RogerRotter's Blog
by: RogerRotter
Have a Week 15 question?
Dec 14, 2007 | 1:07PM | report this

Have a Week 15 fantasy question?

Submit one below, and I'll answer the best ones.

For lineup decisions, please use my rankings to determine which ones to start: QB, RB, WR | TE, K, D/ST

For the latest injury and lineup updates until gametime, please check out my injury updates article.

I'd be happy to answer further questions and provide more explanations. Thank you!

97 Comments | Add a comment   category: fantasy football
 
« Continue reading RogerRotter's Blog
total comments: 97      Page 1 of 2     1 2 Next > 
xrayindy
Dec 14, 2007
1:32 PM
There is going to be a "Nor'Easter" storm in Foxboro at game time...Pats average 19.2 pnts in the snow...still like Brady over Warner?

TopGun25
Dec 14, 2007
2:03 PM
I know you said check your rankings for line-up decisions but this is killin me. I have Willis McGahee, Ernest Graham, Ryan Grant and Joseph Addai on my roster. I can only start three of them can you give me some insight please.
P.S Who to start at QB-Kurt Warner or Jeff Garcia. Thank you for your help.
Sighned,
DontHateMe

ethat001
Dec 14, 2007
2:07 PM
Week 15: Which RB is a better start: Ryan Grant or Earnest Graham? And which defense is the best start: Indy, Seattle or Tampa?

Feel My Drill
Dec 14, 2007
2:27 PM
I've got Brady and Romo, who do I choose this week, considering weather, and all?

Bearsfan4life
Dec 14, 2007
2:36 PM
Should I start

IND. A. Gonzalez
Buf. L. Evans
Chi. D. Hester

Need one to go with Whosyourmomma and B. Berrian

tsnyder19
Dec 14, 2007
3:23 PM
Who to start? I need 3.
- Stevn Jackson
- Ryan Grant
- Thomas Jones
- Marshawn Lynh
- Wille Parker

1305
Dec 14, 2007
4:17 PM
Need to win my simi final and need help - have some good choices ---

Do you start Anderson in Cle in bad weather or Warner in New Orleans on the road in a dome?

My choices are WR are:

Burress in Wash in bad weather
Holt vs. a good defense against GB at home
Branch (SEA) vs. a bad Carolina team
Urban (18 - Points last week for AZ) AZ has two starters hurt

Have a delima at RB - can only use two of the following - advice appreciated

Barber at home vs. Phily
J. Lewis at home in bad weather vs Buff
Graham TB on the road vs. Atlanta

Thanks for you help and good luck to you!!!

jodie
Dec 14, 2007
4:18 PM
heyyy Roger,
I also need you to pick 3 for me out of:
* M. BLEEP
* M. Barber
* B. Edwards
* G. Jennings
thanks for the help kind sir!!!!!!!

1305
Dec 14, 2007
4:19 PM
FeelMyDrill

I would go with Romo and stay away from the weather - NE is great in the snow in terms of wins but bad things happen in the snow - int's, funbles, sacks, etc.

PATRIOTS1MORE
Dec 14, 2007
4:21 PM
Ok with the snow and all. Should I keep Brady or switch the Brees?

Also should I keep Moss or go with Fitzgerald or Wayne?

1305
Dec 14, 2007
4:22 PM
etha001

I have the same exact question

Good luck

1305
Dec 14, 2007
4:29 PM
Roger,

When will we know if Urban (AZ) is a good start at WR? The other WR's with AZ are iffy. But how iffy?

Thanks

Mrwill44
Dec 14, 2007
4:52 PM
Who do i start for wide receivers i can only start three:
Greg Jennings
Donte Stallworth
Roddy White
David Patten
Anthony Gonzalez
Roydell Williams

and for running backs (3):

Julius Jones
Earnest Graham
Gado
Droughns
duckett

darinp010
Dec 14, 2007
5:27 PM
in a pinch week 15. i need a little help with my run game pick 2, i have maroney, ryan grant, marshawn BLEEP, kolby smith. (ryan grant) for sure but need a #2 rb?

Last edited by darinp010 on December 14th at 5:33 PM.

Rocketkilla
Dec 14, 2007
8:25 PM
Ok..so i got..Brady and Moss...but due to the weather im considering starting ANDERSON and Colston instead?????any advice

Chemenke
Dec 14, 2007
8:48 PM
Chester Taylor or FRank Gore?

Chemenke
Dec 14, 2007
9:10 PM
.

Last edited by Chemenke on December 14th at 9:11 PM.

Supermann1
Dec 14, 2007
9:43 PM
Hey Roger,

Now I have some real talented recievers on my team but I can only use 3 of them now should I go with Torry Holt playing the packers with Marc Bulger back, Bobby Engram playing the panthers which secondary is not that good, Anthony Gonzalez playing Oakland since he had a all-star game last week, Larry Fitzgerald playing with his groin injury or Lee Evans playing the browns but the weather might slow the game down to the ground game or David Patten playing the cardinals?

Also should I stick with Brady for the next 3 weeks or sub Garcia in the last two or last game?

Thanks Roger,

Any and All help will be needed!

Last edited by Supermann1 on December 14th at 9:44 PM.

derelick
Dec 14, 2007
10:27 PM
should i start marshawn BLEEP against the browns or marion barber against the eagles? and which 2 wide recievers: dwayne bowe, arnaz battle, or bryant johnson?

jared_05
Dec 14, 2007
11:53 PM
Should I start Donald Driver or Roddy White? And should I start Antonio Gates or Chris Cooley?

Dr3amer
Dec 15, 2007
12:56 AM
Donald Driver or Derrick Mason?

fish77
Dec 15, 2007
1:42 AM
Help!! Pick two of three wide-outs a) Reggie Wayne; b) Marques Colston; c) Braylon Edwards

ONE4OTHERTHUMB
Dec 15, 2007
3:39 AM
I have two Question's, both due to weather. First Brady or Favre? Second Washington D/ST or Jackonsville D/ST? Thank you for your help!

thersoxkid
Dec 15, 2007
4:29 AM
I have a few questions.

QB Carson Palmer or David Garrard?

RB Have to start two. I am starting Earnest Graham. My other backs are Chester Taylor,Brandon Jacobs, and Kevin Jones. what other back would you start?

WR HAve to start three. Starting Randy Moss and Hines Ward. My other options are Jabar Gaffney or Reggie Williams.

And lastly my DEF/ST- I have Green Bay & Tampa Bay. Which one would you start?

jacekt
Dec 15, 2007
4:44 AM
Help with my playoff lineup:
T Romo or D Brees
LT, Willie Parker, A. Peterson or Bench Parker but E. Ghram?
WR- Colston, Coles, Crayton, or A. Gonzo, R White,

Last edited by jacekt on December 15th at 4:46 AM.

lilfatso
Dec 15, 2007
4:48 AM
You have Greg Jennings and Deion Branch both projected for 19 pts...Which one do I start?

vmac88
Dec 15, 2007
5:18 AM
Would you start Brees or Farve at QB and would u who would you start @ r/w Stecker, Hillard or Dunn

fishercatman
Dec 15, 2007
5:46 AM
Hey Roger,

How much should I be concerned about QB's, WR's and the weather? Particularly the wind and snow forecasted this weekend. Does weather effect your rankings? I'm debating starting K. Warner over D. Anderson. Both have good situations, but I feel that the Bills won't be able to stop J. Lewis and the throwing will be minimized. The Cards may find themselves behind and throwind alot as usual. What do you think?

Thanks Roger!

-FCM

fish77
Dec 15, 2007
5:58 AM
Roger - One more. Giants (in the weather) or Tampa Bay's defense?? Thanks!!

King Ranch
Dec 15, 2007
7:01 AM
bad weather in foxboro ma. do I start Kurt Warner over Tom Brady?

timgboots
Dec 15, 2007
7:31 AM
how do I see your answers??? I own Brady and Warner who has the better stats this Sunday?

King Ranch
Dec 15, 2007
7:34 AM
urban cardinals or gonzalez indy?

King Ranch
Dec 15, 2007
7:36 AM
urban cardinals or edgerin james cardinals?

lwcsoccer1
Dec 15, 2007
7:38 AM
who should i start? Favre or Brees?

Defensive Mastermind
Dec 15, 2007
7:52 AM
Rotter,

I have had an outstanding year with Brady. But with the blizzard tomorrow should I bench him. Garcia is my other option against Atlanta. Do I bench Westbrook against Dallas and start Graham?

bigtimeball
Dec 15, 2007
8:31 AM
Make sure you talk about the storm !! It's the playoffs baby ! NE has helped all year and now this storm comes to town. Picked up Gaffney as a FA now wondering if I should go with Smith CAR or Henery CIN. Now ya know why I picked up Gaffney ! I used to like snow !

rgrugger
Dec 15, 2007
8:36 AM
Good Morning, Roger!!
OK...you helped me earn the #1 seed in my league...now, please, help me win it all!! I actually have 2 questions...
1. I need 1 WR I already played Marshall Thursday night. I have Larry Fitzgerald, Plax, Welker and Bobby Engram. Fitz and Plax are on your "Cannot Bench List", but here are my concerns: Fitz...groin injury (but in the Dome vs. NO)
Plax...ankle injury in NY weather
Welker...in a blizzard sharing looks with Moss and Stallworth (I also have Brady in those conditions, but I can't sit him...ever!).
You predict Welker to have the best day, but leaning toward Fitz. Thoughts?

2. RB and R/W: I am tempted to bench Jackson (based off your rankings even tho he is a Cannot Bench). I am contemplating starting Ryan Grant vs STL as RB and Ernest Graham vs ATL as R/W. I am solid with Grant, but my fear is that ATL will come to play with everything that has happened this week and shut down Tampa. Am I thinking too much? Should I put Jackson in vs a good GB D?

As always, thanks in advance!!! Have a great holiday!!

phac
Dec 15, 2007
8:42 AM
Should I start
Carson Palmer or Drew Brees???????
Rudi Johnson or LenDale White

LORDISMO
Dec 15, 2007
9:27 AM
Start Marion Barber or Willie Parker?

Bigguy4football
Dec 15, 2007
9:53 AM
Should I start Ben Roethlisberger, who is questionable, or Jeff Garcia

bigdog808
Dec 15, 2007
10:45 AM
Hiya Roger,

I have four players. none with really appealing match-ups, for two flex roster spots. S. Holmes, Fargas, Droughns, Toomer. I'm leaning towards Holmes/Fargas, but they're both BLEEPed up and the weather in Pittsburgh will be nasty. Same for the Meadowlands. Should I sit the receivers in the snow/sleet and start the Rb's and hope Droughns vultures some goal line carries?

Also, which DST? I have both Indy and Green Bay, I'm leaning towards Indy.

Thanks.

ernbear68
Dec 15, 2007
10:47 AM
I'm in a bit of a jam, Adrian Peterson, Chester Taylor, Marshawn BLEEP and Marion barber. Peterson rushed for 3 yards last week while Taylor rushed for over a hundred. Barber blew it up, two rushing and one receiving td and BLEEP rushed for over a hundred. This is rediculous and it seems that whoever I start the person I don't start tears it up.

The Clipper
Dec 15, 2007
11:40 AM
do I go with Indys D at OAK or Tampas D at home against ATL?

jojosaints
Dec 15, 2007
12:30 PM
Hi Roger,

I have a Wide Receiver question for my 3rd WR in a PPR-League.

I have Jerricho Cotchery vs. New England, Reggie Williams vs. Pittsburgh, or Nate Burleson vs. Carolina. New England and Pittsburgh both have great Defenses (and possible snowy conditions).

Who would you go with? Cotchery or Reggie Williams?

Thanks Roger!

springhead
Dec 15, 2007
12:43 PM
You have Hasselbeck ranked higher than Warner this week. Do your ranking factor in the projected weather conditions? The weather in Carolina shows 20 mph winds. Warner plays in the Superdome, so weather is not a factor.

dukefankw
Dec 15, 2007
12:58 PM
I am curious as to what predictions you might have about starting j.gafny or a.gonzales this week in a flex position. What kind of chance do they have to duplicate previous week(s) points. What about trent edwards or jeff garcia at qb, both going against shaking d's but who can I expect the most points out of?

thanks,
keith (louisville)

jrtango07
Dec 15, 2007
1:11 PM
who would you start anthony gonzalez or patrick crayton? any feedback will help

Nick
Dec 15, 2007
1:51 PM
J. Galloway, H. Ward, B. Berrian or S. Smith which 2 should I start?

Nosliw2088
Dec 15, 2007
2:12 PM
Roger: please pick two

Joseph Addai, Brian Westbrook, or Adrian Peterson (Min)?

Thanks

marino32
Dec 15, 2007
2:21 PM
Roger:

I have T.O. who I'm starting this week I need help on a 2nd W/R. Who would you start out of Kevin Curtis, Donald Driver, Santonio Holmes, Jabar Gaffney or Jerheme Urban? Any help would greatly be appreciated. If I win this week I'm in the Championship game.

Thank You:)
Bobby
Indiana

Last edited by marino32 on December 15th at 2:22 PM.

Page 1 of 2     1 2 Next > 
Add a comment  
ABOUT ME


RogerRotter
I am a FOX Sports Blogger who hasn't yet written a bio.
MY FAVORITE BLOGS
FOXBlog's Blog
Mike Harmon's Fantasy Sports Blog
John Halpin's Fantasy Sports Blog
Time stamping is done in Pacific Time.