The 2005-06 NBA season started with a marquee coach taking over a young team in transition (I know, it's rebuilding, rebuilding is such a dirty word you know?), featuring a star player with whom our marquee coach had previously clashed. Smart money had a blowup occurring by January, but with the coach getting the team to the postseason.
That Phil Jackson, something else isn't he…oh, you thought I was talking about Larry Brown? Yeah, so did I.
Peeps, I have to get this off my chest before we move on to teams actually doing something this season:
Larry Brown is overrated.
Yes, I said it.
Overrated. Repeat after me, New York Yankee-style:
O-verrr-Rated!
Clap clap clap clap!
I know the conventional wisdom had Larry (also known as Coach Right Way) as one of the all-time greats, especially after the Pistons spanked the Lakers in the 2004 finals. I was one of them. With the benefit of hindsight, we know a few things - that the Pistons were much better than we all thought, and that the Shaq-Kobe feud had torched team chemistry beyond all repair, with Karl Malone’s injury being the final straw.
But after two straight trips to the Finals, LB was known as the guy who wanted his team to play The Right Way. What we all should have asked was why didn’t anyone ask is Greg Popovich, Rick Adelman, or Phil Jackson if they coached The Right Way – especially after Pop outcoached Larry last year in the Finals? Is it possible that the “Right Way” talk went to his head?
Well, the results are in. It’s ugly, and I mean Chris Kaman ugly. The Knicks were a 33 win team last year, and they’d have to run the table to get to 27 this year (I'm thinking 23 wins tops).
Worse, they have no freakin’ excuse.
Isiah Thomas may have his weaknesses – ok – a LOT of weaknesses as a GM, but he’s brought in solid young talent with Channing Frye, Eddie Curry, and James Robinson to go with Trevor Ariza and David Lee. Stephon Marbury has more issues than the New York Times, but only The Big O has averaged 20+ pp and 8 assists as Stephon has done. Throw in Quinton Richardson and Jamal Crawford and .500 should have been a lock.
Instead we get the unholy mess that is the Knicks, and now Brown recently whined that the players are “tuning him out”. Brother Larry, human beings have an annoying tendency to do that when they constantly get barraged with noise. Note to Coach RightWay, when you constantly run down your players in the press, it becomes noise. Isn’t it telling that Brown has gotten little public support from anyone? Even given Marbury’s obvious problems playing team ball?
Does Kevin Garnett really want to come into this zoo?
Out here on the Left Coast, Phil Jackson gets mixed reviews, but you don’t hear him and Kobe killing each other. Granted, the Lakers have fewer youngsters than the Knicks, but Smush Parker (who wasn't even in the league last year) and Kwame Brown have made solid strides this season – especially Kwame in the last month since Chris Mihm was injured.
Kwame Brown? The same Kwame who was sent home by the Wizards last year – even when they lost his replacement to injury in the playoffs? Lamar Odom is finally playing three good games in a row. The Lakers look like they’ll win 44-45 games – in a tougher conference - and will almost certainly make the playoffs.
Kobe is getting along publicly with Phil, AFTER Phil hammers him in a book. (I grant you that if Coach allows you to put up 35 shots a game, you shouldn't have a problem getting along with anyone.) Yet even the most ardent Kobe-basher has to concede that Kobe has made more of a committment to team ball, even while scoring a pace unseen since Jordan in 1987.
Meanwhile, Coach RightWay and Starbury have gone to the mattresses. No surprise, Larry Brown hasn't met a point guard he ever got along with. No surprise, since Larry was trashing Marbury at the Olympics. This is the same guy who couldn't appreciate Mark Jackson (only Number Two on the all-time assist list) until he traded him away, and then had to trade back to get him. Which coach would you rather have?
Given LB’s history, the Knicks will almost certainly rebound. Somehow, Thomas will move Marbury or Francis (although if a superstar doesn’t come back in the deal, they shouldn’t do it), and Brown will feel safer. The young players will mature, and Larry will be the hero.
But not to this writer.
Honestly, I’m hoping Step and Right Way stay together. Life has been boring since Kobe and Shaq have made up (kindasorta). A good blood feud is necessary in sports. And the potential of Stephon going Sprewell on Little Larry is just too good to pass up.
Meanwhile, a maturing Laker team is peaking going into the post-season.
Well done, Doc... I'm curious to see what kind of response you get to this post. While I don't necessarily agree that Brown is overrated (a lot of extenuating circumstances with the Knicks beyond his control), it's definitely a different perspective on a guy who is usually heralded as one of the better coaches in NBA history. I agree with one thing though, nobody should feel bad for Larry Brown. He's made his living going from bad team to bad team and turning them around. He shouldn't whine now that he's with the Knicks -- he had to know what he was getting himself into.
Keep up the good work and feel free to email anytime...
--Ty
does anyone think larry brown would have 5 nba titles if he had just stayed at any TWO of his previous 35 NBA coaching gigs for more than 4 years?
does anyone think he'd have 8 NCAA championships if he would have stayed in college? at the same team? i'm not a big fan, but the guy can coach. it might take a year for the stars of the team to buy in to what he wants done, but he CAN coach. it probably wont happen in NY, just because there's too much #### going on there. the thing i dont like about him is that he gets so close to winning it all with a team (detroit excluded) and then he slithers his way out of town for his "dream job." guess what larry, you're officially there now, if not because the Knicks really were your dream job, then because they're the only team you hadnt already coached.
i still dont understand why phil jackson went back to the lakers, other than $10 million. this was for his girlfriend, probably to shut her up about marriage or something. he had plenty of options with teams where guys would have loved to play for him. just think, if he had stuck it out, he could probably have landed the miami gig when they pushed van gundy out.
Nice blast.
I tend to think many of these "new era" coaches are very overrated. I'm not saying a bad coach could have lead the Bulls/Lakers, but when you see the chemistry explode in the press, it seems to me someone has lost control.
Which brings us to Larry Brown. I too feel he's overrated, and perhaps a little weird. The bouncing from team to team, public flirtations with jobs while under contract, it is very unbecoming.
The year in Knick land was flat out vulgar. I tend to think Isiah had/has mad respect for Coach Brown, so many rules could/should have been laid out before he took the check.
Again, another team out of control and where is the coach during this.
The great Jim Rome used to ridicule Phillip for allowing the Lakers to whine in the press incessantly. After his book, I'm guessing he blamed Kobe more than fat-but-talented Shaq. Nevertheless, fans hate hearing bickering outside the lockeroom and Phillip was/is the captain.
Again, great post.
EJ Passeos
G.H. Brooks (aka "Dr. Midnight" to his loyal fan base) is a 2-time Next Great Sportswriter (NGS) Finalist. One would think that bringing game like that would net me *something* - a cool icon to mark my site, some love from Fox Sports, cash, but noooo... :-)
I'm broadcasting live from New York City after a hiatus from the blogging scene, takes on life, sports, and whatever passing thoughts are shooting through my head. The good and bad ..passionate, logical, and on point.
It's a G Thing.... you can look me up at newjack1@eart hlink.net