Edsox's Blog
by: Edsox
Edsox's posts about:
Salary Cap
more Salary Cap posts
Page 1 of 1
Baseball Played the Yankees Way: A No Limit Hold'em Game
Dec 23, 2005 | 12:55PM | report this

Johnny Damon's defection to the Yankees has the Red Sox Nation scrambling to find a scapegoat in the front office, while Yankee fans are patting themselves on the back for the sheer genius of their club's Ruthian-like steal of a deal.

But save the praise and hold the blame for another day, or better yet, another sport.

With no hard salary cap, signing free agents is simply money - not mind - over matter.

In the NFL, a general manager is forced to use intelligence, fiscal ingenuity, and player evaluation savvy to get the best team on the field, since all the GM's start the game with the same number of chips.

Imagine a poker game played by all the baseball GM's.  We've got players like the Pirates' and Indians's GM's, bringing about $40 million to the table.  And then there's George, with about $200 million worth of chips stacked neatly in front of him.  All the other GM's want to play a Limit game, but, of course, the game is in George's house, and he demands the game be No Limit Texas Hold'em.  What's more, if George goes all-in with a pair of deuces (see Kevin Brown) and gets beat, he can always shout, "RE-BUY!", and keep right on playing.

What about the "competitive balance tax", you say?  What about it.  The Yankees were about $80 million over the payroll limit this year, which, BY ITSELF was more than the payrolls of 19 other major league teams.  The Yankees will pay about $30 million for the TAX ALONE this year, which represents 50% or more of the payrolls of 11 other teams.  The Yankees #### taxes and player's salaries like so many peanuts.

Right about here, some of you might be saying to yourselves, "Well, Edsox is a Red Sox, so what's he complaining about?  His team's payroll is higher than every team out there but the Yankees?"  True, but it's not sour grapes.  I can't blame the Red Sox for having some limit to their spending, even if it's a dizzyingly high one.  Johnny's departure is no surprise and remember, I've seen worse - losing Roger Clemens.  I'd rather see the Red Sox payroll go down if it meant a fairer game.

In a fantasy world, I'd get Bud Selig and Donal Fehr together to rectify this ridiculous inequity and create a level playing field with a hard cap.  Of course, the player's union is too strong to let that happen.  It considers any cap a threat to its players' ability to "make a living".  And George would never agree to giving up his chip advantage.  A cap would mean some current owners would be unable to ante up and play the game (if there was a floor on the payroll as well as a cap), but I can't feel sorry for obscenely wealthy men who just aren't quite as obscenely wealthy as some others.  I'm not advocating subsidizing the small-market/miserly owner teams.  Sell your team to someone who can afford to play the game.

Sure, spending the most money doesn't guarantee a World Series championship - the Yankees have ONLY managed 26 championships since 1903 - but giving every GM the same number of starting chips would at least give everybody a fair shot to win based on merit, and not just money.    

1 Comment | Add a comment   categories: MLB, baseball, Boston Red Sox, New York Yankees, salary cap, MLBPA, Johnny Damon
 
« Continue reading Edsox's Blog
Page 1 of 1
ABOUT ME


Edsox
I was born and bred a Yastrzemski Red Sox, a Havlichek Celtic, a Bobby Orr Bruin, and a (gulp!) Steve Grogan Patriot.
MY FAVORITE BLOGS
The Official FOXSports Blog
Manziers' Blog
This and That
NorthSideFan's Blog
The Yard
Falstaff's Blog
IowaGirl's Blog
Stamps's Blog
Time stamping is done in Pacific Time.