It is chic, and sometimes justified, to rip on Isiah Thomas in his career as an NBA executive.
Now, I know Isiah earns a lot of his eminity. Some people can't reconcil the Two Zekes. Psychology isn't my field, but from where I sit, Isiah wears The Mask well - I'm talking DuBois, not Jim Carey. Outside, we get the baby-faced, doe-eyed face, soft voice with the Jell-O pudding smile. Inside, he's straight Michael Corelone. Grow up the way Thomas did, and you better have it.
That core, that life cred makes him able to relate to a Stephon Marbury. Kind of hard to pull nonsense of a man who's won two title on the court. Pity parties won't work on a brother who escaped a Chicago project (and on to a NCAA, two NBA titles, and the Hall Of Fame)that made Coney Island look like Disneyworld.
Celtic Nation still hold the "Larry Bird would be just another good player." line against him - and forget that it was Dennis Rodman who actually mouthed the phrase. Some Piston fans still feel that he shanked a great player and teammate in Adrian Dantley, and got him run out of Motown in favor of his lifelong pal Mark Aguirre.
And we won't even get into the whole CBA mess.
Since taking over as the Knicks GM in late 2003, Isiah has presided over 25 trades, five coaches (including himself), gone through moved more bodies than Tony Soprano (and Tony had a 4 year head start), and it has gotten the Knicks... what?
Well, after the Larry Brown "Reign Of Err", the Knicks actually looked like a playoff team at times, winning 33 games - 10 more than the year before under Brown - and holding down a playoff spot deep into March until injuries to Jamal Crawford, Stephon Marbury, and David Lee proved too much to overcome.
Along the way, the astute fan had to take note of something: For all of the Thomas trades and free agent signings that got rightly panned - my personal favorite was signing fat underachiever Jerome James to a 30 million dollar contract based on one good playoff series against a Kings team minus Chris Webber - Isiah's draft picks have been spot-on:
In 2004, he drafted Trevor Ariza late in the first round. Sought after by several teams after his rookie year, he became trade bait in the Francis trade.
2005: A pretty fair windfall. Channing Frye, who turned in a solid rookie season, and possessed enough promise that Portland welcomed him in the Zack Randolph deal. Isiah also plucked Florida's David Lee at number 30, already acknowledged as one of the league's best rebounders, and a big-time "energy" player off the bench. When he isn't being a knucklehead (or winning dunk championships), Nate Robinson has created a niche as a high energy 6th man, a fan favorite who packs a two-guard mentality into a 5-7 frame.
In 2006, well, do I have to remind anyone of Renaldo Balkman? From personal experience, I can tell you that the best part of attending the NBA Draft are are angry Knicks fans, and they absolutely...cut..LOOSE! The experts echoed the fans with universal disbelief and derision.
Then a funny thing happened - Balkman turned out to be a solid NBA player. He brought defense, passion, and reckless abandon to a team in dire need of all of it. The second Knicks pick, Mardy Collins, made it very easy for the Knicks to move Steve Francis (and his cap-strangling contract) on to Portland, which should tell you a lot. Note that other than Frye, the above mentioned players were drafted at number 20 or later. How many teams can claim even one decent NBA player acquired at similar spot in the draft?
And now that the dust has settled, Isiah can breathe a huge sigh of relief over the Eddy Curry deal. After foolishly not lottery-protecting either first round pick in the deal, it turns out that the Knicks got Curry for Joakim Noah and Ty Thomas. While both young Bulls are promising talents that will defend and run the court, Curry could very well outscore both men this year - combined. Meanwhile, the Bulls are still in dire need of a low-post presence. Curry had a breakout season last year as a low-post scorer - the scarest commodity in the league, almost making up for his criminal lack of rebounding.
Not such a bad deal after all, eh?
Looking back at the trades Thomas has made, Crawford is on the verge of developing into a prime-time scorer. Quinton Richardson will either start at small forward, or be a may be a valued trade chip. The Malik Rose for Nazr Mohammad deal was panned as a big win for the Spurs. Mohammad has since washed out with both the Spurs and Pistons, and Rose is a valued locker room presence, which was why he was acquired in the first place.
Francis came over for Ariza, and while that deal never worked for all of the obvious reasons, he did net the Knicks a 20-10 player in Randolph.
Above all else, give Zeke credit for trying. In a league where too many executives are scared to pull the trigger on a trade, Thomas is probably too aggressive. His trades have often been poor, and cap-hostile, but he makes them. And some of them do work, once we get past the Isiah-bashing.
And be honest - whose roster would you rather have right now? The Knicks with Curry, Randolph, Marbury, Lee, et al. or the Larry Bird's Pacers? Or the Celtics or T-Wolves?
How about the Knicks' roster versus the Lakers - sans Kobe Bryant?
Yeah, I thought so.
Now, if Isiah would just stay away from Ron Artest...
And nice to see you're one of the few who doesn't bash Zeke.
Sure, the jury is still out on the Knicks and if they only win 25 games next season, Zeke'll be gone and the experiment will be considered a failure.
Yet I think most believe, as do I, that this Knicks team will contend for a playoff spot next year.
And as for Balkman, cat by HIMSELF beat that first national championship Gator team twice and almost did a third time in the SEC Conference game. I commended Zeke on that pick.
Great post Dr. Midnight. I've been thinking many of these same exact things but never got around to writing them.
I am with you all the way...until the very end.
Maybe I'm a lunatic like Ron-Ron, but as a native of NYC I think it just might be the ONLY place where he can make it. He's got all his people there and as long as he is healthy we all know about his passion. Back home he would be playing for an entire city. I think he would be relentless on the court...but perhaps also finally wise enough to hold the mental part down.
Maybe it's just wishful thinking. I'm also a St. John's fan and they have been abysmal since Artest went pro. He's a hometown boy and one of my favs so I am always pulling for him. Maybe a return to NYC would be his perfect rememdy. Then again who knows?
Dr Midnight
To witness Thomas and what he's done with the franchise. Is akin to watching a mother throw out the baby , the bath water an the tub all at the same time. Suffice to say the Dolan family had better be holding either feet to the fire. Or some other part of his anatomy should the team fail miserably once again.
He's been as useful to the franchise as to the lookout was on board of the Titanic.
And we all know how that situation ended up don't we ?
i'm not a knick basher by any means and being a die hard piston fan my boy zeke is running the show there but i still dont see alot of defense on that team they got scoreres up the wazoo in curry .. z - bo .. and crawford .. but both curry and z - bo are bascially the same player .. in that there good low post players but dont really block shots nor are there not excatly somebody who make's the kobes and the brons and the wades quake with fear when they drive the lane .. they improve on offense but defense still wins playoff games and esp titles .. MAYBE they will sneak into the 8th spot in the weak east we'll see
zeke may have got the better end of the portland deal, and he definitely has drafted very well since he's been in charge but...........
he still is one of the worst GM's the nba has ever seen. Honestly would you pay Jerome James 10 times what he's worth? Would you pay almost any player on that team he signed as a free agent what he did?
He took the knicks out of the race for a bunch of severley overpaid guys who don't play well together and for what? to win 33 games, to making the playoffs next year as a 6 or 7 seed and getting elimated in RD 1, it's not worth it.
No matter how many good draft picks he makes, it wont make up for his previous mistakes.
Also, he's one of the dirtiest player/coaches the game has ever seen! He dissed larry legend, c'mon! I'm not just saying that, look at the facts, lol.
With all of the moves Zeke has made, he was bound to come up with a few good ones. Overall he has gone out and assembled a team of a bunch of misfits who want the ball at all times while giving minimal effort on the defensive end. I dont see any reasons for Knicks fans to be optomistic going into next season.
I'd like to think that some day Isaiah will be enshrined in the Culinary Hall of Fame. As he's more like a chef in conjuring up
a recipe. Rather than assembling a basketball
team. Looks good on paper and should taste good. But in the end the meal is a complete mess. But then again look at the feast that Wolfgang Pauck puts on at his restaurants. And fans of his are willing to pay several hundred dollars a plate for a sitdown meal. Is Isaiah that much different when it comes to Knicks ?
Iknow he's not the one who fixes the prices of admission when it comes MSG.
Gator, I wouldn't have paid Jerome James a warm 6-pack of Fresca. The guy is a stiff, and I think it was Thomas' worst move. And even Thomas knows it. But Thomas consistently finds talent low in the draft. I'm not even a Knicks fan - hell, I wish the Lakers had found ANY of the following: Frye, Robinson, Lee, Balkman, or Collins. All of them are better than any Laker draft pick of the last five years other than Bynum. So I have to give Zeke that.
Husker...the Millen comment may be true, but they have some promise...I'm cracking up over the nekkid pics comment.
Zack worries me because he looks like Baby Huey - I'm hoping like hell he can keep his weight down. Artest? He brings defense and toughness. He also isn't nearly as good an offensive player as he thinks he is, and most of the shots have to go through Randolph and Curry. I wonder if he can adjust to that.
And being in NYC hasn't helped Marbury as much as it should have. So I wonder about Ron. I think the Knicks need not only a shooter (Morris Almond from Rice would have been my pick) but a "character" guy, a stablizer.
G.H. Brooks (aka "Dr. Midnight" to his loyal fan base) is a 2-time Next Great Sportswriter (NGS) Finalist. One would think that bringing game like that would net me *something* - a cool icon to mark my site, some love from Fox Sports, cash, but noooo... :-)
I'm broadcasting live from New York City after a hiatus from the blogging scene, takes on life, sports, and whatever passing thoughts are shooting through my head. The good and bad ..passionate, logical, and on point.
It's a G Thing.... you can look me up at newjack1@eart hlink.net