RogerRotter's Blog
by: RogerRotter
Have a Week 9 question?
Nov 01, 2007 | 4:29PM | report this

Have a Week 9 fantasy question? Submit one below, and I'll answer the best ones.

For lineup decisions, please use my rankings to determine which ones to start: QB, RB, WR | TE, K, D/ST

For the latest injury and lineup updates until gametime, please check out my injury updates article.

I'd be happy to answer further questions and provide more explanations.

Thank you!

402 Comments | Add a comment   category: fantasy football
 
« Continue reading RogerRotter's Blog
total comments: 402      Page 1 of 9     1 2 3 Next > 
donnypump
Nov 1, 2007
4:39 PM
Pick 2: Kenny Watson, Warrick Dunn, Selvin Young, Roddy White. Who do you like Rog?

Autotech
Nov 1, 2007
4:43 PM
I have WR's Branch, Engram, and Chambers. My league only gets points for TD or over 100yds. Who shoulI go with?

dawitwer
Nov 1, 2007
4:47 PM
McNabb vs. Dallas or Big Ben vs. Baltimore? feels like a coin flip, but could use a push for who to play.

Haleynoel
Nov 1, 2007
4:54 PM
Pick one please: D mason, Donte S, galloway or Chambers in ppr league. T Owens will be the other starter.

Trevor
Nov 1, 2007
4:54 PM
Roger, my team is pretty much ready to go. but i have one receiver problem. i don't know if i should play colston or boldin. could you help me out?

X-Men Attack
Nov 1, 2007
4:59 PM
Quarterback's,
Should I start Brees against Jacksonville?
I just picked up Losman off the Waivers against Cincinnati, should I start Losman?

scuba_hova
Nov 1, 2007
5:05 PM
Roger, Can you expand on why you have Kenny Watson so low in your rankings when the Bengals are playing the Bills? The only reason I can think of is because you think Rudi Johnson is going to poach his carries againist the 24th ranked rushing defense, is that correct? I'm assuming you still think starting Watson is a better option than starting Rudi, is that correct?

Corona's Crew
Nov 1, 2007
5:06 PM
Roger:

Jon Kitna or Jeff Garcia this week?

Also, my league is 2 RB/ 2 WR with one RB/WR flex spot as well.

WR Chad Johnson and Braylon Edwards for sure

RB LT for sure

I have Ike Hilliard, Roddy White, Earnest Graham and Clinton Portis left (Burress and J. Walker are out for me this week)

So, who is my second RB and who is my flex spot? Thanks in advance

Vinmister
Nov 1, 2007
5:06 PM
Who should i bench Romo or Mcnabb

Loan Ranger
Nov 1, 2007
5:14 PM
Who should I start. RB/ L. Jordan, MJD, or Mcgahee.. pick 2 to start...

shama009
Nov 1, 2007
5:16 PM
Who would your start at QB Brees or Roethlisberger?

gamer2323
Nov 1, 2007
5:22 PM
b. westbrook, j. addai, or a. peterson? pick two for this week?

kaleb1107
Nov 1, 2007
5:24 PM
I have McGahee, Gore, Kevin Jones, and Young. Gore is playing terrible, McGahee going against the steel curtain. Jones is playing strong. But will Young get the carries? Who should I start? Pick two. Please help.

Last edited by kaleb1107 on November 1st at 5:26 PM.

Z - MAN
Nov 1, 2007
5:29 PM
I have L.T, Gore, Fargas. I will be starting L.T. but I nee help between the other two. Gore would get the nod but his ankle scares me - Thanks for the help!! (1pt for receptions & 10yds rushing).

No1les
Nov 1, 2007
5:30 PM
Who to start? Wes Welker, K Curtis, or K Walter?
I like Welker, but Indy's D is great against the pass. But then they haven't played NE. So you see my dilemma!
Oh, and MacGahee or E Graham?

KLT
Nov 1, 2007
5:31 PM
pick 1 each Favre or Palmer at QB and Travis Henry or DeShaun Foster at RB???????

BAL BAL
Nov 1, 2007
5:40 PM
Derrick Mason or Donald driver? And also McGahee or lendale White?

zdrummer42
Nov 1, 2007
5:52 PM
I've been offered Dwayne Bowe and Bernard Berrian for Steve Smith. I already have Smith, Roddy White, Brandon Stokley, and D. J. Hackett. Should I take the trade?

Also, should I start the Colts or Eagles defense/special teams, or pick up the Seahawks or someone else from the waiver wire?

Last edited by zdrummer42 on November 1st at 5:53 PM.

MattyBoi1
Nov 1, 2007
5:56 PM
Alright need some advice fellas...I have westbrooke,####, and parker for my running backs...westbrooke and #### are must starts this week but parker is facing a tough baltimore d this week...should i start willie parker, lee evans, or selvin young?????

svreller
Nov 1, 2007
5:57 PM
ROGER:
WHICH 2 RB'S SHOULD I START THIS WEEK?
Laurence Maroney, Adrian Peterson(MIN), Ryan Grant OR Selvin Young.

THANKS,
SHELDON

mf_texans
Nov 1, 2007
6:04 PM
My league only gets points for TD or over 100yds. Who shoulI go with?
WideRecievers: H Ward , M Harrison , L Evans , or L Fitzgerald ( i need two)
QB: Rothlesberger , Garcia , Rivers ???

gunnerz
Nov 1, 2007
6:11 PM
With Holt on a bye and harrison looking to be out again, which 3 wr's of these? Welker, Cotchery, B.Marshall, D.Patten? Also, as RB2 L.Jordan or R.Grant?

kdkaire
Nov 1, 2007
6:15 PM
what are thoughts about Norwood or Watson at rb for this week? At qb Rosenfels or Brees?

gunnerz
Nov 1, 2007
6:17 PM
Roger, with J.McCown back as starting QB in Oakland, do you think L.Jordans stats will rise again since they wont have to run out of the shotgun so much as when Culpepper starts?

MHHALL85
Nov 1, 2007
6:22 PM
Ok, so I have the pleasure of having Tom Brady and Derek Anderson in a 1 QB league. Who do I start this week?

watso
Nov 1, 2007
6:40 PM
T.Jones R.B., K. Watson R.B.or K. Walter W.R. who to start in R/W slot?

jojosaints
Nov 1, 2007
6:57 PM
Hi Roger,

I have a question as to who to start this week in a points-per-reception leage as my 3rd WR. I have the choice of Chris Chambers or Donald Driver. You have Chambers rated more highly, but have Driver as a weekly must-start. Please offer some insight!?!

pantherosity
Nov 1, 2007
7:00 PM
Which D/ST to start... Steelers or Titans?

playa_hata
Nov 1, 2007
7:08 PM
Should I take a chance with Steve smith, or should i play one of the two between Boldin And Colston?

ChrisHenrysPO
Nov 1, 2007
7:12 PM
I have Kitna and Warner as my QB's. Kitna has been inconsistant and Warner well the elbow. I have Chad Johnson, Roy Williams, Greg Jennings, Brandon Marshall, Chris Henry, and Derrick Mason as my WR's and Addai, Rudi, Jacobs, Selvin Young, and Kevin Jones as my RB's. I currently have two offers out one is Roy Williams for Hasselbeck and the other is Williams and Warner for Hasselbeck and Andre Johnson. The guy with Hasselbeck has Anderson(Cle) and fairly thin at WR. Do you think those are fair trade offers or should I try something else? Thanks for any insight.


Oh and if you can help me you are the man unlike that dam Fabio at NFL.com he never answers me.

Last edited by ChrisHenrysPO on November 1st at 7:18 PM.

slickbirdie
Nov 1, 2007
7:12 PM
Every week I read you can't bench Palmer or Romo. Well, I have both and I keep picking the wrong guy, so who's the can't bench this week?

Greenson
Nov 1, 2007
7:14 PM
I have to start two running backs in a league that gives .5 points per carry and reception, 1 point per 20 total yards, and 6 for touches. Here are the options:
Kevin Jones V. Denver, Lendale White V. Carolina, Clinton Portis V. NY Jets or Selvin Young V. Detroit
Thanks

J=dub dallas
Nov 1, 2007
7:26 PM
ok i have brian westbrook as one of my starters. but who should be my second for this week? reggie bush, marion barber, or kevin jones.

Blue & White
Nov 1, 2007
7:40 PM
Who should I start Carson Palmer or Derek Anderson? Both are having a great season. Can you solve my dilemma?

UDONTNOME
Nov 1, 2007
7:42 PM
i hsve Portis, M ####, or Rudi johnson...please pick 2

Last edited by UDONTNOME on November 1st at 7:43 PM.

Strebyp
Nov 1, 2007
7:54 PM
Roger:
I have Grant, McGahee, J Norwood, and Chris Henry. I plan on starting Grant, but who else it all seems like a coinflip.

ltdandaman
Nov 1, 2007
7:57 PM
WEEK 9 QUESTION.
Roger: I have Tom Brady as my starting QB and Derek Anderson as my backup. Brady and Manning are facing off as Brady meets the #5 pass defense and Manning and his offense as well. Should I continue with Brady or should I start Anderson since Anderson goes against Seattle (#16 pass defense)? Who do you think will bring me more Fantasy Points? Thx, LtDan.

It's Ritz
Nov 1, 2007
8:29 PM
Who should I go with: Parker (Baltimore) or Jordan (Houston)?

Thanks!

3maple3
Nov 1, 2007
8:34 PM
I keep going back and forth, I have H. Ward, C. Chambers, I. Hilliard and R. White, which 2 should I start?

DARIN
Nov 1, 2007
9:00 PM
I HAVE SELVIN YOUNG AND NATE BURLESON. SHOULD I STICK WITH ONE OF THEM OR MAYBE PICKUP KEVIN WALTER OR RYAN GRANT? I HAVE A RB/WR POSTION AND 1 PT PER RECEPTION LEAGUE

Nantlas
Nov 1, 2007
9:06 PM
Hey Roger, any insights on F.Gore rdy to play, and if K.Watson will be the featured back on sunday? I have Watson, Gore, S.Young, and L.White not sure who to play, thanks for the help.

FootBallAllStar48
Nov 1, 2007
9:14 PM
play any New England wide receivers?

cway
Nov 1, 2007
9:17 PM
who should i start M. Barber III M. Jones-Drew S. Alexander i need to start 2

Last edited by cway on November 1st at 9:19 PM.

Guadarrama03
Nov 1, 2007
9:19 PM
Todd Heap or Vernon Davis

nugentj25
Nov 1, 2007
9:26 PM
Rudi Johnson or Kenny Watson? Looks like both will be playing

sportsmom01
Nov 1, 2007
9:28 PM
Roger-
I need to pick 3 WR: Kevin Curtis, Braylon Edwards, Shawn McDonald, Terell Owens, and Steve Smith. Who would you pick?

Also, if I were to trade one of my TE which one would you pick? Cooley or Shockey. Which one do you think will give me the best points in the long run?

Thank you!

tansformer
Nov 1, 2007
9:49 PM
Hi Rog,
big dilemma.... who should i start, Packers Def. or New Engalnd's Def. this week?

ithinkther4iam
Nov 1, 2007
9:55 PM
Pick 3:
1) Colston
2) D. Clark IND
3) Hines Ward
4) Wes Welker

Not PPR league. Thanks!

Mikey_MES
Nov 1, 2007
10:03 PM
After week 8 I have the SEA and WAS DSTs after dropping IND for SEA. I picked up WAS prior to week 8 just so nobody else would have them.

I played the waiver wire on Wednesday where I dropped the WAS DST and picked up D.J. Hackett as a week 10 bye WR replacement for either Wes Welker or Lavernous Coles. I know that WAS will probable score more DST point in week 9 than SEA, but I made the add/drop on the assumption that SEA has the MUCH easier remaining schedule and hence the ability to score more fantasy point than WAS for the remainder of the season. Was I wrong in this assumption?

Second, as a result of my four week 10 byes, I needed a kicker to replace Gostkowski...I picked up Folk just before week 8 when somebody dropped him when DAL had their bye. Now I have 2 top tier kickers.

My roster is stocked; Brady, Addai, MBIII, Jamal Lewis, Keith, Wayne, Welker, Coles, Calvin Johnson, and now D.J. Hackett along with Scheffler as my TE.

So is the projected point differential between Gostkowski and Folk for the remainder of the season close enough to justify dropping Gostkowski prior to week 9 (or week 10) IF a high end waiver wire pickup becomes possible, specifically a week 10 replacement QB for Brady? I know that Gostkowski is running up monster PAT numbers but Folk is kicking more FGs. Your thoughts please.

Last edited by Mikey_MES on November 1st at 10:24 PM.

wildcatcory
Nov 1, 2007
10:17 PM
My team is set for the rest of the yr. barring injuries. But would you hold onto Brandon Jackson? With Wynn out of the pic. do you think he will get much PT?

Page 1 of 9     1 2 3 Next > 
Add a comment  
ABOUT ME


RogerRotter
I am a FOX Sports Blogger who hasn't yet written a bio.
MY FAVORITE BLOGS
The Official FOXSports Blog
Mike Harmon's Fantasy Sports Blog
John Halpin's Fantasy Sports Blog
Time stamping is done in Pacific Time.