I'll admit Andy Pettitte has always been a favorite of mine. A first class person and professional who personafies excellence. Which is why the Yankees as A-Rod did to them, must go to Andy's doorstep and get on their knees and beg for him to come back to the Yankees.

If there's one lefty hurler the Yanks should focus their immediate attention on, that won't cost them as much money or any prized prospects it's Pettitte. Thus with virtually every other Yankee being brought back and given a pay raise, there's no reason why the Yanks can't do the same for Pettitte. If it means giving him $20 million + with an option an a "Roger Clemens family plan," then do it!
Granted the Yankees have stressed the importance of wanting, needing and having Pettitte in their rotation but one would think they would like to add an extra incentive to one of their own homegrown winners, a "true Yankee."
Pettitte is a proven winner in New York, in the playoffs and in the clubhouse. Pettitte is also a gamer, the ultimate stopper and would be an invaluable asset in mentoring the Yankees young trio of Joba Chamberlain, Phil Hughes and Ian Kennedy. Plus Pettitte is a lefty, the Yankees haven't won a World Series without a lefty in their rotation since 1958.
If not for poor run support and a shaky bullpen in the early going, Pettitte easily could've won 20+ games last season and won 15 as it was. Pettitte also threw over 215 innings, his most in the Bronx since 1998. With 14 playoff wins and 4 rings, one cannot begin to stress the importance of bringing back # 46.

When pitching ace Jimmy Key went down in 1995 a rookie by the name of Andy Pettitte stepped up and won 12 games. In 1996 when another ace David Cone went down, Pettitte answered the call and won an AL best 21 games finishing 2nd in Cy Young voting. In the 2004 ALCS when the Yankees basically had no game 7 starter, they then realized how much it hurt and how badly they needed Pettitte. If only for one more year, please come back Andy!
Pay Pettitte or regret it.
Super Star