Rebuilding The White Sox

The 2005 White Sox was a collection of solid pitchers, solid defense and above average hitting.  There wasn’t a lot of power in the lineup outside of Paul Konerko, but overall the combination worked. 

However, many of those players have simply gotten old or aren’t as good as they were ages ago.  With a farm system weakened by trades and poor draft choices, there is a whole lot to rebuild.  Plus, with the Wild Card in the American League being a dogfight by no fewer than four teams, the chances of the Pale Hose making the playoffs are minute.

So, why not take this year to restock the farm, see what you have, and try to rebuild as best you can with what you have and what you can get.by selling off your collection of spare parts and arms and hope to rebuild from there.

So, let's take a look and see how I would fix this mess...

The Infield

Taking a look at my squad and contracts, I’ve got some solid options available for next year.  The heart of my offense, Paul Konerko and Jim Thome, are both on the books for next year and I can choose to bring back Thome in 2009 thanks to his option.  After that, I could slide Konerko over to DH, as I think his deense will be below average by them.  I’ve got a solid catcher in Pierzynski still on for next year and a suitable backup in Hall, so I’m good there. 

Joe Crede’s situation is going to be a tough one.  He’s sidelined for all of this year, but he’ll be back next year and should be  asolid regular.  Josh Fields is developing well so far and I think he’ll be a suitable starter at third in the future, but for now, I need him in Left Field, as I don’t have any great options.  I think he’ll be tolerable, but not spectacular.

That leaves my lineup looking like this, so far:

• 1 –
• 2 –
• 3 – Konerko (1B)
• 4 – Thome (DH)
• 5 – Crede (3B)
• 6 – Fields (LF)
• 7 – Pierzynski (C)
• 8 –
• 9 –

Not bad so far.  I’ve got the heart of my lineup stacked with some big bats that should hit for plenty of power.  I’ve also got an attractive trade piece in Crede, once his bat comes to life, that I could trade for a replacement left fielder once I slide Fields back to Third.  Pierzynski swings a solid stick, but I like his game calling and besides, he’s already on the roster.  Why screw with what looks to be a good thing.

Now for the rest of the infield.

I’ve got holes at shortstop and second base that need some filling.  Tad Iguchi is likely to leave as a free agent, but fortunately for me, Kenny Williams has already provided me with a second baseman internally.  Last month, Williams traded minor league hitter Aaron Cunningham to the Diamondbacks for second baseman Danny Richar, a player that’s described as near ready and plays a solid second base with some pop.  I see no reason why I shouldn’t give him a shot, so in goes Richar at second.

Shortstop is the other problem.  The free agent market for shortstops is #### poor this off-season and besides, I’ve got to spend money on some more important things.  I could try and give Houston’s Mark Loretta a shot at shortstop, as he’s having a solid year as Houston’s utilityman and his defense is still solid.  I could also try to look for some other options out there on the trade market, possibly the Angels’ Erick Aybar, but I like the Loretta option a lot.  His defense isn’t quite what I have in Juan Uribe, but the bat makes up for it.  So, why not roll the dice and see what happens.

With that said, let’s take a look at the lineup so far.

• 1 –
• 2 – Loretta (SS)
• 3 – Konerko (1B)
• 4 – Thome (DH)
• 5 – Crede (3B)
• 6 – Fields (LF)
• 7 – Pierzynski (C)
• 8 – Richar (2B)
• 9 –

It’s looking better.  But here’s where it gets worse.

The Outfield

Holy #### #### Batman!  I’ve got no outfield.   Well, not quite…

As I said, Fields could be a tolerable option in left, but that leaves me with two outfield spots open, center and right field. 

I've got one internal option in Ryan Sweeney, a toolsy outfielder that has the skills to play center and enough of a bat to play well in the corner.  He's going to strike out a lot, but he's got power and projects to be similar to Mike Cameron.

Right field is a different story.  I'm going to have to spend some money to fill the spot, as there isn't a whole lot in the system that I can use to not only capably play the field, but also to hit.  Sweeney is going to have to be in the number 9 spot, leaving me short a leadoff man.  Though right field is typically a power position, I don't need power as I've got oodles in the middle of the lineup.

In that case, I've got two options:

One is Eric Byrnes, who will likely be going to his hometown Giants.

The other is Ichiro Suzuki, a Kenny Williams favorite.

Of the two, either one would be a good fit, though I'm partial to bringing Ichiro in to hit at the top of the lineup.  Assuming he's wants to leave Seattle, I'm all over it.  If not, then I ask Byrnes if he's willing to bring his crow's nest hair to Chi-Town.

Either way, I've got to get one of them in to play right. 

So, let's take a look at my lineup, assuming that I bring Ichiro in.

Chicago White Sox

Last season’s club very much underachieved, as the White Sox collapsed in the second half of the season and went from Wild Card leaders to left out of the playoffs.  The White Sox did little to improve the team and seemed to be entering a rebuilding mode, as Kenny Williams has traded Freddy Garcia and Brandon McCarthy in exchange for prospects, hoping to protect against the rising market of starting pitching.  This decision will make or break his career in Chicago, as if the prospects all bust or are nothing less than solid starters, Williams will be blamed to dismantling a contending team that could have won another World Series.

Starting Rotation

1. Jose Contreras (RHP) – Contreras was lights out at the beginning of the season, but after the All-Star break, he seemed to have settled back into the form of a solid, but not elite pitcher.  Contreras is on the books for another couple of years and now appears to have shaken off all of the hell and inconsistency that plagued him when he was in New York.
2. Jon Garland (RHP) – Garland was the White Sox’s second half ace and was nothing but dominant.  Garland will likely be the second man in the rotation, where he and Contreras should be a solid one-two punch in the lineup.  Garland’s ability to induce groundballs is also a plus.
3. Mark Buehrle (LHP) – Buehrle has fallen hard in the past years, with the ERA skyrocketing and his win totals and effectiveness beginning to drop as well.  With Buehrle also entering his walk year, it’s also becoming more and more apparent that Williams no longer wants the lefty around, which came out during a snipe-fest during a press conference.  No matter what happens, the White Sox need Buehrle to return to his old self if they want to win.
4. Javier Vasquez (RHP) – So much talent, so little to show for it.  For all of Vasquez talents, he’s below .500 for his career and has been far less than what the White Sox hoped he would be when they acquired him for prospect Chris Young, who would now look great in White Sox pinstripes.  Vasquez is entering the last year of a four year contract signed with the Yankees, so he had better step up if he’s to get another team to give him a shot.
5. Gavin Floyd (RHP) – Obtained in the Freddy Garcia trade, Floyd was a first round pick in 2001 by the Phillies and thrived in the minors.  But upon hitting the majors, Floyd was hit hard and had become persona non grata to the Phillies after a poor 2006 engagement.  Floyd does have quality stuff, as his fastball is good and his breaking balls are fine, but he seems to have no confidence when he struggles.  It’s likely that he could become a serviceable middle of the rotation guy if the White Sox are able to get his confidence back.  With the lack of any solid options in Chicago, Floyd will likely start in the fifth starters role.

Bullpen

• Bobby Jenks (RHP) – Jenks is electric, with his fastball and he’s got one of the better breaking balls in the majors.  His biggest problem is his size, but Jenks has been rumored to have dropped weight in order to improve his durability.  Even if he doesn’t drop pounds, Jenks should be a solid closer again t his year.
• Mike MacDougal (Setup Man) – The foerm Royals closer proved to be a solid bridge to Jenks after the White Sox acquired him.  MacDougal still has that great fastball/slider combination, and as long as he stay’s healthy, the Sox will have a solid eighth-nineth inning combination for another year.  MacDougal can also spot close, in the event Jenk’s gets hurt.
• Matt Thornton (LHP) – Thornton has great velocity for a lefty and should make for a solid 7th inning relief option. 
• Nick Masset (RHP) – A possible closer, Masset has a great fastball that hits in the upper 90’s and a hard curveball that hits the mid 80’s at times.  The downside to Masset is his command comes and goes, though I think the White Sox will be able to get him right.
• David Aardsma (RHP) – Obtained from the Cubs for Neil Cotts, Aardsma also fits in with the new White Sox bullpen plan, as he too is capable of dialing it up in the high 90’s with good movement.  Aardsma, however, may be a one trick pony, as his changeup and slider aren’t great pitches.  If he can refine one of them, he’ll be a steal. 
• Andy Sisco (LHP) – Obtained from the Royals, Sisco struggled with his command and despite his occasions of success, his occasions of failure promoted the Royals to get rid of him.  Sisco is more of a reclamation prospect, as he projects to be a reliever, but it’s a good gamble considering that the White Sox got him for a bench player.

Starting Lineup

1. Tadahito Iguchi (2B) – With Scott Podsednik out for the near future, Iguchi is the best option to lead off, where his speed and plate discipline work well.
2. Rob Mackowiak (LF) –Mackowiak will be the starting left fielder and will be hitting in the second spot until Pods returns from the DL.  Mackowiak is solid enough where he won’t kill you for a short period of time and should provide roughly what Podsednik gave the Sox last season, minus the steals, until Pods returns.
3. Paul Konerko (1B) – Konerko had a solid season, hitting for power, average and playing first base well.  Even better, Konerko now began to get some pitches to see, courtesy of the big bat behind him.
4. Jim Thome (DH) – Thome proved that the White Sox were wise to gamble on him, as he took to being a DH like a duck to water.  Not only did Thome hit for power and production, but he was able to draw his share of the walks and take the pressure off of Paul Konerko, who was under protected in the lineup last year.  Thome should continue to raise hell in the lineup and should easily get to number 500 before the end of the season, adding to a potential Hall of Fame resume.
5. Jermaine Dye (RF) – Dye is entering free agency this season and it doesn’t look like Williams will try to extend him, as Dye is 33 and will likely cash in after a MVP caliber season, with 44 homers and 120 RBI in 146 games.  There's no reason to think he can't have another great year, and already there have been several teams, Texas included, that have expressed interest in Dye if he hits the market.  I think that Williams will give a good faith offer, but Dye is likely history after this year, leaving a huge hole in the lineup that’s not going to be easy to fill.
6. Joe Crede (3B) – Crede is one of the best third baseman in the league, but it’s clear that the White Sox are not really enamored with him, partially because of his agent, Sox Nemesis Scott Boras.  Crede is a solid hitter with power, plus is capable on defense, as he’s got great range, soft hands and an accurate arm.  While many would say it’s a no brainer to lock him up, the Sox also have Josh Fields lurking in the minors and have made it clear that they would rather play him sooner than later.   Hence, Crede’s name is bound to come up at the trade deadline again, unless Fields proves that he’s not ready for the big club yet.
7. A.J. Pierzynski (C) – Pierzynski has always been a fiery competitor, but one thing that’s often overlooked is how well he manages his pitchers.  That’s valuable, no matter how bad he hits.  As for the bat, Pierzynski doesn’t hit for power, but he’s solid enough to be hit around .290 with some power. 
8. Juan Uribe (SS) – Still solid defensively, Uribe’s bat is slowly starting to die and it’s unknown if he’ll be able to contribute anything defensively, thanks to all the issues he’s having off the field.  Williams had actually tried to trade Uribe for Texas shortstop Michael Young this past off-season.  Still no word if the Rangers have stopped laughing. 
9. Brian Anderson (CF) – Time is running out for Anderson to prove himself, as the White Sox are starting to wonder if he’ll be anything more than a fourth outfielder.  A slow start to the year could banish him to the bench.

Bench

• Darin Erstad (INF/OF) – Jim Rome’s Man Crush, Erstad could be a productive player off the bench, but to be honest, he’s been in decline to years and at this point might not be able to contribute much.  He should have accepted a minor league deal with the Angels to retire with the team.
• Toby Hall (C) – Solid defensively, but he’s got a rotten bat to match his attitude.  Can you believe this happy #### wanted the Dodgers to bench Russell Martin in favor of himself?
• Alex Cintron (INF) – Cintron is a capable backup that could take the starting job if Uribe isn’t able to hack it.
• Luis Terreo (OF) – Fourth outfielder will be on the roster until Podsednik is back.
• Pablo Ozuma (INF) – Capable utilityman finishes the bench.

Disabled List

• Scott Podsednik (LF) – Despite the fact that Pods will be back before the end of Spring Training, he will likely be out the first couple of weeks to allow him time to prepare for the season.  Pods was exposed last season, showing that he was merely a average player, not a great one.  He’s got speed and can slap the ball as well as bunt, but he’s far from a sure thing at the top of the lineup.  Unfortunately, there’s a lack of leadoff guys on this team, with Iguchi being a better fit at the two spot, so this team needs him to come back quickly.

Down On The Farm…

• John Danks (LHP) – The White Sox had to import their top prospect from Texas, who acquired the talented young right hander Brandon McCarthy.  The more and more I think about that trade, the more and more I think it was Garland that Williams wanted to move, but Texas was unwilling to give up Danks for a two year pitcher.  Williams then must have then thought about how much he wanted Danks before deciding he had to have him and offering up his youngest pitcher.  Danks has got solid stuff, with a good fastball that clocks in the low 90’s and a filthy curve and a great changeup that give him three great pitches to work with.  The only problem is that Danks is very prone to give up the long ball, but he’s still going to be a very good major league lefty.  Danks’ presence also means that Mark Buehrle is a goner.
• Ryan Sweeney (OF) – Sweeney has good size and good swing, some power potential and a strong arm in the outfield.  He’s got great range and enough speed to which he can play center.  The problem is that he hasn’t shown any of his power potential and is overaggressive at the plate.  Still, Brian Anderson is in the big club at the moment and it looks like the White Sox in the short term will keep him to allow Sweeney more time to develop.
• Charlie Haeger (RHP) – This knuckleballer still has a good shot to become the next Tim Wakefield if only the White Sox would give him a shot.  Unfortunately, he’s on Williams’ #### list and was mentioned in some trade opportunities.  He could get a start here and there, but he’s more than likely going to rot in Triple A.
• Josh Fields (3B) – Fields is a slightly younger and much cheaper version of Joe Crede.  Both are offensive monsters with great power and the ability to hit for average.  However, Fields has a long swing that will result in a lot of strikeouts in the majors, and despite a strong arm, he’s a poor defender.  Still, Fields will be a very good pro and depending on what happens with Joe Crede, he’ll be in the majors sooner or later, whether it’s with the White Sox or not.
• Gio Gonzalez (LHP) – Gonzalez is making his second run with the White Sox, for whom he was a first rounder in 2004.  Gonzalez has good velocity, hitting the mid 90’s and has a hard curveball and a developing changeup as well.  He is a strikeout machine that gets results, but at 5”11”, he’s small for a starter.  That hasn’t stopped some pitchers, but the stigma remains.  It’s likely that Gonzalez will stay at Triple A, where he and Danks should be one of the more talented lefty tandems in the minors, unless Chicago chooses to use him in the bullpen, of which he can do so now.

In Conclusion

Kenny Williams did what he set out to do when he said he wanted to add depth to the system to prepare for the departure of the staff in the future.  Most of the arms have great upside and Danks and Gonzalez should be future stars in the rotation.  The only problem is that none of this helps the White Sox in the short term and with the rotation now thin, and the flaws in the lineup starting to be exposed, plus the rise of the Tigers and Indians, Chicago is going to take a hard fall this year and miss the playoffs again, which may result in many White Sox fans questioning Williams’ judgment and criticizing his lack of action in improving the team.

Final Result:  Third Place in American League East

Tomorrow:  The Rangers Report Returns!!!