Perhaps there is no bigger crap shoot in baseball than the first year player draft. It does not have the allure of the NFL draft, or the sexiness of the NBA draft, but rest assured, it is just as important. There are no crippling blows if the franchise quarterback does not pan out, but there certainly are monumental failures that can set a franchise back.
For the first time in the draft's history, a team will have back to back picks. The Tampa Bay Rays earned this dubious honor by ineptitude and poor fundamental play. Their farm system is incredibly deep already and the results have shown in the 2008 season.
The 2008 draft is different in many regards from the previous few seasons. For the first time in four years, there is no consensus number one pick and the decision is cloudy on who will be chosen number one overall. There are five premier players in this draft, all with superstar potential. Much like 2006, it might not become clear until a week before the draft who the choice will be. However, this creates suspense, allows for rampant disinformation and negates many possible wink wink deals that so often occur in baseball.
Tampa Bay must choose between need and want, talent or need and the battle of cost. In 2007, they showed no hesitance giving out an MLB deal to David Price. The rumored bonus demands of 2008 are sure to shape the draft in many ways. Talent will inevitably fall and good players will be chosen by good teams.
Many agree that this draft is lacking a lot of depth in the prep pitching ranks and some overall talent. However, that's not to say there aren't some bona fide superstars to come out of this draft.
With that, the Tampa Bay Rays are on the clock:
1. Tampa Bay Rays - Kyle Skipworth, C Patriot HS
Call this a hunch, but I have to go with this. The big rumor floating around scouting circles is that the Rays are enamored with Buster Posey. Their biggest organizational need is catcher, and there really aren't any players with as high of a ceiling as Skipworth in this draft. It's always risky choosing prep catchers in the draft. In fact, only two in the past two decades have moved on to become All-Stars, Joe Mauer and Mike Lieberthal. Skipworth possesses an excellent arm behind the plate and a very projectable bat. He might never hit more than 20 home runs, but will make up for it with a very high number of doubles. He does have some minor issues to work out, like footwork behind the plate, but that's easily corrected with solid instruction.
2. Pittsburgh Pirates - Tim Beckham, SS Griffin HS
Without a shadow of a doubt, Beckham is the most talented and toolsy player in the draft. Beckham very well could be a tough sign for the Pirates, but they've expressed willingness to spend money with Neil Huntingdon in charge. The rumors floating around are that they are looking to draft more high schoolers than in recent years, selecting a college arm in both 2006 and 2007. Beckham has a few question marks about translating his myriad of oozing tools into baseball ability. Beckham profiles at just a shade below BJ Upton and Brandon Phillips at a comparable age. He has 5 legit tools and has 30/30 ability. His baseball instincts are very good, but just needs some refinement on his fundamentals. Beckham has the arm and reaction time to remain at shortstop, however is athletic enough to handle a move to centerfield. Though with Andrew McCutchen in the fold, a move seems unlikely.
3. Kansas City Royals - Brian Matusz, LHP University of San Diego
The 2007 draft saw the Kansas City Royals balk at Rick Porcello's asking price when pitching was ways and away their biggest need. Undoubtedly Matusz will command similar money, but offer significantly less risk. Matusz is one of the few pitchers who was extremely good in high school and stayed that way through college. Matusz profiles as a legit number one starter to anchor the Royals' staff for years to come offering three plus pitches and an above average slider. His stay in the minors is likely to be a very short one, perhaps even making his season debut in the number 5 spot of the Royals' 2009 rotation. His spring has been slightly inconsistent, but many college pitchers featuring a plus changeup are hit harder in college because of the bat speed generated by aluminum. Matusz compares favorably to Roy Halladay and Cole Hamels, which will definitely boost the Royals' rotation.
4. Baltimore Orioles -Gordon Beckham, SS Georgia
Beckham has legit power and flashes it by leading all of
Division 1 in homers. His defense is average at best, but is passable,
especially with the natural advantage of his bat at a premium position.
Beckham compares favorably to a young Nomar Garciaparra with the same skill set. It's not out of the realm of possibility to imagine both Beckham and Wieters as the 3 and 4 hitters as early as the All-Star break of 2009.
5. San Francisco Giants - Pedro Alvarez, 3B Vanderbilt
The Giants have shown that they are not afraid to deal with Scott Boras
and Boras' insane contract demands. In selecting Alvarez, the Giants
are able to select the most complete and polished bat in the class at a
major position of need. Many scouts question if Alvarez can stay at
third base at the highest level, but with uber prospect Angel Villalona
moved to first, he will stay at third based solely on need and
organizational depth. Alvarez has hit for power and average across
every level in which he has played and more importantly has had the
spotlight on him for two full seasons and has more than lived up to the
hype and embraced the superstar potential that he possesses. While many
scouts feel that Alvarez lacks the necessary contact skills to be a 300
hitter in the bigs, he compares favorably to other elite third basemen
in recent years. With these lofty expectations and a major offensive
void left by Barry Bonds, Alvarez should fit right in. As an added
bonus, Alvarez has always been loved and with Brian Sabean putting a premium on character and niceness post Bonds, this seems like a match made in heaven.
6. Florida Marlins - Buster Posey, C Florida State
Posey has climbed draft boards almost as fast as his prep counterpart in Kyle Skipworth. He has received serious consideration for the number one overall pick. Posey offers a very complete set of tools from behind the plate, but might only be slightly above average in the majors. He should hit for contact, but his power numbers will fall to earth and be severely deflated by the Giants' home park. However, Posey will play gold glove defense while fluctuating from year to year in the mid 280's up to the low 300's and getting on base. Immediately upon being drafted, Posey will be the Marlins' best hitting prospect.
7. Cincinnati Reds - Tanner Scheppers, RHP Fresno
Other than Skipworth, no player has shot up draft boards faster than Tanner Scheppers. Scheppers features a dominant fastball that touches the high 90's with an absolutely filthy slider that is nearly unhittable. Scheppers also throws a 11-5 power curve and a developing change, but with his relative inexperience, it's to be expected. At worst, Scheppers is the next Brad Lidge while at best, he is a front line starter. Scheppers has shown the ability to strikeout batters while managing reasonable groundball/flyball splits that will seriously help him in Great American. New general manager Walt Jocketty has shown an affinity for selecting college arms and not breaking slot; Scheppers will fit both molds.
8. Chicago White Sox - Aaron Crow, RHP Missouri
What don't the White Sox need? Their farm system is ways and away the worst in baseball and Ken Williams continues to mortgage the future for the present. In Crow, the White Sox get arguably the best pitcher in the draft who is going to command an awful lot of money. The White Sox' brass has shown a willingness to spend money, though rarely breaks slot. Crow has demonstrated excellent command as evidenced by his 43 inning scoreless streak. There are some mechanical issues that any team selecting Crow has to hope won't result in injury. However, his fastball/breaking ball combination would definitely play well in the AL Central and his fastball is big league ready now topping out at 98 mph.
9. Washington Nationals -Shooter Hunt, RHP Tulane
Hunt has catapulted himself into the top 10 with an absolutely
dominating spring showing increased velocity and most of all, improved
command. Hunt is flatly a strikeout pitcher, something the Nationals
definitely need. His command still needs some refinement and he'll
never be in the top 25 in walks, but offsets it with his pure
dominance. His strikeout to walk ratio will compare to Carlos Zambrano's, but simply enough to dominate a game.
10. Houston Astros - Tim Melville, RHP Holt HS
Coming into the season, Melville was a top 5 pick, but his velocity has been really down and many are wondering if he's a candidate for Tommy John surgery. Also, being a prep pitcher in 2008 really is working against many players as this is an absolutely atrocious class. If Melville returns to form, he projects as a true number one starter with a mid 90's fastball, two breaking pitches and a surprisingly well developed changeup. If fully healthy, Melville would have slot just below Porcello and Bumgarner and ahead of Parker in the 2007 draft. His bat should surprise a few people, especially pitching in Minute Maid park.
11. Texas Rangers - Justin Smoak, 1B University of South Carolina
Coming into the season, it'd have been nearly impossible to envision Smoak falling out of the top 5, let alone almost the top 10. Smoak's season has been disappointing but switch hitting first basemen with 40 home run potential are few and far between. The Rangers really have helped reload their farm system over the past two years, and Smoak is another integral piece. Smoak will help remind Rangers fans of their last switch hitting first basemen--Mark Teixeira.
12. Oakland Athletics - Eric Hosmer, 1B American Heritage HS
Hosmer fills not only an organizational need, but also he is without a doubt the top player on the board here. He profiles as a middle of the order slugger with a plus glove and a plus-plus arm. He is eerily reminiscent of Casey Kotchman and Adrian Gonzalez at the similar age, offering a comparable offensive and defensive skill set. He possesses the type of bat that can change games in a heartbeat. His eye at the plate is comparable to a college senior rather than a high school senior. His bat speed generated is absolutely ridiculous. It'll be a tough sign for Beane, but Hosmer is worth it. Adviser Scott Boras is said to be looking for a $7 million big league deal and if that's the case, Hosmer will undoubtedly fall much lower. Beane regularly goes college, but Hosmer is the closest can't miss high school prospect in quite some time.
13. St Louis Cardinals - Yonder Alonso 1B, University of Miami
Seldom do the Cardinals take risks in the first round, though with Alonso still on the board, it has to be done. Alonso's bat provides a smooth and easy left handed swing with prototypical doubles and home run power. The Cardinals will run into the problem on where to play Alonso as Albert Pujols is currently occupying first base and he won't be moving anywhere any time soon. Alonso has been tried in the outfield but has been only average there. With the correct coaching, he should be able to slide right into left field and the middle of the order. His approach is smooth and easy and he is never afraid to take a walk.
14. Minneosta Twins - Brett Wallace, 3B Arizona State
There are questions whether the Twins truly get it or not, often going for signability, batting average and raw tools while ignoring many baseball skills. Wallace has shifted to third base this season and has looked surprisingly good there, and could stick at third in the bigs. He will take walks, hit for power and get on base. Something the Twins will definitely be enamored with is that Wallace is almost assuredly willing to sign for slot or right below.
15. Los Angeles Dodgers - Gerrit Cole, RHP Orange Lutheran HS
It's no secret that the Dodgers love prep arms and Cole is arguably the top one in the class. However, Cole has an awful lot of negatives going against him, much like Kyle Drabek. Cole's mechanics are terrible, he is being advised by Scott Boras and he's as likely to strike someone out as he is throw at their head and spit on them. However, he is a local kid and the Dodgers tend to lock on a select few high school arms and move from there. They've gone prep pitcher every year since 2002, sans 05 where they lacked a first round pick. If Cole pans out, this is going to be a steal.
16. Milwaukee Brewers - Josh Fields, RHP Georgia
It is no secret that Milwaukee is in a win now mode, and Fields certainly helps fit that bill. Eric Gagne looks like a disaster closing games for the Brewers and Fields could have the job by September. The Brewers again go with a college senior, erasing almost any and all signability concerns. Fields throws in the upper 90's with a nasty slider that is a flat out strikeout pitch.
17. Toronto Blue Jays - Christian Friedrich, LHP Eastern Kentucky
The Jays almost always go college arm and this year should be no different. Friedrich has a smooth delivery and should be able to move extremely quickly through the Jays' system. He has a dominant 12-6curveball that looks a lot like Rich Hill's and Barry Zito's and offsets it with a solid fastball with a lot of movement. He isn't going to be a top flight starter, but he will fill in very nicely behind Roy Halladay and perhaps split he and Burnett.
18. New York Mets - Ethan Martin, RHP/3b Stephens County HS
The Mets have said publicly that they plan to start spending more in the draft, and the natural thought is that they plan to start breaking slot for high school players. Martin has long been considered a power hitting third basemen, but when he stepped on the mound his future became very clear. He throws in the upper 90's with surprisingly good breaking stuff and a very good changeup. His slurve is a definite two planer, which really will make a world of difference against wood where bat speed is negated.
19. Chicago Cubs - Aaron Hicks, RHP/OF Woodrow Wilson HS
The skills are there, the only question mark on Hicks is where they should play him. From the mound, he has a mid 90's fastball and a power curve that comes in dancing in the upper 80's. From the outfield, he is a bona fide 5 tool prospect, very reminiscent of Andre Dawson. He has a cannon for an arm from centerfield and has plus-plus speed which projects him to a 30 steal per season player. The Cubs will have to be patient with him and determine which position is best for him, and not bail if he struggles.
20. Seattle Mariners - Conor Gillaspie, 3B Wichita State
Gillaspie is a prototypical left handed third basemen with an easy swing and natural power. His main question is whether he can stay at third. His swing is very smooth and easy and will project to very high doubles totals in Safeco. The Mariners tend to go college, so this almost makes too much sense. Gillaspie should be the starting third basemen in Seattle the second Adrian Beltre's contract expires.
21. Detroit Tigers - Kyle Lobstein, LHP Coconino HS
Having completely emptied the farm system, sans Rick Porcello, the Tigers go to the high school ranks to help give organizational depth and a potential number 2 starter. Lobstein does not have overwhelming stuff, but definitely makes up for it with plus command and control. His fastball is in the upper 80's to low 90's,with a very nasty curveball and a developing, yet solid change. His total package is reminiscent of Barry Zito, especially his loose and repeatable delivery.
22. New York Mets -Brett DeVall, LHP Rutherford HS
The Mets go prep arm again in an attempt to rebuild an aging rotation. Devall is a textbook left handed pitcher with a fastball in the high 80's to low 90's with excellent movement and great command of an arsenal of breaking pitches. DeVall has competed on the highest levels and has maintained an even keel, something that is important in ultra competitive NL East. He should reach the majors very early and have success, despite mediocre peripherals. However, his command should allow him to be successful, much like Tom Glavine.
23. San Diego Padres - Tyson Ross, RHP University of California
The Padres usually go the college route and this year should be no different. Ross has befuddled many scouts and there is not a consensus opinion on his ability orprojectability . Despite his size, he lacks intense velocity and pitches like a stereotypical left handed crafty veteran. He will need some considerable refinement on his mechanics and overall pitching prowess. However, the skill is there and with mechanical refinement, an extra 3-5 mph on his fastball seems possible. He is a 3-4 year project, with incredible risk versus reward outcomes.
24. Philadelphia Phillies - Alex Meyer, RHP Greensburg HS
The Phillies regularly go with a high school arm and Meyer is an absolute monster on the mound standing at 6'7" and he should fill out to about a lean 230 pounds. Meyer commands a fastball in the low to mid 90's with an absolutely devastating slider. His changeup, like many high schoolers, is raw, but is there. His size suggests durability as he has been a workhouse in his high school days. He has legit ace potential.
25. Colorado Rockies - Brett Hunter, RHP Pepperdine
The Rockies routinely go with a college arm, having gone that direction the past two seasons. Hunter profiles as either a number 2 starter or dominant closer. He has a high effort delivery but amazing results, comparable to Tim Lincecum. His mid 90's heater is accentuated by a filthy and sharp slider. He might take longer than most college righties as he has been moved around by Pepperdine.
26. Arizona Diamondbacks - Lance Lynn, RHP Mississippi
Lynn doesn't have dominating stuff, but does offer projectability at a position of need. He is a textbook college pitcher with above average command and intangibles. With Arizona having given up quite a few of its pitching prospects to acquire Dan Haren, it is no secret that they need some serious upgrades. 2006 first rounder Max Scherzer looks destined for the bullpen as many predicted, and 2007 first rounder Jarrod Parker is still two years away. Lynn is a prospect who should move quickly through the minors and help the Diamondbacks sooner rather than later.
27. Minnesota Twins - Dennis Raben, OF Miami
Raben is a pretty sure bet to be a solid, yet unspectacular player in the bigs. He'll hit for average, some power and play solid defense and most of all, should sign for slot or slightly below. On a loaded team, only Yonder Alonso has stood out more than Raben. There is a very good chance that he will not be around this low, but if the draft shapes out this way, it's to be expected.
28. New York Yankees - Isaac Galloway, OF Los Osos HS
If Galloway is still around this low, it's only because of signability. The Yankees are not afraid to flex their financial muscles. Galloway is a true 5 tool prospect, with emphasis on tools. He is an incredibly fluid athlete with an amazing power and speed combo. The Yankees will have to be patient with him as there are holes in his swing, but the reward seems worth the risk. His final position will likely be right field where his power arm can be utilized fully. The Yankees' system is lacking premium offensive talent. Former over hyped prospect Jose Tabata has really struggled and was recently suspended and the rumor is floating that he has asked for his release. Austin Jackson profiles as a lead off hitter and centerfielder and has been markedly over hyped in his own regard. The Yankees' hype machine can continue to roll.
29. Cleveland Indians - Jarret Martin, LHP Centennial HS
Another very late riser, Martin throws a low 90's fastball with very solid changeup and a slow curve. For a high school pitcher, he is extremely polished and could easily reach the show faster than some of his high school counterparts. If he can improve his velocity by perhaps 2-3 mph, dominance is possible. His three pitches are reminiscent of a very raw Cole Hamels, which in itself is a daunting reputation to live up to.
30. Boston Red Sox - Trey Haley, RHP Central Heights HS
Haley has shown a very repeatably smooth delivery with a mid 90's fastball and late breaking hammer curveball. He is tall and has the typical pitchers body. Haley has really come on as of late and has moved from a third round pick to possible late first, or sandwich picks. He has drawn comparisons to Clay Buchholz in stature and raw stuff.
Stay tuned for the supplemental round and draft notes in the next few days.