BobbyMcMahon's Blog
by: BobbyMcMahon
BobbyMcMahon's posts about:
Italy  SOCCER > Europe > Italy
more Italy posts
Page 1 of 2
1
2
Euro 2008 - Day 21
Jun 27, 2008 | 7:52AM | report this
I try to answer as many questions as possible but I know that I have missed a number over the last few days. As much as I would like to sit and blog most of the day, time is a problem and I am afraid that it is just not possible to answer every query that is posted.


UEFA World Cup Qualifying
Another off day at the European Championships and an opportunity to look ahead at World Cup qualifying in Europe that will get underway in less than eight weeks when Kazakhstan plays Andorra. The bulk of the game day one fixtures go on September 6.

There are eight groups of six countries and one of five. The group winners will qualify for the finals. The eight best runners-up will be qualify for a play-off round in which there will be four two-leg ties and the winners will qualify to play in South Africa in 2010.

In deciding the best runners up spots the eight groups of six will not have the results against the countries finishing bottom counted.

Group 1 Portugal, Sweden, Denmark, Hungary, Albania and Malta

Group 2 Switzerland, Greece, Israel, Moldova, Latvia and Luxembourg

Group 3 Czech Republic, Poland, Northern Ireland, Slovakia, Slovenia and San Marino

Group 4 Germany, Liechtenstein, Azerbaijan, Wales, Finland and Russia

Group 5 Turkey, Spain, Belgium, Bosnia Herzegovina, Armenia and Estonia

Group 6 Croatia, England, Ukraine, Belarus, Kazakhstan and Andorra

Group 7 France, Romania, Serbia, Austria, Lithuania and Faroe Islands

Group 8 Italy, Bulgaria, Republic of Ireland, Cyprus, Georgia and Montenegro

Group 9 Netherlands, Scotland, Norway, Macedonia FYR, and Iceland

Based on what you have seen over the last three weeks has your views changed on who might qualify from Europe?



Prediction Update
We are down to only two possible winners. LHJS currently has 36 points and Geniusatwork has 34 points. With ten points available to the tournament winner it comes down to Germany (LHJS) or Spain (Geniusatwork).

Whoever gets it wrong will drop down the standings as there are a significant number of people sitting with figures in the low 30s and with either Spain or Germany to win.

The unofficial prediction rabbit Carlos has fallen to the folly of allowing his heart to rule is head. He picked Portugal to beat Spain in the final and so he has stalled out at 42 points.


Comment of the Day
“WSC statisticians are also compiling a report on behalf of a secretive but influential global organisation that we are not at liberty to name. Findings include: Simone Perotta's birth in Ashton-under-Lyne has been mentioned a total of 15 times by the two TV channels and national radio; the local TV directors have missed live action while running a slow motion replay 23 times; the BBC panel have offered truisms disguised as analysis on 65 occasions; Alan Shearer has appended “for me” to his half-time comments on 19 occasions, conclusively establishing that the views expressed are his alone rather than those of the entire BBC production team in Vienna, or Geordies everywhere.” – When Saturday Comes on television coverage in the UK.


Stat Fact
The highest scoring European Championship final was in 1976 when Czechoslovakia and West Germany drew 2-2. In the penalty shoot-out Uli Hoeness’ spot kick cleared the crossbar with room to spare and then Antonin Panenka chipped the winner down the middle as Sepp Maier anticipated a shot to the corner.


True or False
Uli Hoeness was the last German player to miss a penalty in a shoot-out at a major international championship?

52 Comments | Add a comment   categories: Germany, Spain, Portugal, Uli Hoeness, Antonin Panenka, Sepp Maier, Alan Shearer, Simone Perotta, Netherlands, Scotland, Italy, France, Romania, Austria, Russia, Turkey
 
Eurio 2008 - Day 18
Jun 24, 2008 | 9:45AM | report this
Another break day and so an opportunity to answer some questions.


DanielgreggSomething I've noticed about this tournament, don't recall if it's something unique or not: there've been so many records broken. Croatia broke some kind of record when they beat Germany, Turkey broke their record against the Czechs, the Dutch beat their 30-year record against Italy, and Italy beat their 30-year record against France, and now Spain banished their longstanding record against not only Italy, but their June 22 jinx.

You probably don't put too much store in these records. I just think it's been interesting to see so many games one after another with pundits pointing out these records before almost every game, and then they go and promptly break them--so consistently.


Bobby – There have been a good number of these instances. I think it would need a statistician to provide more intelligent comment.  But you also have to consider that international match ups don’t happen every year or sometimes even every second year and so extended records of 20 or 30 years may only be less than a dozen games.  Something that happens in domestic league leagues


LHJS - I hope one day the America's can combine to form a great tournament like EURO's. 8 groups, 5 or 6 teams per group, winner and second place team gets an invite. Every country between Chile and Canada would have a chance. I think it would be great fun for all soccer fans. A nightmare for police but still as we see on TV it could be great.

Bobby – This is something that comes up on a pretty regular basis. I can’t see either Federation amalgamating for the purposes of World Cup qualifying but maybe there is just a small chance that they could get together for a regional championship.

Here is a précis of an article I wrote for “WSC – When Saturday Comes” back in April 2002 just after the Gold Cup of that year.

“……The more astute readers will have noticed that South Korea and Ecuador are not Central American, North American or Caribbean counties. Since it’s inception in 1991 the Gold Cup has invited guest teams to compete, not something that lends credibility to the competition. It’s simple: when you invite outside teams to enter a regional championship it’s no longer a regional championship.

Can anyone imagine the European Championship inviting Brazil, Argentina and Cameroon to fly in for a game or two? In the past we’ve seen Peru, Colombia and Brazil turn up along with South Korea and Ecuador. To date no guest has won the Cup but two have reached the Final.

This time around only Mexico drew well in the early stages and after they lost in the quarter final to South Korea, average attendance dropped dramatically. Despite the USA reaching the final where they beat Costa Rica 2-0, the last four games in the competition attracted less than 22,000 fans. Cup organizers were quick to point out that the Cup was up against the National Hockey League all-star game and the Superbowl weekend. It begs the question - why would you schedule the Gold Cup against these events in the first place?

The problems facing the Gold Cup are strikingly similar to those facing CONMEBOL and the Copa America. Copa America with the ten member countries of CONMEBOL has to invite two guest countries in order to get to a workable number. Honduras, Mexico, Japan, the USA and Costa Rica have all taken part in the Copa in recent years. There is, however, a solution – the Pan American Cup.

Never heard of it you say? That’s because it’s time to drop both the Copa America and the Gold Cup and start a new sixteen team tournament to be held once every four years with no guest teams.

To ease fixture congestion the tournament could be scheduled just before or just after the European Championship. A Pan American Cup makes sense for everyone, including the long suffering fans.

From a CONCACAF prospective it gives their member countries the badly needed challenge of better opponents. The participation of Brazil and Argentina would increase television revenue in the US and generate greater media exposure throughout North America.

With the imminent demise of the ill fated and vastly unpopular Confederations Cup the need to identify regional champions no longer exists. If the Pan American Cup could live up to half of its potential, the qualifying competitions would generate interest.

By holding the tournament two years after the World Cup, qualification standings in each confederation could form the basis of awarding automatic spots in the Pan American Cup, perhaps the top five finishers in each. As tradition dictates, the previous winner would get a bye along with the host country.

With four spots remaining, three could come from a Central and South American qualifying competition while the remaining spot would be from a North America and Caribbean tournament.

Is there hope that CONMEBOL and CONCACAF would give up some of their power and merge the two troubled competitions? From a CONCACAF prospective they run a competition of no value, so they have little to lose by making a move. CONMEBOL’s view is likely to be different given the Copa America is the oldest international tournament in the world.

However, FIFA has already told the South Americans that an eighteen game World Cup qualifying competition can’t continue if the Copa America is held every two years. The South American qualifying group generates tremendous interest and a great deal of money.

It’s not something the CONMEBOL countries want to lose so the status quo may not be an option. The alternatives are changing the Copa America to a four year format or make a bold move and go for a Pan American Cup.”  


Shmish - What's your take on the criticisms that are being leveled on coaches such as MVB and Donadoni? It's predictable that Aragones or Loew will also be condemned by media and bloggers. I think all of these men seem to have done a good job, but I'm not a soccer analyst.

Whether a team is outplayed or outcoached, do we always have to point fingers at the coaches? Surely as Bobby suggests, we should pay attention and offer praise to the winners, when praise is due. One man's or team's success doesn't necessarily equate to another's failure.



Bobby – When a team loses the coach more times than not becomes a lightning rod for criticism. At club level there is almost always a game coming within a week or so and the coach and team have an escape route. That’s rarely the case at international level with friendlies and competition spread out.

Coaches know the “rules” when they sign on as unfair as they may be.  But each defeat produces knee-jerk reactions from the fans and the media and the pressure builds on the national associations for a change to be made. Without having lived through it I doubt many of us can truly understand the constant pressure that coaches all operate under.

So much of it comes down to managing expectations going in, unfortunately as fans most of us have expectations that are unrealistic. I’m waiting for the day when a fan admits he would have picked a different team than the one the coach did and because the team won its obvious the coach knows what he’s doing and has not lost the plot!


Terry 63 - Hey Bobby, we're missing the Tartan Army at these major tourneys. Start checking the census rolls to see if there are any Scots with Brazilian grandmothers.  Of course...I meant to say Brazilians with *Scottish* grandmas! But either way couldn't hurt.

Bobby – At least Scotland has shown some improvement over the last couple years.  Under Berti Vogts a team made up of Brazilian grandmothers might have been a better option. That’s what you meant wasn’t it?


ZUCO2 - I was watching the FSR yesterday and I heard Derek say that there was 9 minutes of added time in a qualifying game in Asia. Shouldn't FIFA have a rule that allows referees to give a certain amount of stoppage time? A sort of limit that shouldn't be broken?

Bobby – So what you do in the situation where there was a serious injury and possibly even a couple of serious injuries? Or the game is delayed because of a streaker? It is up to the referee to judge how much stoppage time should be played I don’t see any benefit by capping it – and in fact I think the opposite is true, it would lead to more abuse.


Exponents - Bobby, off topic, but let's say the USMNT needed a new coach (I think you'll agree that they do)...who should they try to get? Of course this begs the question of who would actually want to coach the USMNT.

Bobby – No, I actually don’t agree. To date Bradley has won the only competition the United States has entered since he became coach (Gold Cup) so why would you be looking to replace him?


Rowdies33 - I haven't seen much heat on Van Basten for his tactics during the game. RVP played on the right flank where he has played before in this tourney, but he was always looking for the cutback and Heitinga wasn't getting forward so there was no width on the right and then by not bringing Robben in on the left there was no presence going forward on the left to stretch the field.

Given the difficulties of set pieces for the Russian defense, wouldn't crosses from wide positions have likely given them problems? Of course, the Russians dominated the play and perhaps nothing changes, but it seemed like the Dutch offense was basically using 1/2-3/4 of the width of the field making the Russians defensive pressure much easier to employ. Thoughts?


Bobby – It might be a bit pointless turning up the heat up on van Baston given that we all knew he was finished with the Netherlands after this tournament.  You do make valid points however. 

But the problems that the Russians were experiencing from set pieces were coming from in swinging free kicks on the left. Robbin would be delivering more conventional out swinging crosses with his left foot so I’m not sure the two would necessarily be connected.  I was surprised that the Dutch did not try and force the Russian full backs to defend more and instead allowed them to attack almost at will.

I think the brilliance of Hiddink’s strategy was to counter the counterattack by pinning the Dutch so deep and not giving them time on the ball that they are unable to use the counterattack tactic that had been so lethal in the group stage.


LHJS - I almost forgot, Bobby did I catch Carlos?

Bobby –Carlos picked up nine points in the quarterfinal round and has 37 points. However, he only has one team left and that is Spain. He has Spain down as beaten finalists.


RINGO - Do those who predicted the third place game lose points?

Bobby – No, they just have to suffer the public embarrassment of adding games that don’t exist.


Comment of the Day

“I bumped into Howard Webb, the English referee, at Zurich Airport last Friday. He was on his way back to Manchester, having not been retained for the knockout stages of Euro 2008, after his controversial decision in the final minutes of the match between Austria and Poland. Webb was no different to a lot of other Englishmen at leading tournaments, really, in that he was eliminated by penalties.” - Martin Samuel in The Times.


Stat of the Day
1: Number of the past 52 goals in the tournament to have come from a defender — Christian Panucci  - From Bill Edgar of The Times.


 
 
31 Comments | Add a comment   categories: Croatia, Czech Republic, France, Italy, Spain, Canada, Chile, Peru, CONCACAF, CONMEBOL, Luis Aragones, Marco van Basten, Joachin Lowe, Russia, Netherlands, Arjen Robben, Guus Hiddink, Howard Webb, Christian Panucci
 
Euro 2008 - Day 17
Jun 23, 2008 | 9:29AM | report this
After sixteen straight days of football we have a two-day break before the semifinals get underway. A chance perhaps to indulge in some observations?

In terms of entertainment and quality this edition of the European Championships far exceeds what was on show four years ago. It’s on par with 2000 but the latter stages of the tournament in Netherlands and Belgium had two fantastic extra time games and one that was not unlike the Spain and Italy (except this time Italy supposedly played with 11 men for the full 120 minutes) game yesterday. The last three games of Euro 2008 will decide where it will ultimately sit in the list of great tournaments.

And that partially segues to the fallout from the last quarterfinal match. Contrasting the column inches and tone of blog posts emanating from North America dedicated to Russia versus Netherlands against Italy versus Spain makes interesting reading and may give an indication of how far the game still has to go in these parts.

It seems to me that more effort has been dedicated to trashing the Italy - Spain game than celebrating and reveling in the quality of the play and the spectacle that was Russia versus the Netherlands.

There are far too many posters and writers overly concerned about the reaction from non-soccer fans and sportswriters in North America. It is if a multitude of North American soccer fans/bloggers/posters decided after yesterday’s game to strap on the cilices and whip themselves bloody before the soccer-haters of North America even had a chance to mobilize.

It is a reaction of a bullied child that would opt to inflict self administered pain rather than allowing the bully the pleasure. It is also the reaction that does nothing to grow the game in North America. It was a poor game yesterday - you get them from time to time and not only in soccer. That’s just the way it is and self-flagellation isn’t going to change anything.

Celebrate the great, praise the beautiful, rejoice that on occasion we get to enjoy 120 minutes of footballing heaven the likes of which we were privileged to see on Saturday. No one every grew anything worthwhile by wallowing in the negative and when you respond to soccer-haters gripes all you are doing at best is reinforcing the darkside. At worst it runs the risk of becoming a self-fulfilling prophesy.


As group winners Portugal, Croatia and Netherlands fell at the first knockout stage you could hear a rising crescendo of “it’s not fair.” Perhaps it’s not fair, but there is nothing that grants a right to go on and win a tournament just because a team starts well.

Tournament play is about pacing, peaking at the right time and taking advantage of the breaks when they come your way. You don’t get bonus points for artistic impression, going unbeaten in the group stage or even qualifying after only two games.

You only have to glance at the history of major tournaments such as the World Cup and the European Championships to see how difficult it is to lead from start to finish (as it is in any competition in any sport). Now and again a country will come along and be able to pull off such a remarkable achievement.

Performances by the likes of Brazil in 1958 and 1970, and France in 1984 are extremely unusual and it is easier to find examples of teams burning intensely in the early stages but flaming out spectacularly while failing to reach their overall goal.

Hungary (1954), Netherlands (1974), Italy (1978), Denmark (1986), Spain multiple times, and the daddy of them all Brazil in 1982 played memorable football in the early going only to fail in the later stages.



Comment(s) of the Day

“Previously, Daneiele de Rossi and Alessandro Di Natale had failed for Italy, while Daniel Guiza, of Italy, also had his effort saved.” –Kevin McCarra in the Guardian.

Now that I have seen that it can happen to the best I don’t feel so bad about Fernando Cannavaro!

It was later corrected to read - “Previously Daniele de Rossi and Alessandro Di Natale had failed for Italy, while Daniel Güiza, of Spain, also had his effort saved,” but as of this morning Antonio was still being referred to as Alessandro.


“European football has been at a crossroads for some time but the dull, negative style that won the championship for Greece four years ago – and let's be honest propelled Rangers to the UEFA Cup Final and to a lesser extent served Scotland well in their qualifying group – has been found wanting in the face of a new dawn.

Manchester United showed the way at club level by winning in Moscow and at least four of the quarter-finalists in the current tournament have also seen the light. If ever a tournament has rekindled our enthusiasm for the beautiful game and provided a hopeful vision of the future, this has been it. If we are honest, we must also admit that this vision has been helped by the fact that the home nations were not there to cloud the view.” – Pat Nevin in the Scotsman on Sunday.


Prediction Update
With three games to go here is a list of the top fifteen. *Indicates no countries left.

31 points – LHJS
28 points – Willisman, jekka75*.
27 points – Sangria*, SheehyCFC, alwaysinthekop.
26 points – sounderfan, jstlouis, nakleenazar*, stonefacesurf*.
25 points – ErnestoM, anti-madridista, musc01, cpinkhouse, redfan4ever.


CONCACAF World Cup Qualifying Update
El Salvador 3-1 Panama
El Salvador wins 3-2 on aggregate

Bermuda 0-2 Trinidad & Tobago
Trinidad & Tobago wins 3-2 on aggregate.

Netherlands Antilles 0-1 Haiti
Haiti wins 1-0 on aggregate.

Cuba 4-0 Antigua and Barbuda
Cuba wins 8-3 on aggregate.

Guyana 1-2 Suriname
Suriname wins 3-1 on aggregate.

Barbados 0-1 United States
United States win 9-0 on aggregate.

Costa Rica 3-0 Grenada
Costa Rica wins 5-2 on aggregate.

Mexico 7-0 Belize
Mexico wins 9-0 on aggregate.

St. Lucia 1-3 Guatemala
Guatemala wins 9-1 on aggregate.

Canada 4-1 St Vincent & Grenadines
Canada wins 7-1 on aggregate.

You can find the make-up of the groups for the next stage by following the link.

It is poorly laid out but it is supposed to indicate three groups of four with the the top two moving onto a final group round. The top three will qualify and the fourth place side finisher will play-off against the fifth team from South America.

89 Comments | Add a comment   categories: Russia, Netherlands, Italy, Spain, Hungary, Denmark, Brazil, France, Daniele de Rossi, Antonio Di Natale, Daniel Güiza, Rangers, Manchester United, USA, Mexico
 
Euro 2008 - Day 16
Jun 22, 2008 | 9:26AM | report this
Thank you to all the posters and readers who take the trouble to read the blog each day. A special thanks to some of the new posters who have come to the blog during the Euros. I hope you can stick around.

Quarter Final
Spain vs. Italy
Preview – Of all the quarter finals this one is the most beautifully and finely balanced. For each Italian ying, you can find a Spanish yang. Recent history in major tournaments suggests a win for Italy, but current form points towards Spain.

If Gianluigi Buffon is the best goalkeeper in the world then Iker Casillas can’t be far behind. I.D. Luca Toni as the definitive target man and scorer and Spanish fans can counter with the speed and strength of David Villa and Fernando Torres.

Cynics might even point out that the both sets of centre backs are on par – each pairing looks good when the ball is at the other end of the park. Spain is likely to be without Carles Puyol and a central defensive pairing of Valencia’s Raul Albiol and Carlos Marchena can only increase the level of confidence……if you are Italian.

There again, you also get the feeling that Christian Panucci and Giorgio Chiellini constitute a make shift solution to a defence that has lacked the composure normally provided by Fabio Cannavaro.

The full backs are another saw-off. At their best Zambrotta and Grosso (Italy) and Ramos and Capdevilla (Spain) can get forward and effectively support the attack from wide positions.

So where will this one be won and lost? Not surprisingly it will be probably come down to who can most effectively control the midfield. There is a difference in how both sides normally line up. Italy favour a 4-3-2-1, Spain 4-1-3-2. For Spain the first-choice defensive midfielder is Marcos Senna and he will prowl the area in front of the back four looking to control (probably) Cassano and Perrotta.

However, the most intriguing contest will be between Italy and Spain’s defensive and attacking midfield trios. Barring surprises Spain will start Xavi and David Silva with Iniesta (who hasn’t had a particularly good tournament so far) or Fabregas.

All three players are comfortable on the ball and are first rate passers – their problem is if it comes down to heavy lifting can they match Ambrossini and De Rossi? Ambrossini would appear to be the logical replacement for the suspended Gennaro Gattuso while Daniele De Rossi, who has enjoyed a great tournament since being left on the bench for the first game against Netherlands, will join him in the engine room.

The suspension of Andrea Pirlo means that Italy needs to find another playmaker to centre Ambrossini and De Rossi and only option is Roma’s Alberto Aquilani. The responsibility will be a test for Aquilani who at 24 next month is the youngest member of Italy’s squad.

His international experience for country and club is limited and we have become use to him being revered to as a future star. If Italy is to move on to the semi finals it may well be that being a star of the future just won't hack it anymore and the future must start today.

Referee: Herbert Fandel, assistants: Carsten Kadach, Volker Wezel (all Germany), fourth official: Frank De Bleeckere (Belgium)


Spain 0-0 Italy (Spain win 4-2 on penalty kicks)
It was a terse, tense and and a largely forgettable one-hundred and twenty minutes with the penalty kick decider providing the only moment of sustained excitement.

While the absence of Gennaro Gattuso and Andrea Pirlo did not hurt Italy defensively, they certainly missed the playmaking of Pirlo. What he would normally accomplish in one pass was taking two of three today. And when the pass finally arrived at its intended target, Spain had anticipated the danger.

Spain enjoyed the vast majority of possession but with De Rossi and Ambrosini sitting deep their midfield found it difficult to spring Villa and Torres as Italy plugged the passing lanes. And so chances for both sides were extremely limited. Even the substitutions made by both coaches failed to break the predictable pattern.

And so it came down to penalties. De Rossi’s miss gave Spain the upper hand but Buffon’s save from Guiza opened the door for a turnaround. However, Casillas got the better of Di Natale and it was left for Fabregas to sink the fifth and winning penalty for Spain.

Best for Italy on the day were Chiellini and De Rossi while for Spain Silva and Senna worked tirelessly.  Spain goes on to play Russia in the semifinal, and for Italy it is Goodnight Vienna.


Comment of the Day

“I’ve been reading what foreign journalists say about Holland. There is one recurring story: the Dutch always destroy themselves through infighting, but this time they haven’t yet. This shoddy half-truth misses the point about Dutch football. Holland are good precisely because our players quarrel about football.” – Simon Kuper.



Prediction Update
Russia’s win yesterday was more bad news for many of you who posted predictions. Netherlands was a popular pick to make it to at least the semi final stage while those picking Russia to progress that far was limited to two or three. The updated standings will be posted tomorrow at the conclusion of the quarter finals.


126 Comments | Add a comment   categories: Spain, Italy, Gianluigi Buffon, Iker Casillas, Luca Toni, David Villa, Fernando Torres, Carles Puyol, Raul Albiol, Carlos Marchena, Valencia, Giorgio Chiellini, Christian Panucci, Fernando Cannavaro, Fabregas, Daniele De Rossi, Alberto Aquilani
 
Euro 2008 - Day 11
Jun 17, 2008 | 7:28AM | report this

Netherlands 2-0 Romania

Romania took an ultra-extra cagey approach to this vital match trying to ensure that they didn’t offer Netherlands a chance to counter attack. By the end of the ninety minutes they had won the battle but had categorically lost the war.

The safety first approach worked in the first half as the Netherlands were forced to build their attacks rather than benefitting from the super quick passing that had caused Italy and France so much trouble.

However, Netherlands did have chances with the best falling to Robben but he shot wide with only Lobont to beat. Boulahrouz of all players was enjoying far too much space when attacking down the Dutch right and more might have come from a couple of his raids.

Romania’s passing was inconsistent with far too many sloppy passes or players being caught in possession. Early in the second half any thoughts Romania may have harboured about holding back and then pushing for a late winner were crushed when their sloppy play infected the back four.

The Romanian defence allowed Afellay to chase down an errant Robben cross completely unmolested. The Dutch midfielder played the ball back into the box and again the defence failed to deal with it. This time the ball found Huntelaar and Romania was in trouble.

Needing to up the tempo Romania was unable to change gears as their passing deteriorated under the pressure of now having to chase the game. Maruis Niculae who started in place of his namesake Daniel was a willing front runner but sorely lacking the skills to bother the Dutch defence.

Mutu was a sporadic presence as the two received virtually no support from the midfield. The replacement of Maruis by Daniel made no difference as the Dutch continued to deal with any Romanian threat with a minimum amount of trouble.

Another goal from the Dutch, this one from Robin van Persie, only served to highlight the gulf between these two teams on the day.

Romania go home and leave thinking of what might have been if only Buffon had been a split second slower or even a fraction of a second quicker. But even then the game against the Netherlands offered up a second chance to Romania and they bottled it.


France 0-2 Italy
The share of the play might have been even but Italy should have had France dead and buried before half time. French supporters can look to the penalty kick awarded against Eric Abidal and the red card he received as the turning point in this game but there ominous signs before that moment  for France.

The injury to Franck Ribery early in the game was another blow to France but even a fully fit Ribery for ninety minutes would not have mitigated the problems caused by a porous central defence and a ponderous in midfield.

The lead up to the penalty decision was a microcosm of France’s early problems. A free kick in the centre circle was played to Pirlo. With no pressure on him Pirlo had time to look up and clip a 35-yard pass over the head of Abidal and onto the toe of Toni. Abidal attempted a tackle was never going to finish up as anything but a dead-cert penalty kick.  

Toni was giving the French defence fits before Abidal’s sending off and he continued after the dismissal. Grosso also hit the post from a free kick and Perrotta came close to breaking through. 
French coach Raymond Domenech’s decision to withdraw substitute Nasri (he had replaced Ribery) shortly after Abidal’s red card will be a source of heated discussion amongst French fans. A more fateful decision was perhaps taken before kick off in opting to deputize full back Abidal as a centre back.

You can certainly argue about the merits of centre backs Jean-Alain Boumsong and Sébastien Squillaci.  But asking a regular full back to play centre half when Domenech had two specialist centre-backs available begs the question why did he bother picking Boumsong and Squillaci to start with?

Daniele De Rossi’s deflected free kick was the clincher and put the game well beyond 10-man France. De Rossi was excellent throughout and his performance was a reminder of Donadoni’s mistake in not playing the Roma midfielder against Netherlands in the first game.


Comment of the Day

"That is the happiest I have ever been after a match in which I didn't score," Ruud van Nistelrooy after Holland beat France 4-1.


Prediction Update

LHJS, Sounderfan, knvoetbal all recorded 100% scores is predicting the outcome of Group B. Sounderfan is the only poster with a 100% record at the conclusion of the first two groups. He leads everyone by at least two points.

95 Comments | Add a comment   categories: Romania, Netherlands, Ruud van Nistelrooy, France, Italy, Lobont, Arjen Robben, Boulahrouz, Afellay, Huntelaar, Maruis Niculae, Mutu, Robin van Persie, Daniele De Rossi, Luca Toni, Eric Abidal, Jean-Alain Boumsong, Sébastien Squillaci, Roberto Donadoni, Raymond Domenech
 
Euro 2008 - Day 7
Jun 13, 2008 | 5:51AM | report this

Group C

Romania 1-1 Italy

This was an amazing and enthralling match that hung in the balance right through to the final whistle. And in the end Italy and Romania remain in contention for a place in the last eight come the final round of group play next Tuesday.


Italy has Gianluigi Buffon to thank for their first point of the tournament and making sure that they maintained a fragile grip on continued participation. Panucci was got caught red-handed trying to hog tie Niculae for little apparent reason and with ten minutes left Romania got a chance to almost certainly send Italy home.

But the Italian keeper guessed right on a well struck but poorly directed penalty kick from Adrian Mutu. Buffon got his right hand to the shot which then deflected onto his trailing leg and clear.

Earlier in the second half Mutu turned opportunist has he anticipated a header from Zambrotta back to Buffon. By the time the Italy right back had realized what he had done Mutu had struck a rising shot behind Buffon and high into the net. It was however a very short-lived lead as Italy equalized with their next attack.

Giorgio Chiellini intelligently opted to direct a header down and across the Romanian goal rather than go for glory and Panucci snuck in at the back post to tie the game up.

It was almost inconceivable that this match could reach half time scoreless. Italy set off at a cracking pace and keyed on the right side of the Romanian defense early. Contra came in for special attention as Grosso moved forward to support the Italian attack and Petre instead of playing in midfield found himself augmenting Contra at right back.

It took fifteen minutes for Romania to find any attacking intent but once they settled chances were created in quick succession. Tamas and Mutu had shots well saved by Buffon while Rat went narrowly wide from a long range effort and a deflected Chivu free kick came back of the post with the keeper helpless.

The series of close encounters reinvigorated Italy and the first half finished with Lobent making a couple of fantastic saves before being beaten by a Toni header. Fortunately for Romania the assistant referee’s flag went up for offside; replays showed that Toni was not offside.

The best game of the tournament so far in my book and the Group of Death, for once, has lived up to the pre-billing.


France 1-4 Netherlands

It was the sort of day that you want to bottle and preserve only to be opened when you need reminding of how compelling, beautiful and thrilling this sport can be. While Italy and Romania produced an opening act that threatened to one up the main attraction, the Netherlands and France rose to the challenge and produced a display for the ages.

A look at the final score might lead you to conclude that this was a terrible performance by the French. But rather this was a case of an astonishing performance from the Dutch. Think the World Cup Final of 1970 when Brazil beat Italy 4-1. Was Italy that bad? The truth is it didn’t matter because on that day Brazil was just so brilliant it did not matter who wore the other jerseys.  

And so it was today as the Dutch put on a master class of passing, movement, shooting and finishing that was quite breathtaking. While 4-2-4 made way for 4-3-3, then 4-4-2 and now 4-5-1 or 4-2-3-1 the basic premise of attacking and defending has remained stunningly simple. When you attack you want to create space, when you defend you want to shrink the space.  A simple concept yes, but something that is exceedingly difficult to pull-off - especially when the opposition is constantly trying to counter.

It was concept that the Dutch executed  today to perfection as they sliced open a French midfield with a display of passing that was devastating. No ten yard square passes to slow the tempo ala Makelele. The Dutch bypassed the French midfield with passes that changed defence to attack in the blink of an eye. Meanwhile, the French midfield with two anchors (Makelele and Toulalan), that should in theory have been the perfect foil to the Dutch counter attack was left gasping and chasing shadows.

Netherlands back to back wins against the World Cup winners and runners up from only two years and by a clear three goals each time is unprecedented in my memory. The question for the Dutch is what do they do for an encore?
France and Italy both remain alive with the winner of Tuesday match also needing the Dutch to maintain their undefeated streak when they face Romania in order to move on.

 What a day.

Man of the match - Rafael van der Vaart. Amongst a number of very honourable mentions Ruud van Nistelrooy. Can't play as a lone striker? Hmmm.


Comment of the Day

"If someone talks about my private life, for example, I'll give them a good punching. I'm not interested in suing. I like to sort things out my way" - Luiz Felipe Scolari.
124 Comments | Add a comment   categories: Romania, Italy, France, Netherlands, Luiz Felipe Scolari, Giorgio Chiellini, Adrian Mutu, Gianluigi Buffon, Zambrotta, Christian Chivu, Claude Makelele, Jeremy Toulalan, Ruud van Nistlerooy, Rapael van der Vaart.
 
Euro 2008 - Day 3
Jun 09, 2008 | 5:00AM | report this

France 0-0 Romania

It was an ultra-cagey first half with neither team willing to commit players forward in numbers during open play. Free kicks and corners offered up the best opportunities but even then the keepers were rarely tested.

You got the feeling that if France was willing to up the pace and go after Romania that they would be rewarded. Tamas and Goian looked very comfortable when balls were played high into the Romanian area but there was a sense that the ball played quickly along the ground might have provided them with a far greater challenge.

What's more Romania's goalkeeper Bogdan Lobont seemed at times to be intent on writing his own special chapter focusing on passbacks in the David James and Fabian Barthez best seller "Adventures in Goalkeeping."

The second half pretty much replicated the opening forty-five minutes. France held an edge but Romania defended with composure and opted to play the ball through the midfield once the French had surrendered possession.

The French midfield cried out for a player to quicken the tempo of the game but Makelele’s forte is to slow the pace down not to speed it up and France rapidly ran out of attacking ideas. The French attack was not helped by a thoroughly badly balanced pairing of Nicolas Anelka and Karim Benzema.

The second half in particular was close to a mirror image of the Scotland game in Paris last fall. A well organized and motivated team comfortably holding off a French side that enjoyed a significant edge in possession but was unable to change the flow of the game as their attacking options weathered and died.

A draw means that no matter the outcome of the second round of games both countries will enter the final round with a chance of progressing.

Man-of-the-match

My pick would be left back Razvan Rat. Tidy in possession and quick in the tackle Rat not only kept Franck Ribery quiet but he also found time to move forward to support the Romanian attack.



Italy 0-3 Netherlands

Italy is well known for starting tournaments slowly but rarely has it cost them as dearly. This time it has and even though the opening goal was undoubtedly offside the Italians were badly outplayed by a Dutch side was quicker in thought and in execution.

The second Dutch goal was as beautiful as the first one was offside. The classic counter attack came after van Bronckhorst had cleared what could have been own goal of the Dutch line and fed the ball up the left touchline. A glorious 40 yard cross field pass was headed down by Dirk Kuyt and Sneijder showed great composure and skill to hook the ball passed Buffon.

A third could have come before half time as van der Vaart played the pass of the tournament to date. He slipped awonderfully weighted pass behind Materazzi who looked like he was running in sand to van Nistelrooy. This time Buffon deflected the shot over.

Italy looked to be poorly equipped to come back from a two goal deficit. A five minute spell from the 70th minute, when first Toni and then Grosso got behind the Dutch defence and then Pirlo was denied off of a free kick by van der Sar, was the best Italy could offer.

Ironically the best Italian spell of play ended with another Dutch counter attack and another key contribution from Giovanni van Bronckhorst. Gio was smart enough to know that Kuyt would not score one-on-one with Buffon and craftily positioned himself for the cross that came after Buffon’s save. When Kuyt sent in the cross van Bronckhorst had a free jump and the goal bound header was helped across the line by Zambrotta.

A nightmare for Italy; a dream for the Dutch. But remember……it is only the start.

 
Stat check – Italy’s worst defeat at major finals since losing 4-1 to Brazil in 1970?

Comment of the Day

This was a description of Croatia midfielder Luka Modric by Peter Mallett in Saturday’s Globe & Mail.


“Traditionally known for tireless running, precision through balls and brute physical strength this 22-year-old midfielder personifies all that makes the red, white and blue checkered shirts of Croatia revered.”

Hmmm - Brute strength? At a little over 5 foot 9 inches and 143 pounds soaking wet Modric might be considered a brute by an under-13 girl’s team but that is about it.

Prediction Pool

Here is a breakdown of the winners as predicted on the blog by Friday’s posters.

Germany 25.9%

Spain 19.5%

Italy 13.9%

France 13.0%

Portugal 12.0%

Netherlands 9.2%

Romania 2.8%

Russia 1.9%

Croatia 0.9%

Sweden 0.9%

Thanks to everyone who took the contribute their predictions and I will post the interim leaders at the completion of the group stage.

93 Comments | Add a comment   categories: France, Romania, Italy, Netherlands, Luka Modric, Peter Mallett, Germany, Spain, Italy, Portugal, Russsia, Croatia, Sweden, Dorain Goian, Tamas, Bogdan Lobont, Claude Makelele, Razvan Rat, Franck Ribery, Nicolas Anelka
 
Euro 2008 - Part 6 of 10.
Jun 02, 2008 | 6:34AM | report this
Group C
Only France and Germany have won the Henri Delaunay Trophy more than once. The French won as hosts in 1984 and again in 2000. There were a number of occasions when the 2000 win could have turned out very differently. Spain’s Raul could have sent the the quarter final into extra time but missed a last minute penalty for Spain and France won 2-1.

The semi final against Portugal was decided in favour of France by an extra time golden penalty kick from Zidane. And in final Italy was only seconds away from winning when Sylvain Wiltord equalized sending the game into extra time. David Trezeguet then scored a golden goal winner just before the break.


How they qualified

France’s two losses to Scotland made the headlines but once all was said and done the French still scored more goals (25) and conceded fewer (5) in finishing second by three points to Italy in Group 8. Thierry Henry was France’s leading scorer with six goals.


The Coach
Outspoken and eccentric Raymond Domenech continues to prove the old adage about never underestimating an over achiever. Domenech succeeded Jacques Santini after France lost in the last eight of Euro 2004 to the eventual winners Greece.

Although France made heavy weather of World Cup qualification and the first two games of the finals against Switzerland and South Korea they did reach the World Cup Final before losing on penalties to Italy.

His selections are rarely anything but controversial and he has done it again setting off a heated debate after leaving the likes of Djibril Cisse, Philippe Mexes, Mathieu Flamini (recalled later as cover for a Patrick Vieira) and Hatem Ben Arfa out of the final squad of twenty-three named last week.


Key Players
Karim Benzema does not have the name recognition of some of his illustrious team mates but over the next decade this youngster could become one of the world’s best players. Don’t be surprised if Domenech uses him sparingly but given a chance the 20-year-old could turn a game or two France’s way.

Franck Ribery impressed everyone in Germany two summers ago and a move to Bayern Munich last year led to him being named Bundesliga Player of the Year. Ribery has skill, close control, pace and creativity in a package that makes even the best defenders fear him.


Great Euro Memory

Two second half goals from Platini and Bellone gave France a 2-0 win over Spain in the 1984 final in Paris. The 90th minute clincher from Bruno Bellone was the fourteenth goal scored by France in the tournament finals and the only goal scored by a French striker.


Synopsis
Every tournament has to have a GROUP OF DEATH and for Euro 2008 Group C is it. When you look at the players available to Domenech it is impossible to dismiss France as legitimate challengers for the trophy. They have talent in every area but a nagging feeling persists that they may find it difficult to breakdown a resolute defence – ala Scotland.


Coming Up in World Cup Qualifying
Austria, Romania, Serbia, Lithuania and Faroe Islands will be the opposition in Group 7.



Italy has now made it to the last four finals and won the tournament in 1968.


How they qualified
After an opening game home draw to Lithuania and a loss in Paris to France Italy then rattled off a sequence of nine wins and a draw to win Group 8 by three points over France and five points ahead of third place Scotland. With five goals Luca Toni led the scoring for Italy.


The Coach
Roberto Donadoni has achieved something that Italy failed to do after winning the 1982 World Cup and that is reaching the following European Championships finals.


Key Players
Luca Toni may have only scored twice in Germany in 2006 but he was pivotal to Italy’s success. A massive player -both in size and in temperament.

The reigning bad boy of Italian football Antonio Cassano is in Donadoni’s squad and all eyes will be on how both deal with a situation that may be inherently unstable. Cassano was the only bright spot for Italy four years ago in Portugal but missed out on the 2006 World Cup after falling out with everyone except the baker, the butcher and the pizza-maker.

There is a quality to the Italian squad that few can match.


Great Euro Memory
The Championship win in 1968 against Yugoslavia after a replay takes pride of place. Down by one to a first half Dragan Dzajic goal with around ten minutes to play, Domenghini’s equalizer took the final to a replay. Goals from Luigi Riva and Pietro Anastasi saw Italy lift the trophy in the rematch.


Synopsis
Enter the tournament as World Champions although they were not assured of qualification until they had faced Scotland in the last group game. A

A team that should probably be building for a title defence in two years in South Africa but Coach Roberto Donadoni has generally stuck to experience with a significant number of World Cup winners returning two years on.

The trio of Antonio Di Natale, Marco Borriello, and Fabio Quagliarella does however offer the coach some interesting options up front. No one would be surprised if Italy won the tournament but by the same token a traditionally slow start in the anointed GROUP OF DEATH could prove very costly.


Coming Up in World Cup Qualifying
Drawn in Group 8 with Bulgaria, Republic of Ireland, Cyprus, Georgia and Montenegro.


Part One - History and Background


Part Two – Portugal and the Czech Republic.


Part Three - Switzerland and Turkey.


Part Four - Austria and Croatia.


Part Five - Germany and Poland.



Part 7 coming up on Tuesday - Netherlands and Romania.

Predictions Part 10 - June 6



33 Comments | Add a comment   categories: France, Zinedine Zidane, Sylvain Wiltord, David Trezeguet, Thierry Henry, Raymond Domenech, Mathieu Flamini, Patrick Vieira, Karim Benzema, Franck Ribery, Michel Platini, Bruno Bellone, Italy, Luca Toni, Roberto Donadoni, Antonio Cassano, Dragan Dzajic, Luigi Riva, Pietro Anastasi, Antonio Di Natale
 
Euro 2008 - Part 1
May 28, 2008 | 9:04AM | report this
Over the next ten days the blog will be dedicated to the 2008 European Championships. Part 1 covers some of the history of the tournament and an outline of the groups, game-days, officials and some odds and ends. From there is will be a preview of two teams per day and on day ten will come the predictions.

History
The idea of holding a European Championship came, like many other good sports ideas, from a Frenchman.

Henri Delaunay, who was head of the French FA, proposed a tournament for all European counties even before the first World Cup was held in 1930. However, it took until the formation of UEFA in Basle, Switzerland in June 1954 for the notion to take root.

Delaunay was appointed as UEFA’s first General Secretary but died in 1955. In recognition of his leadership and vision the European Championship trophy was named after him.

The tournament started out as the European Nations Cup in 1960 and consisted of group games with the winners moving on to a knock out round of eight. The winners at the quarter final stage would then play semi-finals and a final in the country of one of the final four.

This format continued until 1980 when all eight group winners competed in two groups with the group winners playing for the trophy and the two group runners up playing for bronze. Four years later in France a cross over semi final round was added and the format was maintained when West Germany hosted in 1988 and Sweden in 1992.

When England held the finals in 1996 the number of qualifiers expanded to sixteen countries and from that point onwards the competition became a cash cow for UEFA. It is now arguably the third most watched sporting event in the world after the FIFA World Cup and the Summer Olympics.

Past Finals
1960 USSR 2-1 Yugoslavia

1964 Spain 2-1 USSR

1968 Italy 1-1 Yugoslavia
Replay Italy 2-0 Yugoslavia (extra time)

1972 West Germany 3-0 USSR

1976 Czechoslovakia 2-2 West Germany (Czechoslovakia on 5-3 on penalties)

1980 West Germany 2-1 Belgium

1984 France 2-0 Spain

1988 Netherlands 2-0 USSR

1992 Denmark 2-0 Germany

1996 Germany 2-1 Czech Republic (on a golden goal)

2000 France 2-1 Italy (on a golden goal)

2004 Greece 1-0 Portugal


Top Goalscorers
1960 Ivanov (Soviet Union) and Jerkovic (Yugoslavia) 2 each.

1964 Pereda (Spain) and Novak (Hungary) 2 each.

1968 Drazij (Yugoslavia) 2.

1972 Gerd Muller (West Germany) 4.

1976 Dieter Muller (West Germany) 4.

1980 Allofs (West Germany) 3.

1984 Platini (France) 9.

1988 Van Basten (Netherlands) 5.

1992 Bergkamp (Netherlands), Brolin (Sweden), Larsen (Denmark), Riedle (Germany) 3 each.

1996 Shearer (England) 5.

2000 Kluivert (Netherlands), Milosevic (Yugoslavia) 6 each.

2004 Baros (Czech Republic) 5.


The Groups and Games Days

Group A
Switzerland, Czech Republic, Portugal and Turkey – June 7, 11, and 15.

Group B
Austria, Croatia, Germany and Poland – June 8, 12 and 16.

Group C
Romania, France, Italy and Netherlands – June 9, 13 and 17.

Group D
Spain, Russia, Greece and Sweden – June 10, 14 and 18.

Quarter Finals

Winner A vs. Runner-Up B – June 19, Basle

Winner B vs. Runner-Up A – June 20, Vienna.

Winner C vs. Runner-Up D – June 21, Basel.

Winner D vs. Runner-Up C – June 22, Vienna.

Semi- Finals
Winner A or Runner-Up B vs. Winner B or Runner-Up A – June 25, Basel.
Winner C or Runner-Up D vs. Winner D or Runner-Up C – June 26, Vienna.

Final
June 29, Vienna.


The Stadiums
St. Jakob-Park, Basel, Capacity 42,500.

Letzigrund Stadion, Zurich, Capacity 30,000.

Stade de Geneve, Geneva, Capacity 30,000.

Wankdorf Stadion, Bern, Capacity 32,000.


Stadion Tivoli, Innsbruck, Capacity 30,000.

Worthersee Stadion, Klagenfurt, Capacity 30,000.

Wals-Siezenheim Stadion, Salzburg, Capacity 30,000.

Ernst-Happel Stadion, Vienna, Capacity 50,000.


The Officials
UEFA has assigned 12 referees and 24 assistants (plus eight fourth officials) to officiate the games. Each referee trio is made up of a referee and two assistant referees from the same country. The trios have worked together as teams over the last year.

Referee - Konrad Plautz (Austria); Assistants Egon Bereuter & Markus Mayr.

Referee - Kyros Vassaras (Greece); Assistants Dimitrios Bozatzidis & Dimitrios Saraidaris.

Referee - Lubos Michel (Slovakia); Assistants Roman Slysko & Martin Balko.

Referee - Frank De Bleeckere (Belgium); Assistants Peter Hermans & Alex Verstraeten.

Referee - Roberto Rosetti (Italy); Assistants Alessandro Griselli & Paolo Calcagno.

Referee - Manuel Mejuto Gonzalez (Spain); Assistants Juan Carlos Yuste Jimenez & Jesus Calvo Guadamuro.

Referee - Howard Webb (England); Assistants Darren Cann & Michael Mullarkey.

Referee - Pieter Vink (Netherlands); Assistants Adriaan Inia & Hans Ten Hoove.

Referee - Peter Frojdfeldt (Sweden); Assistants Stefan Wittberg & Henrik Andren.

Referee - Herbert Fandel (Germany); Assistants Carsten Kadach & Volker Wezel.

Referee - Tom Henning Ovrebo (Norway); Assistants Geir Age Holen & Jan Petter Randen.

Referee - Massimo Busacca (Switzerland); Assistants Matthias Arnet & Stephane Cuhat.


Returnees
The Netherlands, France, Portugal, Spain, Czech Republic, Germany, Sweden, Russia, Switzerland, Croatia, Italy and Greece all appeared at the 2004 finals in Portugal. Missing from the 2004 line-up are Denmark, England, Bulgaria and Latvia.

Five coaches Luiz Felipe Scolari (Portugal), Lars Lagerback (Sweden), Karel Bruckner (Czech Republic), Kobi Kuhn (Switzerland) and Otto Rehhagel (Greece) return from 2004. Portugal, the Czech Republic and Greece all appeared in the last four in 2004.



Tomorrow - Portugal and the Czech Republic.

64 Comments | Add a comment   categories: Henri Delaunay, European Championship, Euro 2008, Austria, Greece, Slovakia, Italy, Spain, England, Netherlands, Sweden, Germany, Norway, Switzerland, France, Belgium, Portugal, Czech Republic, Russia, Luiz Felipe Scolari
 
Speakers' Corner #68 Responses
Jan 22, 2008 | 8:41PM | report this

Ringo - An easy one for you this week. Dundee can win the FA Cup  or Tayport can win the Junior cup. Which one do you take?

Bobby – Dundee has a slightly better chance of winning the Scottish Cup this season than Scotland does of winning the European Championship this summer. A trip to Motherwell in the next round might have the making of a wee surprise but the focus of the team must be on promotion back to the SPL.

Tayport drew at home to perennial contender Pollok (viewer discretion is advised) last Saturday and they travel to the west of Scotland for the replay this weekend. The Scottish Junior Cup is a tough nut to crack

Carljamaica - Greetings from Jamaica. Do you think this Manchester United team is as good as people are saying?  Do you think they are serious contenders for the Champions League meaning do you think they have what it takes? If not where do you think they are short. Is Ronaldo just going through a purple patch or is he really the real deal?
Awaiting your thoughts.

Bobby – Much warmer than where I am! United deserve to be considered as one of the favourites to win the Champions League. They have been given a decent draw (not easy but Lyon are a side that United can beat) but often a bit of good fortune is also needed along the way.

There is still a month to go before the first leg of the first knock out round and things can change very quickly. Injuries, suspensions and key players losing form can all hit at an inopportune moment. In terms of their most significant weakness it is probably a lack of height and power up front.

You can see in some of the league games this season that without that option it gives the opposition one less thing to worry about. Having a big strong forward on the bench that could go on just to mix things up a bit would provide that additional alternative.

Since Ronaldo joined United he has improved every season. If you look back at his play when he joined United in 2003 the raw talent was there for everyone to see. Four and a bit years on and every aspect of his game has improved – some parts by leaps and bounds.


Craigy_f1. Was Probert correct to book Arteta? Has a card ever been used in that situation that you are aware of?
2. Does the lack of ACoN on any American network show the ignorance of the American networks as to the value of the tournament in Ghana? 3. Was it omitted for the same reasons that the Asia tournament was omitted?
4. What’s your impression of Lord Coe?
5. What’s your:- Goal of the week, Save of the week, Game of the week, Referee of the moment.
6. Favourite clip from Flash Gordon
7. What was your take on the teams and the result for the USMNT against a Sweden B team?
8. Will you and the boys try some colour this week?

Bobby – 1. It seemed to be a strange decision. The only way that I could see the referee having a valid cause would be if he had told Arteta to wait for the whistle.

2. The value is set by the number of people who would watch the tournament and despite what we think soccer on English language stations in North America do not regularly draw big numbers. A tournament that has games scheduled during the work day is an obvious problem.

3. I don’t know the reason why the Asia tournament was omitted so I can’t answer the question.

4. He used to be a very fast runner and was able to turn left? You can’t hang-out at the upper echelons of global sport without being forced to hold your nose at the goings-on. If you decide to hold true to your principles at that level it means you will have a short and largely ineffective career in the political world of sport.

5. Sully Muntari’s winner against Guinea, can’t think of one, poor weekend nothing stood out, oops the moment just went.

6. The End

7. Meaningless friendly for all except for the players and coaches.

8. Probably not.

GSfromWinnipeg - How about opinions on possible rule changes? You can certainly throw in your two cents, as well as everyone else.Here are some of my thoughts:
1. Why do we need to get so fancy with goal-line technology. Chips in the ball? Come on. If you want to position cameras along the line, fine. But, why can't they just add a back-line official who is in charge of watching for balls crossing the line? He could also assist with fouls in the box. It seems to me this would satisfy the purists and be at least as effective as technology that often still doesn't answer the question 100%.

2. Get rid of this passive offside rule. It just adds to the confusion. Vassell's goal on Sunday was a perfect example. Since the ball does not go to him, is that the end of Phase 1? Then he is back onside by the time the ball ricochets to him, so that makes it a good goal. But this must be a nightmare for the linesmen. Especially when it seems standard practise for players to line up offside on deadball situations to try and confuse the defense. By the way, since you are supposed to play to the whistle, and, as a defender, a man is behind you heading for goal, therefore you have to make an attempt to catch him, pulling yourself out of position. But the ball never goes to that attacker so he is "passive" while the onside attacker takes advantage of the space left by the defender to score. How is this helping the game.

KEEP IT SIMPLE (which offside will never be). If anyone is offside, play is dead. Period.

3. NO TO SIN BINS. As Harry Redknapp says, that will just encourage 10 minutes of time-wasting and defensive play. Just what football needs, 10 more minutes of 10 men behind the ball.

4. 3 YELLOW CARDS BEFORE YOU GET A RED. Encourage the refs to hand out a yellow every time a foul deserves it. I think they often don't give a yellow, because they know how serious the ramifications a second yellow is. This leads to inconsistency. The good refs talk to a player first and warn him a yellow is coming next time, but we can get rid of that need. The "talking" will be the first yellow. This would especially be of use in internationals where language is often a problem.

Also, get rid of suspensions for accumulated yellows (or at least increase the number of yellows before suspension). This almost always ends up excluding the best players from the biggest games due to some idiotic decision by the player or the ref, three games ago. I am thinking of Roy Keane missing the Champions League final in 99, Ballack missing the 2002 World Cup final, Zidane missing a key match in the 98 Cup, etc.

5. GOLDEN GOAL IN TOURNAMENTS AND ENDLESS OVERTIME. I know, this is a pipe dream. But how about giving it a try. I agree with Bobby, penalty kicks is dramatic and a test of mettle and skill, but it isn't the game that was intended. I think overtime rarely works as is because at least one team plays for the penalty kicks, and both teams are so afraid of conceding, they hang back and trust to fate in the kicks. If there is no promise of penalty kicks,

Bobby – 1. Sign me up for that position. Six officials for a game of football? Don’t like that idea.

2. That’s fine make it simple but just wait and hear the cries when someone slots one home into the top corner from 35 yards out and the goal is disallowed because one of his team mates stopped to tie his bootlace and was offside on the other side of the park alone on the touchline.

3. Sin bins are one of the stupidest ideas to come out and until you brought it up again I thought it had died.

4. The language problem was the exact reason that coloured cards were brought in so now to have a mandatory “talking to” being a warning before a yellow card only compounds the problem. Players will just claim that they didn’t know they were on a warning.

Idiotic decisions - Zidane missed games in 1998 because he stomped on a Saudi player.  Your basic argument is that players should be given more leeway to foul. I don’t think that is going to encourage anyone to think twice about sliding in late.

5. I####ame goes to overtime the least that both teams deserve is the opportunity to fight back should they go behind. With the Golden Goal rule we would never had the likes of West Germany and Italy sharing five extra time goals in 1970 or France and West Germany playing an epic extra time in 1982.

Mts2284 - 1. Recently, a reader asked you about commentators and which ones you liked. What’s your take on BBC’s John Motson? I live in the States and don’t get BBC but I’m a huge fan. Just wanted your opinion on the matter.
2. Why have Thierry Henry or Premiership players like Cristiano Ronaldo not won the FIFA Player of the Year award? Its always players from Serie A and La Liga, like Messi, or Ronaldinho.
3. Why does Ryan Babel not feature more in Liverpool’s starting 11? He’s a fantastic talent with loads of potential.

Bobby –1. His biggest break came when Ronnie Radford thumped the 30 yard winner for Hereford against Newcastle in the FA Cup. I was never a huge fan (although there were many who were aweful)  when I lived in the UK – my preference would be for Martin Tyler.

2. I think basically because although they may have good domestic seasons they fail to make a real impact in the Champions League, European Championships or World Cup. Like Ronaldo I don’t think Messi has ever won a senior world or European individual award.
3. You probably nailed it with “loads of potential.” There are few teams willing to commit a regular spot to a player who is not considered the finished article although he may have potential. Having said that