With eight days remaing until the trade deadline, the most sought after player in all of basketball is...Kelvin Cato? The rarely used reserve center (and his expiring $8.6MM contract) has made the Orlando Magic the NBA's most attractive trading partner. At the moment, the Magic have two offers on the table that are difficult to turn down, but only one can be executed.
OFFER # 1: New York Knicks
To Orlando:
SG/PG Jamal Crawford (signed thru 2011 for a total of $49.68MM--$6.48MM currently)
SG/PG Penny Hardaway (expiring $15.75MM contract)
One of:
PG Nate Robinson (rookie contract of $1.2MM)
PF David Lee (rookie contract of $860K)
SF Trevor Ariza ($640K, expiring)
From Orlando:
PG Steve Francis (owed $62.46MM thru 2009 -- $13.77MM currently)
C Kelvin Cato (expiring $8.6MM)
Why would Orlando choose this deal?
The bigger question is why New York is the one making this offer. Or another question, is Isiah Thomas mentally handicapped? I wrote in an earlier blog entry that the Knicks should do whatever they could to rid themselves of Stephon Marbury, who drags the team down with his selfish play and has a suffocating contract. Instead, Thomas is trying to go the opposite direction and is looking to acquire Marbury's doppelganger from Orlando. The tandem of Francis and Marbury would put two undersized shooting guards (masquerading as point guards) on the floor at the same time, and there are not enough basketballs in the Big Apple to satisfy those two. In return, Thomas is offering a tall point guard who has the most reasonable (with "reasonable" being a relative term) contract of any player Isiah has acquired, one of his promising young players, and one player who was finally going to be out of the Knicks cap hell at seasons end.
Orlando would choose this deal in preperating for the summer of 2007. Getting rid of their two largest contracts, and with the deal of Grant Hill expiring after next season, the Magic will be way under the cap for the 2007 free agent class. By all expectations, there should be many promising targets that Summer and Orlando could be the prime location ready to woo them.
Aside from the cap flexibility, the Magic get one, maybe two starters out of the deal who can be built around. Their best case scenario in this offer is Trevor Ariza (the Magic should get Fran Vazquez from Spain for next season making Lee unnecessary, and Nate Robinson is 5'7" tall). Assuming that is the finalized deal, their depth chart could look like this:
PG - Jameer Nelson / Keyon Dooling
SG - Jamal Crawford / DeShawn Stevenson
SF - Grant Hill / Hedyet Turkoglu / Trevor Ariza
PF - Dwight Howard / Pat Garrity
C - Tony Battie / Mario Kasun
Surely that is not a team that can win now, but that actually could help them in the long run. Unlike offer # 2, the Magic keep their 1st round pick for this season and losing more would improve the draft position. Then, of course, Fran Vazquez (last year's first round pick) will reinforce the squallid front court, and they can make a push for another impact player in the 2007 free agent class.
OFFER # 2: Detroit Pistons
To Orlando:
C/PF Darko Milicic (signed thru 2007 for $9.35MM -- $4.14MM currently)
PG Carlos Arroyo (signed thru 2008 for $12MM -- $4MM annually)
From Orlando:
C Kelvin Cato
1st Round Draft Pick
Why would Orlando choose this offer?
According to multiple sources, Orlando has actually been the one to make this offer and they have done so on multiple occasions. An ESPN article suggests this deal is on the verge of happening with the only hang up being how much lottery protection the Magic would receive on the pick. Considering how weak this year's draft is considered to be, the Magic should be generous with their requests. If they do not get into the top 3 to 5, they can likely do better with their 2007 pick.
Giving up basically nothing, this deal would be great for the Magic. While Milicic would be the most focused on portion of the trade, Carlos Arroyo is actually a really good point guard and has a reasonable contract. Remember, Arroyo was often the best player on a surprising Utah Jazz team that just missed out on the playoffs the year after John Stockton retired and Karl Malone left for the Lakers.
As for Milicic, he needs an opportunity to prove himself. Buried in the Pistons depth chart, he has never had a chance to show the promise that made him a second overall pick in a draft that included Lebron James, Carmelo Anthony, Dwayne Wade, Chris Bosh, Kirk Hinrich, and several other players that have made a huge splash for their teams. This is not to say that Darko can be written off as a bust, yet. The Pistons were only in the position to draft him because of a decade old trade, and not because they were a rebuilding team. Quite the opposite, in fact. Darko has a championship ring from his rookie season when he sat behind veterans Ben Wallace, Rasheed Wallace, and Corliss Williamson. Since then, the Pistons have actually upgraded the positions Darko is challenging to play by acquiring a former Dream Team player in Antonio McDyess. So, it is no surprise that the Pistons have not allowed him to learn on the fly while they try to win championships.
A team like Orlando can use him, though. Outside of Dwight Howard, their frontcourt is weak and they can give Milicic valuable minutes. In return, the young (he cannot legally drink in this country until June of this year) seven footer could pair with Howard to give the Magic twin towers to build on.
Should offer # 2 be the direction Orlando goes, their depth chart may look like this:
PG: Carlos Arroyo / Jameer Nelson / Keyon Dooling
SG: Steve Francis / DeShawn Stevenson
SF: Grant Hill / Hidyet Tukoglu
PF: Dwight Howard / Pat Garrity
C: Darko Milicic / Tony Battie / Mario Kasun
Again, not a team that can win immediately. Getting Francis off of the point, though, could work wonders from the beginning. Then, next season, with Vazquez's arrival, the Magic could make a challenge for the playoffs.