We know it probably won't be as spirited a debate as the last Hall-of-Fame argument we moderated in this space. But Hall-of-Fame debates are always fun, even if they're not clouded by allegations of steroid use.

So with that in mind, we ask the question: Is Jeff Bagwell, who officially announced his retirement Friday after 15 seasons and 449 home runs, worthy of a spot in Cooperstown?

BAGWELL'S CAREER NUMBERS

SOUND OFF BELOW ...