbingly average since the All-Star break. In two recent games against the Penguins, almost all of Pittsburgh’s goals came on the powerplay.
In other words, as bad as the PP has been of late, the PK has been even worse. Nothing but hard work is going to improve that.
Which leads to the obvious question: what’s the reason behind the Canadiens woes?
The answer might be that the players could be tuning out head coach Guy Carbonneau and his staff of Kirk Muller and Doug Jarvis.
Yes, these guys were expected to be no-nonsense coaches who’d motivate this team into a tighter, harder-working unit, and for the first three months of the season, they seemingly accomplished those goals.
But that hasn’t been apparent since the New Year. It’s caused star blueliner Sheldon Souray to openly take his teammates to task in a recent loss to the Toronto Maple Leafs, proclaiming that the Habs were a better team than the Leafs but just weren’t playing like it.
I like Carbonneau, Muller and Jarvis, and I’m not advocating they be fired, as that would be ridiculous, but there’s something that’s missing, something that as a rookie coach “Carbo” hasn’t been able to tap into to snap his charges out of their moribund mindset.
Perhaps it’s the lack of an obvious superstar to rally around.
The Maple Leafs have rallied around Mats Sundin, the Sens around Heatley, Alfredsson and Redden; the Bolts around Lecavalier, Richards and St. Louis, the Flames around Iginla and Kiprusoff, the Canucks around Roberto Luongo.
As much as I admire Koivu, he’s not a superstar, not the kind of player who can hoist this team on his back through a rough patch and carry it through with his play. That’s been painfully obvious over the past six weeks. Captain K needs help, a sniper to benefit from his savvy playmaking.
The Canadiens could certainly use a player like that, but is it worth the short-term gain of pursuing, say, Peter Forsberg and his crooked foot and sacrificing the future?
The Habs have plenty of promising young players, and Bob Gainey isn’t a GM to start selling off that promise for a quick fix, but it’s also obvious now that if this team is to make the playoffs this season, let alone make any noise in the playoffs, Gainey may have to pull the trigger on a major deal to get it done.
If not, this team will have to look to within, something it’s been attempting to do without much success over the past two months.
Which could mean the rest of the season could be another down-to-the-wire gutwrencher for Canadiens fans.
Hi Spector. First-timer from Moncton. Just wanted to show these stats: Samsonov, 7 even-strength goals, even, 14:33 average-time-on-ice. Ryder, 7 even-strength goals, -16, 16:33 ATOI.
I think Ryder needs to learn that he's not in a pick-up game and stop trying the same move all the time. He also needs to learn how to pass the puck.
1) Habs fans, like fans from most teams see their team through only the eyes of their team. This is the New NHL. As Lyle correctly points out, EVERY team goes through a slump.
2) One month they look unbeatable, the next look like AHL-ers. The key is which team can curtail that slump the longest.
3) A positive for the Habs is the fact that their special teams are very good. Gainey made up for his awful signing of Samsonov by waiving him freeing up some cap space.
4) This team IS a playoff callibre team. re they a Cup contendor? As with all teams that mostly will depend upon their goaltending. Still 90% of what matters in the NHL
I agree 100%!! The habs need a captain...Nothing against Koivu, but he just seems too "bla" theres no pation there! As you know, I'm a flames fan, but I think one of the greatest captains I've seen in a while was Keith Primeau. He took control of his team and it seemed that he'd give someone a shot in the head if he felt they needed one. I don't really agree with what Sheldon
Souray did, coming out and saying that...It seems like the whole team is falling appart and if someone doesn't take the reigns soon, they're not going to meet calgary for the cup this year!
Sorry guys, but if the Habs are going to be serious contenders, they have to get a goalie. I said from the start that Huet is not the man...you fans will quickly realize that when they go out in the first round. They also need a player thats consistent. A player thats consistent of putting up points. I'm sure everybody has their opinion on what they need so take it half easy on my comments.
Things could be worse. Believe me, things could be worse. The Habs are definitely a team to keep a close eye on as the deadline approaches. If they continue to struggle they might just make a desperation move, as in give up too much in prospects and/or draft picks for a short term fix.
Did you bother to look at stats or watch a game before formulating your opinion Sean?
Huet is the man, if he's 100% he'll take the Habs to the promised land, him and the wicked PP (not so much the PK anymore, Smolinski will fix that though)
Spector I think the tandem of Huet and Aebs may surprise you come playoff time. It always seems that a goalie comes out of nowhere to put up that wall.
I think that once you find good consistent scoring, you may be a force to be reckoned with come April. Good luck to you guys, my guys will be watching you at home with a beer no doubt.
Seriously, I think you guys are all getting worked up over nothing....the habs are a playoff team, you WILL make it to the playoffs, and I'm really hoping for an all canadian cup final this year. Now if you were leafs fans, I'd be the first to point and laugh at you. Raycroft may be playing well for now, but so was Theodore last year... Fact of the matter is, the habs will be a team thats in serious contention and if you were worried about the team, you wouldn't be a real fan
This is by no means a slam on the Habs so please don't take it that way. I had them figured to be battling for one of the last two playoff spots come seasons end. Their hot start was a surprise and now they are just settling into the team they really are. I don't think it is time to panic as they should make the playoffs, but they will have to make some sort of move to get some scoring if they want to make some noise. On a bright note, they have one of the hardest working players in the league in Johnson and the hard work is paying off for him and his linemates. The top line should take notice and follow suit - a little hard work can go a long way.
From the players on the Habs roster I'm unhappy in particular with the European players like Kovalev, Plekanec, Samsonov, Bonk, Perezhogin and Niinimaa. I think all of them except Plekanec and Perezhogin are on the downside of their careers and are not really helping the team, and Plek and Perez are not playing effective. I like the goalie tandem of Huet and Abby but do they really need both of them? Jaroslav Halak is putting up VERY impressive numbers in Hamilton, and I think Yann Danis is now (at the age of 25) also ready to take the next step. And why not give Kostitsyn, Grabovsky and Jancevski their chances as well? I think they could do it.
Last edited by Stevo808 on February 8th at 8:41 AM.
Kovy didn't play on a line with Jagr it Pittsburgh, he played with Lang and Straka mostly, and he had success as a Penguin because he was alowed to roam free all over the the ice and create while not being subjected to a rigid system. I don't think being with Koivu will help but he has to get off that line with Sammy. Two puck hogs is one too many.
i've been a hab fan since the 1960's only thing i've found is that they haven't changed their style of play..they've allways been a defensive team and seem more confortable playing in their own end.in the old nhl their defenceman were taking a beating because they had trouble moving the puck out of their end.they did great in a 6 team league..and later parts of the first expansion.they also had players like guy lafleur too help them with his 50 goals seasons..but that is in the past and u can't play in the past. they do need a different direction. they will make the playoffs this yr but like other yrs that is all they will do..
It's always easy to panic at a time like this but as is usually the case, a team is never as bad as it looks when its slumping, as clearly the canadiens are and they're never as good as they look when they're streaking as the Maple Leafs, Penguins, Lightning are right now. In the Habs, case, they finished 7th in the conference last year. 6th, which is where they sit now, or better, is an improvement from a team that is still in a "measured" rebuilding mode. Gainey may try and bring in a Forsberg to give his team a lift but ultimately adding a Nagy or Horcoff, or a Jokinen and Horton, players that could potentially grow with the club over the coming years, would be the better approach to take
I mentioned early on, that Kovalev and Samonsov weren't the players to pin any hopes on. No offence, but it appears I am right.
Samsonov was signed because Gainey struck out on Arnott, and Shanny.
The team is not as good as their early season record, nor are they as bad as their current slide indicates.
The team is still feeling the effects of the mismanagement by the Houle regime, and it will be a while before they are back.
Hopefully, by the time Price is ready for the big club, Gainey will have things sorted out.
I can't think of one player beyond Souray any team would excited about, and he's as good as gone.
Maybe Latendresse, but he still has to prove himself somewhat. I like Komisarek, but he's never going to rival any of the "big three".
i think much of the blame lies at the desk of bob gainey. trying to build a team around koivu, who is a second line, not first line forward, is a flawed strategy.
by signing samsonov and then trading ribiero for Janne Niinimaa, gainey handcuffed the team. samsonov is a slightly better but older and more expensive version of ribiero and niinimaa is one of the few players who could be -2 with less than five minutes of play. ribiero could have been parlayed into something much more valuable and would have contributed as much as samsonov. so gainey spent close to $6 million to barely replace a player on which he had a one year contract for less than two million.
gainey has made over the entire team, but the results are unchanged.
I'm Lyle Richardson, also known as Spector, Foxsports.com 's "Prince of Pucks".,which is based on the fact I live in Prince Edward Island, Canada and I couldn't think of a better byline. I've been an NHL hockey commentator since 1998 on my website, Spector's Hockey, and I'm a contributing writer for Foxsports.com , The Hockey News and Eishockey News. I'm also a regular on The Faceoff Hockey Show and a frequent guest on "The Late Crew" on The Team 1200 Ottawa.