Were you as shocked as I was? On 3rd and goal with a minute remaining, Peyton Manning just fell on the turf so Adam Vinatieri could kick his fifth FG to go up by nine. Sure, it was the safe call, but this was after all, the NFL poster boy, king of media hype, regular season legend, Peyton Manning. You mean you don't let him take a shot at the end zone? No.
No you don't. And what I saw yesterday led me to believe that Tony Dungy was actually coaching the Colts, instead of deferring to Manning. It was a nice change. I'm thinking that Dungy has learned from the example of Mike Shanahan (managing John Elway) who knew: 1. You very rarely win playoff games without running the ball 2. When your QB has a history of choking, you don't put the ball in his hands if you don't have put the ball in his hands. Deep down, I kind of root for long suffering chokers, except Marty Schottenheimer, and I secretly hope that Manning finds a way to break the "yeah but" curse. I also know that if it meant winning a SB, he'd be just fine if the Colts kicked nothing but FG's the rest of the way.
It also merits mention that you can't win solely on defense. I told a friend earlier this week that I didn't think the Ravens would get past the Colts because I have no faith in Steve McNair come January. McNair's record in his last six playoff games before last night, 2-4. Now he's 2-5. McNair is not a smart QB. As a matter of fact, he rivals Mike Vick for the slowest brain ever at the position, and dumb guys don't win playoff games. McNair stupidly jammed the game killing pick into the hands of the Colts. Where was all of his veteran leadership then? I don't which was more ridiculous, McNair's pick or Ray Lewis' Halloween costume in the post game press conference.
NO/PHI
The Saints are a well coached team. The Eagles came out on fire last night, almost knocking out Reggie Bush early, taking a few leads and playing ferocious D. But Bush and the Saints were resilient and poised all night long. These teams were very evenly matched and when that is the case, the difference is coaching. What does that say about the veteran, Andy Reid. He's a one speed coach, a la Bill Cowher, who can't elevate his team come January. I felt terrible for Jeff Garcia who played his heart out and at 36 or 37 will likely have few if any chances to take a team to the SB again.
Can the Saints win out? I don't think so. For some unthinkable reason, I still believe in Rex Grossman and the Bears.
The Coaching
The truth is beginning to come out in Pittsburgh. Ever since Art Rooney Jr. made the remark that "it's about time we won our fifth SB" bfore the 2005 training camp I knew Bill Cowher's time was short. If the obvious distance between Cowher and Art Jr. at Cowher's resignation (not retirement) PC wasn't enough, now the word from a Cowher confidant is that "it didn't have to end like this". This only makes me more sure than ever, that Art Jr. only needed one disaster follow up to a SB miracle to push the slobbering goon out the door. At some point or another, word will get out that Art Jr. grew tired of the cheerleading act and the postseason disasters and paved the way for Cowher's exit.
The Pittsburgh press is throwing Cowher a bone by saying the Steelers are interviewing Chandler Gailey at Cowher's recommendation. Gailey was the guy who would have replaced Cowher in 1998 had Danny boy done the right thing and fired him back when he should have.
Just when you think Arthur Blank has learned his lesson, he hires a project to coach a failure. When you look at Mike Vick's career, it so closely mirrors that of Kordell Stewart it's amazing. And we all know how it ended up for Korkie. If the Falcons wanted a last crack at developing Vick, the best choice was undoubtedly Ken Whisenhunt. Whiz is adept at getting favorable matchups, without sophisticated in-play adjustments, which plays to Vick's very limited mentality. And Whiz has NFL experience. Who was the last college coach to make a successful transition to the NFL? Jimmy Johnson, 17 years ago. My guess is that Blank just wanted a puppet coach so he can try to run the team from the press box. It doesn't matter though, more freedom for Vick is just extra rope with which to hang himself.
I'm not sure that Raider and Cradinal fans even care who coaches their teams as long as the departing coaches are gone. Denny Green and Art Shell are the poster children for the lobby to discontinue affirmative action. Have you ever seen two more clueless idiots on an NFL sideline. Both teams would have been better off if the ballboy's had taken over.
So Nick Saban took the guaranteed money and ran. So what. Players do this all the time and no one questions it. Yes, Saban handled it poorly with the press, what else is new? When did Saban ever handle the press well? The guy took a cushy job for a lot of money, and will be in control of almost all aspects of his coaching destiny instead of pandering to crybaby prima donnas. Tough choice, huh?
The Rumors
There was some talk that, if Garcia took the Eagles deep, Philly might trade McNabb to Minnesota. I doubt this. But not because McNabb is the better QB, especially for the WC system. As a matter of fact, watching Garcia run the Eagles offense has been a thing of beauty, and watching McNabb jammed into a dink and dunk offense with his cannon arm and incredible physical gifts has been excruciating at times. But if the Eagles unload the injury prone McNabb, and I think they should, their first job is to draft a QB, because the diminutive Garcia is always one good hit away from retirement and not to far away from Social Security either. My guess is they keep McNabb and Garcia for one more season and try to get a better, younger fit for the WC, like Matt Schaub.
Herm Edwards is growing less and less confident in Trent Green. His threat to scrap the playbook and firing a close friend of Green, assistant John Shea, is evdience of that. But this why Edwards will never take a team deep in January. Don't get me wrong, Chief fans, I love Edwards as a person. But he's kidding himself if he thinks it's anyone's fault but his that the Chefs didn't have a better regular and post season. Edwards brought back Green too early and stuck with him too long. The Chefs were your typical sixth seed, a team that got lucky late and didn't deserve to be in the postseason. Edwards kidded himself about that too.
Will Bill Parcells stay in Dallas? Who cares. Parcells is obviously well past his prime but has assembled some excellent talent. Jerry Jones would be smart to keeep Parcells on where he belongs, as GM. Except that's the job Jerry thinks he's doing.
Will Marty retire if he wins the SB? The answer is the same as what I'll do if I win the lotto. Why not discuss what society will do to handle the cleanup when Pigs start flying? Who are we kidding here. Cowher managed to dump a 15-1 season in the ####, what on earth makes anyone think that Chokenheimer can't burn a 14-2 season to the ground in January.
Perfect idea about Parcells as GM in Dallas. He can still get his players, but when it comes to playcalling in the game, the young coaches are kicking his ####. I've heard rumors that Lovie Smith would be willing to listen to JJ if the Cowboys went after him for next year or the following year. He'd be a better option in my opinion. Who knows.
I'm a Raider fan.
In my opinion AL Davis is Coaching from his cushy Luxury suite.
So I don't think it matters who the coach is.
Also , you seem to be more of an opinionated bigget than football fan. "affirmative action"
Last edited by Jrock1 on January 14th at 12:37 PM.
The title of the post is "Dungy finally gets it". I've always admired Lovie Smith and would be thrilled if he gets a ring.
Tomlin? He seems a hell of a lot smarter than Cowher, but maybe I'm damning him with feint praise.
Either way. The only disappointment with Tomlin is that he'll retain LeBeau (at least for now). When I heard it was between him and Grimm, I felt that we'd be more likely to get a long needed house-cleaning with Tomlin. That 52-Okie, ZB #### needs to be scrapped for an NFL defense.
